x****n
发帖数: 2149 | 1 在interview里，JKR否定了“密谋论”，但是并没有说snape是好是坏。
那么DD对SS说"please..."到底指什么呢？
哈哈，越来越有趣了！
MA: OK, big big big book six question. Is Snape evil?
JKR: [Almost laughing] Well, you've read the book, what do you think?
ES: She's trying to make you say it categorically.
MA: Well, there are conspiracy theorists, and there are people who will claim
-
JKR: Cling to some desperate hope [laughter] -
......
ES: Was Dumbledore planning to die?
JKR: [Pause.] Do you think that's going to be the big theory?
MA & ES: Yes. |
|
j***y
发帖数: 4 | 2 I believe Snape is on the good side. But I started to doubt it after read the
interview with JKR...
Here is the quote:
"
....
ES: I know Dumbledore likes to see the good in people but he seems trusting
almost to the point of recklessness sometimes.
[Laughter] Yes, I would agree. I would agree.
ES: How can someone so -
JKR: Intelligent -
ES: be so blind with regard to certain things?
JKR: Well, there is information on that to come, in seven. But I would say
that I think it has been demonstrated, |
|
f******w
发帖数: 10267 | 3 Arthur还得留着给Harry当爹呢，当然不能杀，爹妈不能杀，老婆不能杀，三强之一Ron
不能杀，叛徒杀了没意义，只能是双胞胎里的一个。书没出来之前，我最怕的就是杀
Hagrid。
Luna只不过是比一般女孩子成熟，看世界的角度跟别人不一样，这跟她的身世有关。很
多时候她能一眼看穿世界，在第五部书里，她给了Harry很多的支持，因为她也平常被
人看成异物也不被人理解。不是把Luna配给谁好，是Harry跟她配对最合适.可惜呀，
JKR太俗了，非要不着边际地把Ginny配给他，我老ft了半天。如果说这是给Harry一个
正常家的必经之路，那么JKR在前面铺垫的太不够，而且Ginny这个角色写的也太苍白。
第七部里，Ginny啥都没做呀，就是被当作准老婆给保护起来了，相反，Luna是多么的
勇敢和超凡，她跟Ginny一样大，没有妈/JKR在那里美其名曰地说是underage。我一直
觉得，harry的感情世界在第六部转折的太突然了，而且说白了，这个转折给人的感觉
就是，Harry喜欢追的就是漂亮妹妹。 |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 4 maybe she will just give an open ending...
like someone said before, it is too hard to use one book to tell all stories,
especially it seems next year Harry won't stay at school. JKR has to move
Harry around a lot, physicially. Just like book 5, there will be many places
Harry had to go and he had never been there before, so that will take time. I
think JKR will have a lot of trouble to tighten things up.
Not matter how the story ends, I just hope there is no more killing besides
Voldermont's ul |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 5 I just read the part III of JKR interview, and there is a very interesting
answer:
MA: Oh, here抯 one [from our forums] that I抳e really got to ask you. Has Snape ever been loved by anyone?
JKR: Yes, he has, which in some ways makes him more culpable even than Voldemort, who never has.
I guess this is the key. |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 6 they should ask "has Snape ever loved or been loved by someone?" LOL~
Is it possible Lily loved him before she got married with James? :PPP
Did you notice the last question?
MA: Was there anyone else present in Godric抯 Hollow the night Harry抯 parents were killed?
JKR: No comment.
[All laugh.]
JKR: I抦 sorry!
Maybe Snape was there when Potters were killed? What happened was a huge shock
to him, so that he questioned what he believed... |
|
S***e
发帖数: 4426 | 7 possibly snape was there. never've thought about that before.
but still don't think the snape/lily thing works.
Is it possible Lily loved him before she got married with James? :PPP
Did you notice the last question?
MA: Was there anyone else present in Godric抯 Hollow the night Harry抯 parents
were killed?
JKR: No comment.
[All laugh.]
JKR: I抦 sorry!
Maybe Snape was there when Potters were killed? What happened was a huge shock
to him, so that he questioned what he believed... |
|
x****n
发帖数: 2149 | 8 当年第一次看书名介绍我也这么以为。不过那篇文章下面就是JKR访谈，说
这个"prince"不是potter or riddle.
至于那课本，难道不是因为snape小时候只能用得起二手书？就像穷困的Ron家。
而且第五部里也说他小时候骑破烂笤帚被人嘲笑。他是很可怜啦，但是自己也太mean.
