m*******d
发帖数: 45 | 1 Editor的意思是？
文科一journal的Editor发信来：
The reviewers want to see some revisions made to your manuscript before
publication.
然后invite you to respond to the reviewers' comments and revise your
manuscript.
这个听起来很postive了吧？感觉只要改了就接收了？（在submission system里面显示
是Major Revision)
之前另一篇文章第一轮的时候这个editor是明确rejection的，虽然可以R&R.
What do you think? |
|
w*********g
发帖数: 813 | 2 看到好多同胞都是某某journal的editor,guest-editor什么的。请问怎么才能拿到一个
editor title 当当呢？有什么渠道吗？请指点，谢谢！ |
|
b********y
发帖数: 891 | 3 二/三流杂志。
第一轮referees' reports很好，editor的信也很friendly,只要求一些minor revision.
revision submitted之后，我和co-author（比较有名的senior professor)都很有信心。
没想到昨天收到final decision,让人大跌眼镜。
editor突然又请了第三个referee,说因为原先两个referee对我们的方向不熟。
第三个referee的reports无比的差，从literature review,到experiment design,到
methodology,到analysis,到results,全被批的体无完肤。
editor的于是给的final decision是，rejection.
但是最后他说，
Although this is not the result you were perhaps hoping for, you do have
some comments that will help you revise the paper for an audience in... 阅读全帖 |
|
r*t
发帖数: 309 | 4 收到一个邀请，从爱尔兰来的，要我做new journal Editor。 有点纠结，征求大家意
见要不要做。 头两年做事没有报酬。。第3年说可以给10% processing charges.
"Because the journal will not have revenues in the first two years, while
the publisher will have to cover the costs of above listed and other
publishing solutions and services, we do not plan any remuneration for the
Journal Editor in the first two years. In the following years, the Journal
Editor will receive 10% of Article Processing Charges received by Versita
for accepted articles." |
|
S**********l
发帖数: 3835 | 5 最近跟人合作的一篇paper，不要太倒霉，投到A杂志，遇到某editor，说不给审，换了
B杂志，竟然又碰到这个editor，说不给审。现在考虑C杂志，竟然发现editor还是这个
人。。。。。。这可咋办呢。。。 |
|
n******v
发帖数: 2184 | 6 你换个这个人不做editor的journal。这个人做三个journal的editor，是不是退休不做
research只做editor了？ |
|
x********5
发帖数: 131 | 7 第一篇稿子，感觉Editor直接决定发了, 就没有再等其他的 Reviewer的Comments 也没
有把改的稿子再给第一个Reviwer看。
第二篇稿子， 我是递上改稿之后等了一个星期， online status 一直是 with
Editor, 就发了封信询问：
Dear Dr.***,
I wonder what is the current status of our revised manuscript to **** (
Journal) - **** (Paper + Assigned number). Thank you very much!
