L***s
发帖数: 9258 | 1 To summarize, the original contribution of this work is still questionable a
nd has major flaws. The authors should be honest and should not ignore the p
rior art in which lots of techniques are generic and applicable to many tech
nologies.
老子气坏了，写了封email回给editor:
We feel very disappointed and strongly disagree the criticism raised by revi
ewer on our academic ethics. We believe we have already given a fair judgeme
nt on the difference between our work and all prior-art works at the maximum
exte... 阅读全帖 |
|
n******v
发帖数: 2184 | 2 写的好。该说就的说。
a
p
tech
revi
judgeme
maximum
ar
questi |
|
m****m
发帖数: 2211 | 3 如果光看这段，你的回复正常
问题是summarize之前的有没有举出一些work你们没有很好的cite呢
a
p
tech
revi
judgeme
maximum
ar
questi |
|
e****g
发帖数: 4434 | 4 靠，不是咱俩的collaborative proposal吧，
a
p
tech
revi
judgeme
maximum
ar
questi |
|
w*****n
发帖数: 2693 | 5 hehe
其实blind review和网上发帖有点像
人隐身的时候通常都比面对面的时候mean一些，悲愤一些，犬儒一些
收到review，可以放两天再看，当场看基本都有骂人的冲动
a
p
tech
revi
judgeme
maximum
ar
questi |
|
i**l
发帖数: 4224 | 6 X. He ? an hour ago
I can't help feeling disgusted by Luisa Lim's story, yes, disgusted, and the
re is nothing disingenuous about my feeling here.
It's not the first time that Ms. Lim took on colored lens and put her negati
ve spin on things happened in China, nothing shy of a fly looking for a rott
on apple when there are numerous fresh produce in an orchard.
Guess what, Chinese don't need any validation from people who don't have the
capability of appreciating this language. I'm very happy for... 阅读全帖 |
|
b*s
发帖数: 82482 | 7 何谐？
X. He ? an hour ago
I can't help feeling disgusted by Luisa Lim's story, yes, disgusted, and the
re is nothing disingenuous about my feeling here.
It's not the first time that Ms. Lim took on colored lens and put her negati
ve spin on things happened in China, nothing shy of a fly looking for a rott
on apple when there are numerous fresh produce in an orchard.
Guess what, Chinese don't need any validation from people who don't have the
capability of appreciating this language. I'm very happ... 阅读全帖 |
|