所以JKR认定了他作自己笔下的倒霉蛋。hehe... |
|
U***n
发帖数: 38 | 9 JKR said in a recent interview that James Potter was the only child born to
very old parents (which explains why he was pampered and arrogant). Thus his
parents are conveniently dead in the books and JKR or the readers do not need
to worry about them. :P |
|
qd
发帖数: 74 | 10
JKR说本来第五本就要杀死Ron爸爸的，后来实在不忍心，就放过了他。于是最后杀了
Lupin和Tonk，她希望可以牺牲一个father figure。不知道2个人是不是指Lupin和Tonk
。不过Tonk好像并不是非常主要的人物。
我本来担心是Hagrid。可是JKR说，她从一开始就打算好了，希望Hagrid最后把HP从禁
林里抱出来，所以没有安排他死。 |
|
T*******e
发帖数: 195 | 11 JKR显然是想说Voldemort彻底死了．
但那个闪电疤没疼过不说明任何问题，JKR写到最后明显头昏了．
当Voldemort在森林里第一次杀死Harry的时候，就把Harry体内的他的灵魂杀死了．
所以从那个时候起，Harry和Voldemort就没有了connection，这为彻底杀死Voldemort
提供了可能．同时Harry也再不可能通过这个疤痛不痛来感知Voldemort死没死． |
|
|
t**x
发帖数: 20965 | 13 我哪里说我拿了?
你煞笔
我是说很多人的确很忙做更有意义的事情
而不被政府承认
川粉煞笔在看别人怎么都象拿食物券
怎么都不干活
自己十全十美
世界上最让人恶心的就是川粉.
就算拿了就丢人了? 我不这么认为, 因为我相信人都是有尊严的
Jkr没有食物券就没有哈累波特
一个拿食物券的
比你们所有川粉绑在一起对社会贡献更大
: 你丫原来是拿食物券的，难怪整天在网上找人吵架，终于知道你为啥是川
黑了，
原来是
: 老川要动你的狗粮了。
: 开了一
: 声称医
|
|
T**********2
发帖数: 341 | 14 就看不起像你丫这样有能力工作而不愿工作寄生虫。
: 我哪里说我拿了?
: 你煞笔
: 我是说很多人的确很忙做更有意义的事情
: 而不被政府承认
: 川粉煞笔在看别人怎么都象拿食物券
: 怎么都不干活
: 自己十全十美
: 世界上最让人恶心的就是川粉.
: 就算拿了就丢人了? 我不这么认为, 因为我相信人都是有尊严的
: Jkr没有食物券就没有哈累波特
|
|
|
D*******l
发帖数: 5462 | 16 [20:53:56]mouseroyal:我能录像放到网上么？
[20:53:57]IamCPA:我好怕怕啊
[20:54:00]CardsClub 进入游戏
[20:54:10]deerhunter5:别紧张
[20:54:11]Derick1 开始旁观
[20:54:15]catexplorer:随便放
[20:54:17]catexplorer:没事
[20:54:25]CardsClub:玩吗？
[20:54:25]mouseroyal:好的 谢谢
[20:54:32]IamCPA:你们手下留情
[20:54:37]roadtotake:take it easy
[20:54:52]DRL 开始旁观
[20:54:55]catexplorer:你们很强，
[20:55:01]catexplorer:我们才怕
[20:55:10]toside 开始旁观
[20:55:10]native 开始旁观
[20:55:20]Derickdrl:给大家加油！
[20:55:26]catexplorer:我和road 没配合打过
[20:55:34]roadtotake:nobadby co... 阅读全帖 |
|
D*******l
发帖数: 5462 | 17 [21:00:01]ddDD4:i bet 100 on road team
[21:00:01]duoduo10 开始旁观
[21:00:04]nomadby:谢谢
[21:00:05]IamCPA:cheerleader 要到我们这队来
[21:00:26]roadtotake:pressure
[21:00:27]Derickdrl:可以开始了吗？
[21:00:37]hopeman:derick,you record?
[21:00:39]catexplorer:可以
[21:00:39]roadtotake:i will reimburse you
[21:00:41]hopeman:or I record?
