w*******n
发帖数: 4188 | 1 Recently I got one piece from Haebler's collection of
Mozart's piano sonata.
That is really wonderful.I have only heard several pieces
from the whole collection
by Lipatti,Kempff, Haskil,Uchida.It is said the whole set of
Uchida is also great.
I am not sure which set I should buy.Asking for suggestion. |
|
a*****a
发帖数: 112 | 2 It is a great pity that you overlooked one of the greatest
interpretation of Mozart's piano sonatas, namely that by
Walter Gieseking. EMI has on catalog one 8-CD album of
Gieseking playing complete solo piano works of Mozart. If
you don't mind mono recording, I think this is the best one.
Although a famous Mozartian as she is, Haebler seems to have
left no recording not having been surpassed. Uchida's
version is quite reliable (and good in recording quality),
if not very instructive. And compare |
|
w*******n
发帖数: 4188 | 3 Now please allow me to talk briefly about my feeling of some other players I
know.
Haebler and Uchida are fine. Haebler's sound is really great, very crispy,
tempo is not that good, but still OK. I just got one piece of Uchida, not
good, not bad either, plus I heard so many bad things about her playing, I
give her up. I do think, Haebler is at least slightly better than Uchida.
I got a complete Gieseking playing Mozart solo works, not just sonatas, 8 CDS
from EMI. Because I have bought his compl |
|
j***k
发帖数: 2719 | 4 MOZART小提琴奏鸣曲是我经常放给我女儿听的录音之一。曲调优美，最重要是简单而且
有MOZART的东西里最具代表性的天真快乐。非常适合小孩子听。
MOZART小提琴奏鸣曲的版本巨多。几乎有录音以来所有的小提琴家都会录上一套
。我一套黑胶和两套CD。
那套黑胶和一套CD其实是一个录音，都是谢森（HENRYK SZERYNG）和INGRID HAEBLER在
７０年代（？）PHILIPS的录音。SZERYNG的录音我基本上见到一套就买一套，他的
EXECUTION非常干净，尽量保持原汁原味，非常对老衲的胃口。HAEBLER的钢琴是温柔的
一派，很低调更好体现了小提琴的魅力。对于这个版本，基本没有任何不满意的地方。
每次听都会心情好。
录音是PHILIPS，和所有那个时代的PHILIPS室内乐的录音一样，自然清晰，有血有肉。
无可挑剔。
音质上当然是黑胶的更好！可是７０年代的老东西了，基本就是过年过节才舍得拿出来
听一次，其他时候就听硬盘刻录的CD版本了。好在，这个CD虽然是PHILIPS的廉价版本
，但质量也不错。重新混音和转换的时候，好像没有听出加了任何人工味精，很难得。
一共两盘小双... 阅读全帖 |
|
L*****k
发帖数: 13042 | 5 发信人: jwalk (jwalk), 信区: HiFi
标 题: WEEK １：群众喜闻乐见的MOZART小提琴奏鸣曲的版本比较
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Tue Jan 3 13:04:41 2012, 美东)
MOZART小提琴奏鸣曲是我经常放给我女儿听的录音之一。曲调优美，最重要是简单而且
有MOZART的东西里最具代表性的天真快乐。非常适合小孩子听。
MOZART小提琴奏鸣曲的版本巨多。几乎有录音以来所有的小提琴家都会录上一套
。我一套黑胶和两套CD。
那套黑胶和一套CD其实是一个录音，都是谢森（HENRYK SZERYNG）和INGRID HAEBLER在
７０年代（？）PHILIPS的录音。SZERYNG的录音我基本上见到一套就买一套，他的
EXECUTION非常干净，尽量保持原汁原味，非常对老衲的胃口。HAEBLER的钢琴是温柔的
一派，很低调更好体现了小提琴的魅力。对于这个版本，基本没有任何不满意的地方。
每次听都会心情好。
录音是PHILIPS，和所有那个时代的PHILIPS室内乐的录音一样，自然清晰，有血有肉。
无可挑剔。
音质上当然是黑胶的更好！可是７... 阅读全帖 |
|
a****t
发帖数: 720 | 6 另外，对于fan uchida的人来说，她的mozart钢协27也值得期待。
只是我个人不喜欢uchida，尤其把她和haebler相比之后，再也没
听过uchida了。
客观上上，她还是有很多企鹅三星的。 |
|