Sincerely yours,
****
过了3-4天， Editor直接回信接收。 |
|
k**g
发帖数: 1558 | 8 我用过的好的editor还是稍微看一下逻辑的。我先用过一个便宜的Editor 基本没有改
啥,因为没有什么语法错误, 还狂说我英文好。结果被那个好的editor改了很多, 主要
改的就是flow, 其实就是要读上去顺口。比如说我喜欢用however, but 等, 虽然用起
来没有错,但是整个文章的flow就很差。 |
|
k**g
发帖数: 1558 | 9 我用过的好的editor还是稍微看一下逻辑的。我先用过一个便宜的Editor 基本没有改
啥,因为没有什么语法错误, 还狂说我英文好。结果被那个好的editor改了很多, 主要
改的就是flow, 其实就是要读上去顺口。比如说我喜欢用however, but 等, 虽然用起
来没有错,但是整个文章的flow就很差。 |
|
b**********s
发帖数: 73 | 10 我是商学院rookie，有一篇独立的文章在领域的top journal revise and resubmit。
从上一轮开始referee一直纠结我的英文写作能力，并明确要求找个copy editor帮我修
改。其实我每轮都找，到现在已经花了2k刀在这上面了，但是一直没有改到referee满
意的程度。这一轮刚收到report，referee很气愤，甚至质疑我根本没有找copy editor
，言辞非常激烈。
不知道各位大大能否推荐一位经管类靠谱的copy editor？ |
|
n*****t
发帖数: 1015 | 11 这个领域最好的杂志回应了我交上的文章。本来很寄希望这个editor，因为他是这个领
域的大牛，技术比较强。但他给我的回信comments就基本是把referee的话重复一遍，
也就是说他连我文章里的methodology都没懂怎么回事，更别说contribution了，也就
是说他其实都懒得看我的文章，随便给了一个根本啥都不懂的referee对我的文章胡说八
道一通就把我打发了。如果editor看了我的introduction，都应该知道referee对我
methodology的攻击是完全错误的。这个referee的report里，把我的modology是完全没
看懂，攻击的是莫名其妙，甚至我明明说跟另外一篇文章的结果一致，他却问我为什么
用同样的数据得到不同的结果！对我的文章结果却没有任何comment。最让我无语的是
连这个领域是个人都该知道的一些基本概念他都不知道，竟然质问我为什么那么做。所
以，我猜这个referee不仅是个junior，可能要么不是真做我们这个领域的，要么可能
是个还没学明白的博士学生。哎，我自己也是无名的junior，花那么大精力写个文章就
这么被草菅人命... 阅读全帖 |
|
D******n
发帖数: 2965 | 12 哎，象你这样估计不仅是出身名校，还是牛老板的学校，所以和editor argue 和玩似
的。如果信访对大部分人都管用的话，editor 还不忙死。当然，也有可能你是science
或数学方向的，主编更客观一些，容易argue一些。
editor
2 |
|
w*****n
发帖数: 128 | 13
谢谢。 有人反对那是一定的，否则就接受了。
大家有经验能帮忙看看editor consult 些什么呢？是reviewer反对的理由不够清晰么
？不够充分？曾经做过editor的老板或经验多的老板能帮忙分析editor的立场么？谢谢
。 |
|
z****s
发帖数: 1760 | 14 平时积极为期刊审稿，高质量的审稿，主编或副主编说不定哪天需要找Editor的时候就
想起你来了。当然如果已经在那期刊发过文章那更好。
也可以自己发信给主编自荐，但是如果在领域里还没有啥名气，而且审稿记录比较少的
话，成功率会比较小。建议先用 Publons.com 积累审稿记录。
多发高质量的文章，强大自己，慢慢就会有主编看上你了！
[在 AnthonyGe (AnthonyGe) 的大作中提到：]
:请问各位faculty,怎么才能成为杂志的Editor或Associate Editor之类的，如果联系
妥当？不指望能做什么好杂志，想从小的烂的开始。当过审稿人，但还想提高一下。 |
|
r*********e
发帖数: 80 | 15 Managing Editor, Radiation Detection Technology &Methods
Location: Beijing, China
站内回信可内推.
Do you have a passion for physics and its applications, and a desire to
explore beyond your own field of research? Do you want to enable scientists
from around the world to communicate their work to their peers? Do you want
to work at the heart of the scientific community in China, one of the world
’s biggest investors in scientific research?
Radiation Detection Technology & Methods is a new,interdisciplin... 阅读全帖 |
|
m******n
发帖数: 5 | 16 Medjaden (www.medjaden.com) is a company that provides professional editing/
consulting services to laboratory researchers, post-graduates and clinical
doctors publishing in biomedical journals. Our mission is to help the
researchers get their valuable research work published in an internationally
recognized scientific journal in English. Our staff has extensive
experience in reviewing, writing and editing biomedical manuscripts and
biostatistical analysis. We also aim to ensure that every manus... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 17 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 18 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 19 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 20 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 21 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 22 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 23 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 24 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 25 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 26 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 27 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 28 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 29 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 30 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 31 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 32 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 33 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
g*********e
发帖数: 14401 | 34 Dealsea is looking for Deal Editors
›Other dealsea.com coupon codes & deals
›(1 comments)
Dealsea is looking for Deal Editors / Senior Deal Editors.