[21:00:42]nomadby:可以
[21:00:44]native 开始旁观
[21:00:46]Derickdrl:你也可以录
[21:00:51]Derickdrl:一起没问题
[21:00:55]Derickdrl:这样有后备
[21:00:56]ddDD4:9
[21:00:59]Derickdrl:各位
[21:01:06]hopeman:ok
[21... 阅读全帖 |
|
D*******l
发帖数: 5462 | 18 [22:00:51]HOWs:系统太慢
[22:01:01]feiyang1516:/
[22:01:01]Derickdrl:是老刑给ddos
[22:01:02]Derickdrl:了
[22:01:18]HOWs:我再提议改天比
[22:01:28]Derickdrl:其它选手？
[22:01:42]Derickdrl:这是第3局？
[22:01:46]tuolaji126:算了
[22:01:46]HOWs:恩
[22:01:47]Ayanna:恩
[22:01:49]yu329 取消旁观
[22:01:55]tuolaji126:就今天搞完
[22:02:01]feiyang1516:我觉得就比下去好了
[22:02:14]HOWs:ok
[22:02:15]feiyang1516:我们再约比较困难
[22:02:23]tuolaji126:要等就下个周末了
[22:03:16]Derickdrl:那比赛继续
[22:03:25]Derickdrl:第4局
HOWs得分:2
feiyang1516得分:-2
Ayanna得分:2
tuolaji126得分:-2
总得分:60分... 阅读全帖 |
|
j******n
发帖数: 871 | 19 JKR 开始旁观
zdzbf:尼玛
zdzbf:早不来晚不来
sunnygirls8 开始旁观
sunnygirls8:zdzbf
zdzbf:恩？
sunnygirls8:你那个id还能救过来么？
zdzbf:啥？
sunnygirls8:lj啊
zdzbf:干嘛
sunnygirls8:我突然觉得，那个id 还有大用
zdzbf:。。。
zdzbf:别坑我
zdzbf:对家啊
zdzbf:会不会
jimmyman 开始旁观 |
|
j******n
发帖数: 871 | 20 JKR 开始旁观
zdzbf:尼玛
zdzbf:早不来晚不来
sunnygirls8 开始旁观
sunnygirls8:zdzbf
zdzbf:恩？
sunnygirls8:你那个id还能救过来么？
zdzbf:啥？
sunnygirls8:lj啊
zdzbf:干嘛
sunnygirls8:我突然觉得，那个id 还有大用
zdzbf:。。。
zdzbf:别坑我
zdzbf:对家啊
zdzbf:会不会
jimmyman 开始旁观
jimmyman:rightturn went to thailand?
jimmyman:lol
ppmm2得分:2
zdzbf得分:2
laosi得分:-2
grumman得分:-2
jimmyman:手术成功么？
总得分:40分(扣底0分;倍数0)
跳级:1级
jimmyman:laja, laja
jimmyman:要点脸这么难么？
zdzbf:你？这辈子很难
jimmyman:自杀的id还能救回来，lol
sunnygirls8:半路改变主意就是了
jimmyman:别再跟我说是意外
sunnygirls8:完全看主人意愿
sunnygirls8:跟你... 阅读全帖 |
|
f******w
发帖数: 10267 | 21 想热闹而又保持质量，是一个很微妙的平衡。但是花园版，还是种花种草种菜，防虫，
施肥，等等比较重要，都需要知识和技术。
忘了是哪个版的规定了，凡是水贴，48小时（还是24？）以后合集删帖。要不然等10万
贴再整理，板斧的工作量太大了。
多说一句，不准拍我！至于啥是高质量的文章吧，再次推荐清漩妹妹在本版唯一的小说
。当然，罗卜青菜，有人比较喜欢琼瑶，有人喜欢贾平凹（我是说废都的贾平凹），有
人呢，比较喜欢JKR（比如说我）。本版有才的人很多，比如你们的版大，也是笔杆子
一根，有她在，说实话，我都得把文字琢磨很多遍，把文章写漂亮了才发的。
http://www.mitbbs.com/bbsann2/entertainment.faq/gardening/D1295
多谢大家读我的唠唠叨叨，人老了，没办法，呵呵。 |
|
j******n
发帖数: 21641 | 22 象哈利波特这种洪篇,展示的是一群人,特别是一群成长中的和精灵古怪的人
现在哈迷还创作了很多前传后传还有非主要人物成为主人公的延伸小说
JKR自己也很有自信,她创造的哈小宇宙还有很多空间呢
指环王又何尝不是如此
还有那些吸血鬼小说
有人就fancy这个,不需要什么理由的
现在回头看郑渊洁童话
是否也不理解小时候的我们自己呢 |
|
m****e
发帖数: 160 | 23 PS：墙裂抗议 LOTR 三本算一本（虽然JKR他老人家的本意是作为一本书来写的），
Harry Potter 七本算七本。。。 果然这年头写书跟发paper一样，零敲碎打地灌水是
王道么 ToT |
|
x*****7
发帖数: 4749 | 24 找了我喜欢的Severus Snape名字的来历。
Severus = obvious connotations of severity and strictness. Possible allusion
to the Roman Emperor, Lucius Septimius Severus, who reconstructed Hadrian’
s wall and defeated Clodinus Albinus and Pescennius Niger. There are also
several saints with the name 'Severus.'
'Snape' meaning: JKR says "Snape is an English village" (eT), probably the
one in North Yorkshire near Hadrian’s (aka Severus’) Wall. This village
also has a 'Snape Castle.' There is another Snape Village tha... 阅读全帖 |
|
x*****7
发帖数: 4749 | 25 找了我喜欢的Severus Snape名字的来历。
Severus = obvious connotations of severity and strictness. Possible allusion
to the Roman Emperor, Lucius Septimius Severus, who reconstructed Hadrian’
s wall and defeated Clodinus Albinus and Pescennius Niger. There are also
several saints with the name 'Severus.'
'Snape' meaning: JKR says "Snape is an English village" (eT), probably the
one in North Yorkshire near Hadrian’s (aka Severus’) Wall. This village
also has a 'Snape Castle.' There is another Snape Village tha... 阅读全帖 |
|
c***r
发帖数: 4631 | 26 Ginevra (Ginny) Weasley
Ginevra 是Guinevere的意大利语。Guinevere在亚瑟王的故事里面是亚瑟王的王后。
Guinevere的意思是“白，美丽，圣洁的仙（女）”。JKR在构建哈利波特这个人物的时
候汲取了很多亚瑟王的元素，构建哈利波特的老婆这个人物的时候用了一些亚瑟王的王
后的元素也是必然的。
说起来亚瑟王的故事的发展也是一个很有意思的故事，12世纪的时候，有个叫Geoffrey
of Monmouth的，写了一本《不列颠列王传》献给他的领主，Robert, 1st Earl of
Gloucester。 这个Gloucester也是Beattrix Potter写的《The tailor of Gloucester
》的故事发生的地方，也是哈利波特的作者出生的地方。《不列颠列王传》从Hermione
的妈导致特洛伊城破后特洛伊人一路漂流到了意大利建立了罗马，后来一个叫Brutus的
特洛伊后代从罗马扬帆西去，在女神戴安娜的指引下到了不列颠谈起，讲了李尔王，讲
了凯撒入侵不列颠，讲了君士坦丁，讲了罗马人离开不列颠，讲了大王Vertigern借... 阅读全帖 |
|
e*******r
发帖数: 1433 | 27 设定太滥，只能当成故事看。小说还凑或，电影拍得太烂！
LOTR 可比 还珠楼主的 蜀山剑侠传，值得敬仰，不值得看。
HP可比金庸的鹿鼎记，只讲故事，弱化武侠奇幻。
故事是不错，也没那么惊天动地，旷世名著。
你喜欢的要亲JKR的大脚板，请便，who cares
你憎恨的要扔鸡蛋，没空奉陪，who cares. |
|
f*******m
发帖数: 3759 | 28 突然恍然大悟。。。原来jkr阿姨以前就提出了inception这个理论 |
|
or
发帖数: 720 | 29 honestly i thought cho was a placid char, and in 5 she was getting a bit like
moaning maytle, rueful and tearful.
no much progress on plot. and more loose ends were left in the end.
the interesting thing is chars were growing up.
ginny was cool, more assertive and forward.
ron was still childish and clownish.
luna was cute.
eventually there'll be three young couples, imo:
ron & hermoine; harry & ginny; neville & luna.
is this too obvious? jkr might surprise us. |
|
or
发帖数: 720 | 30 hmm I liked Harry's anger. But his emotionality on Sirius' death was
un-affecting since this death was so accidently blurt out. I felt very silly
about that prophecy. When getting to the end and Dumbldore's explanation,
it's like what? isn't this too obvious, we have all guessed along it was
either V. or HP. Poor Lord V., how many times could he fail?! I also
presumed Cho was Asian, and thought JKR was dismissive by flatting her into a
weeping-willow. |
|
a***a
发帖数: 3 | 31 Is it written by you? :-) I think I am also in love with Sirius :-) and got a
bit choked up when he "died", although I already knew he was the one half way
through the book... As I replied to another HP post in the Literature board,
his death is too sudden and as many people suggested he was not hit by a
"killing" curse so he may come back in another form (image in the mirror,
spirit, phantom, dream, whatever). JKR will bring him back one way or another
now that there is so much pressure from di |
|
EJ
发帖数: 23 | 32 Could be that he didn't intend to or doesn't even know? I think it is possibl
e, though i hope not, that Harry has the other horcrux. Remeber, the horcrux r
ing has a lightning shape and so does Harry's scar. And JKR herself has said
that the last word of the book is probably going to be "scar"? Dumbledore did
say that he thought after LV tried to kill Harry, he turned the snake into hi
s last horcrux, but that's just a pure speculation. What if he accidentally l
eft a mark on Harry? They a |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 33 I think Snape will retire with glory then. lol~
about the popular of Slytherin, an interview of Jo is very interesting:
(from http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/)
MA: What does it do to you to see a character that you love, for people to express sheer hate -
ES: Or vice versa.