Responsibilities:
Research and identify new deal / coupon opportunities
Edit deals / coupons from draft
Collaborate and negotiate with managers from merchant marketing department
to prepare good deals that favour our visitors
Qualifications:
Passionate Deal Seeker
Interest in research on shopping/latest trends
Good writing skills
Good co... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 35 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 36 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 37 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
t**j
发帖数: 198 | 38 【 以下文字转载自 Biology 讨论区 】
发信人: tyhj (tyhj), 信区: Biology
标 题: 投稿如果最后被接受， editor会通知审稿人吗
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Mon Jun 13 04:22:13 2011, 美东)
不知名的审稿人为我的破文章出了不少力， 最后文章被editor 接受了。
editor 电子邮件通知的我， 他一般会把这个消息也告诉审稿人吗
有审稿经验的人说一下 |
|
J******o
发帖数: 6 | 39 杂志 Drug Target Insights is looking for 4 个 guest editor, 每个editor 需要
征集5篇PAPER， topics 是关于 Gene Therapy and Proteomics. 有兴趣的junior
scientists 留下email. 对申请EB1A有帮助。我是lead guest editor, 也是为了申请
绿卡用才做的。大家互相帮忙. |
|
f**********n
发帖数: 9 | 40 本人有机会给某个期刊推荐10+个Review Editor，也就是审稿人。期刊是Frontiers in
Materials （carbon－based materials section），是个open－access期刊，目前还
没有影响因子。该系列的其它期刊影响因子在2-5之间。大家可以自己Google。
这个期刊的Review Editor（审稿人）也在其Editorial board里面，每个Review
editor都可以在其网站上建立自己的Profile。
感兴趣的朋友请和本人联系，并附上简短的CV。注意：不能保证马上就有审稿机会。 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 41 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 42 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 43 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 44 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 45 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 46 part time editors in need!
BiomedWorld is an editing company established to help international
biomedical researchers eliminate language barriers and get their work
recognized and published in prestigious peer-reviewed journals.
With the growth of the company, we have experiencing increasing
amount
of requests for editing biomedical manuscripts from both basic researchers
and clinicians. We are now recruiting freelance or part-time editors who
are
experienced in editing biomedical manuscr... 阅读全帖 |
|
f**********n
发帖数: 9 | 47 本人有机会给某个期刊推荐10+个Review Editor，也就是审稿人。期刊是Frontiers in
Materials （carbon－based materials section），是个open－access期刊，目前还
没有影响因子。该系列的其它期刊影响因子在2-5之间。大家可以自己Google。
这个期刊的Review Editor（审稿人）也在其Editorial board里面，每个Review
editor都可以在其网站上建立自己的Profile。
感兴趣的朋友请和本人联系，并附上简短的CV。注意：不能保证马上就有审稿机会。 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 48 现杂志招募2～3名guest editor，有兴趣的朋友请私信！谢谢！
Journal:
Breast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research
Benefits for Guest Editors:
1. Recognition on the journal’s editorial board webpage and in the
editorial
2. The opportunity to publish your own papers in a high visibility Pubmed
indexed journal
3. Cultivate editorial experience
4. Collaborate with leading scholars working in the subject area.
Roles:
1. solicit 4～5 papers.
2. able to submit a paper of your own, which if accepted for publication by
the editor ... 阅读全帖 |
|
p****t
发帖数: 452 | 49 从版上学到找editor要review的方法，给各个editor写信，有几个回了，要我review
paper，但
由于是我自己主动提出的，editor的信里常常能看出来，不知各位大侠是怎么处理的？
谢谢！ |
|
p*******8
发帖数: 98 | 50 请问向我review过文章的杂志editor要推荐信，是找editor-in-chief要好呢，还是向
找我review文章的editor要好？谢谢！ |
|