JKR: It amuses me. It honestly amuses me. People have been waxing lyrical [in letters] about Draco Malfoy, and I think that's the only time when it stopped amusing me and started almost worrying me. I'm trying to clearly di |
|
S***e
发帖数: 4426 | 34 yeah. i just read about this. so it says that snape has been loved by someone,
not has loved someone. curious...
really can't imagine what will happen if snape is still a DE. how could harry
possibly win the war then?
answer:
MA: Oh, here抯 one [from our forums] that I抳e really got to ask you. Has Snap
e ever been loved by anyone?
JKR: Yes, he has, which in some ways makes him more culpable even than Voldemo
rt, who never has.
I guess this is the key. |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 35 but JKR said in some sense he was more culpable even than Voldemort...
My wild guess is that Voldemort promised him that only James and Harry need
die, so Snape killed James, but Lily refused to step aside so Voldemort killed
her in spite of objection of Snape.....
I know maybe I went too far. :D Another 2 years waiting... Argh!!! It gonna
kill me! |
|
S***e
发帖数: 4426 | 36 rowling said the reason that snape was more culpable than voldemort is that he
has been loved by someone, while voldemort hasn't.
now i really wanna kidnap rowling to get her plan. seriously, i hate this woma
n.
it must be voldemort who killed james, cuz in book 4 james's image also came f
rom voldemort's wand. i even think snape would die for james if he could as ja
mes had saved his life, though he hated this fact.
but JKR said in some sense he was more culpable even than Voldemort...
My wild |
|
EJ
发帖数: 23 | 37 JKR has answered this question herself. Study the interview archive on the Le
aky Cauldron |
|
p*********d
发帖数: 2373 | 38 spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//
spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//
spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//spoiler//
just finished reading "The half-blood prince" last night, why Dumbledore had
to die?? the 5th book was sad enough that Sirius died, and JKR made it again,
wuwuwu.............. it was supposed to be a fun book, not a tragic reading,
wasn't it? |
|
n**r
发帖数: 510 | 39 agree...
JKR said in an interview that as an Hero, Harry Potter should not have too
much assistance from other people....something like that...
that is why these people died.
I do not agree with this though...
, |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 40 JKR said this is not a fun book from the 1st one. there were always ppl dying
, |
|
f*****o
发帖数: 113 | 41 i remember JKR said Harry's grandparents died long time ago and had nothing
to do with the story. But anyway, Harry will go to Godric's Hollow. He may
find something interesting there...
世 |
|
s***n
发帖数: 2366 | 42 人家毕竟是本儿童读物。是要教孩子们理解获得成功的艰辛和友情珍贵的。
JKR现在书卖的这样好，还没有跟风去搞悬念，打斗，实属不易。 |
|
E******n
发帖数: 641 | 43 Indeed, there're a lot of flaws and I don't think JKR was that careful.
But overall just treat it as an great entertainment, enjoy its magical world. |
|
E******n
发帖数: 641 | 44 He didn't deserve death. Tortured for generations in Malfoy's house, did so
many goods, but JKR chose to let him die!
Same goes for Fred, should've lived and let Percy die, if she really think
one of the Weasleys should die. |
|
d****i
发帖数: 397 | 45 JKR喜欢malfoy一家，一个都没死。@_@
so |
|
f*********d
发帖数: 166 | 46 因为JKR就是妈妈吧，如果不是为了养孩子就没有HP系列了 |
|
d****i
发帖数: 397 | 47 全职妈妈能做到这份上算是很厉害了。jkr说hermione身上有很多她自己的影子，我就
不明白他为什么把herm的老公写的那么弱，细细。 |
|
k**x
发帖数: 2611 | 48 lv应该还是在书里找到的，那本the darkest art是AD后来收起来的
他问的是能不能多做几个Horcrux
根据JKR的访谈，lv过于嚣张的漏了点风，以为别人猜不出来
但RAB是猜了出来
is
18
got |
|
E******n
发帖数: 641 | 49 I regard this as a loophole by JKR. |
|
f*******y
发帖数: 106 | 50 orz 不晓得是不是违反版规，是的话版主砍掉即可 |
|
