l******t
发帖数: 2243 | 1 1a or 1b? re-submit seems to be faster according to this board. good luck!
发信人: cepm (Mad Cow), 信区: Immigration
标 题: XM359就是一Asshole
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sat Jan 1 20:38:08 2011, 美东)
TMD
一个月前NOID说我contribution不够，说推荐信没多大用，要pre-existing
independent and objective evidence。 我说好呀，于是把所有citation里highlight
我的文章都重新强调一遍，然后再找两个人写了很给力的推荐信，有让4个合作者说我
的东西给他们很大帮助，相关文章很快就会发出来。结果denial letter对这些
evidence一个字没提，又说了一遍推荐信没多大用，要pre-existing independent and
objective evidence。
这还不算气人的，最气人的说我2010年10月才博士毕业，it is highly unl... 阅读全帖 |
|
C*******s
发帖数: 231 | 2 pat pat。
这些理由确实有点荒谬，看起来xm359不是善茬呀！
highlight
and
that |
|
g****x
发帖数: 3862 | 3 xm359 在那个center呀？
highlight
and
that |
|
B*****l
发帖数: 192 | 4 background：
engineering PhD, now work as a research scientist in a company
16+ publication (most of them are 1st author)
>130 citations
>30 reviews, served in the program committees of a few international
conferences
papers used by some professors as lecture material
one best paper award from a conference
8 reference letters (6 from U.S.), including a support letter from a
conference chair on my review experience
Claim:
authorship, contribution, review
IO是XM359，好像是TSC的Director。
140在6月交上去后一直没动静，实... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
m*****h
发帖数: 2292 | 11 【 以下文字转载自 Immigration 讨论区 】
发信人: BigTail (大尾巴), 信区: Immigration
标 题: 求助！TSC EB1B NOID received today
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Wed Dec 8 00:21:12 2010, 美东)
background：
engineering PhD, now work as a research scientist in a company
16+ publication (most of them are 1st author)
>130 citations
>30 reviews, served in the program committees of a few international
conferences
papers used by some professors as lecture material
one best paper award from a conference
8 reference letters (6 from U.S.), including ... 阅读全帖 |
|
s**********e
发帖数: 454 | 12 以下是我找的近两个月的NOID，可能不全，共17个。其中（4）， （14）和（5）没有
PP，其余的都是PP。
很多人都说PP不会影响通过/不通过，我只摆数据，您下结论。
(1)eb1b NOID to TSC officer one week ago.
10/5 NOID received by USCIS and hard updated online
10/6 soft lud;
10/7 soft lud;
10/8 soft lud.
(2)9月23收件
10月5 LUD
今天收到律师传真NOID
(3)EB1A PP TSC 被1219 拦腰一刀
(4)3.22 寄出I140
7.19 收到NOID
8.10 寄出回复
10.6 收到approve的email
今天收到mail
(5)package sent out: 08/18
RD: 08/23
NOID by fax: 08/30
NOID response sent out: 09/27
NOID response received: 09/29
AD: 10/04
(6)EB1A NOID, PP, Got 2-... 阅读全帖 |
|
c**m
发帖数: 757 | 13 TMD
一个月前NOID说我contribution不够，说推荐信没多大用，要pre-existing
independent and objective evidence。 我说好呀，于是把所有citation里highlight
我的文章都重新强调一遍，然后再找两个人写了很给力的推荐信，有让4个合作者说我
的东西给他们很大帮助，相关文章很快就会发出来。结果denial letter对这些
evidence一个字没提，又说了一遍推荐信没多大用，要pre-existing independent and
objective evidence。
这还不算气人的，最气人的说我2010年10月才博士毕业，it is highly unlikely that
you have had enough time to garner the type of sustained work experience,
national or international acclaim necessary to be considered at the top of
your field。 真tmd服了，
我... 阅读全帖 |
|
T****O
发帖数: 407 | 14 Change your attitue first :-)
Did you truly mean it by "我承认我也就一普通人，发了几篇小文章，在学术界一无名
小卒而已"? Then please correct me: you were a gimmick in your petition and
the adjudicator saw through it.
highlight
and
that |
|
m********t
发帖数: 9426 | 15 BSO你老板是大牛啊
照理说你老板的引用那么多，你一起挂名应该不少啊
highlight
and
that |
|
b*********r
发帖数: 7139 | 16 comfortable. 1A or 1B? How many independent recommendation letters you got?
Resubmit. Good luck next time. |
|
c**m
发帖数: 757 | 17 惭愧，我来的时候老板已经开始吃老本了，
那些成就都是早些年打下的。再说不是大牛了，只是在适当时间灌了几篇适当的水而已。 |
|
h*****5
发帖数: 566 | 18 移民官真是越来越变态了。建议楼主还是重新组织一下材料，再file一个新case到TSC
。 appeal要等很久才有结果。
highlight
and
that |
|
c**m
发帖数: 757 | 19 心里话而已。做人觉得还是明白自己几斤几两最好。
petition letter吹的自己都脸红。
无名
and |
|
c**m
发帖数: 757 | 20 1A 7封，遍及5个国家4大洲。学术界工业界都有。
? |
|
T****O
发帖数: 407 | 21 DIS is America! If you feel bad when advertising yourself as best as you
can, why bother with green card?
Or you want to wait until your credentials satisfy yourself? That's an
option too. |
|
y***e
发帖数: 6082 | 22 重新搞，能过的，pp看自己的感觉了
TMD
一个月前NOID说我contribution不够，说推荐信没多大用，要pre-existing
independent and objective evidence。 我说好呀，于是把所有citation里highlight
我的文章都重新强调一遍，然后再找两个人写了很给力的推荐信，有让4个合作者说我
的东西给他们很大帮助，相关文章很快就会发出来。结果denial letter对这些
evidence一个字没提，又说了一遍推荐信没多大用，要pre-existing independent and
objective evidence。
这还不算气人的，最气人的说我2010年10月才博士毕业，it is highly unlikely that
you have had enough time to garner the type of sustained work experience,
national or international acclaim necessary to be considered at the top of
yo... 阅读全帖 |
|
y***e
发帖数: 6082 | 23 还好把，我觉得PL也没怎么吹，不知道吹到脸红是要吹到多么厉害，不是说了硬证据至
上为第一原则么
心里话而已。做人觉得还是明白自己几斤几两最好。
petition letter吹的自己都脸红。
无名
and |
|
|
|
m********t
发帖数: 9426 | 26 有这么牛的老板，你应该很牛啊
下次肯定过
bless
已。 |
|
|
b*********0
发帖数: 1030 | 28 refile might be a good chose
highlight
and
that |
|
|
a********0
发帖数: 30 | 30 VERY SORRY TO HEAR THIS. ANYWAY, STILL wish you have a happy new year!!!
Suggest that do not appeal. Re-organize the file and find more independent
ref. letters on which your work has been applied or used or cited, and have
more publications or citations.
When you review other people's paper, if the authors appeal your points or
say "you do not read my paper carefully or you are wrong", are you feeling
well? Of course not, and most likely you will do ... :-)
The same here...
highlight
and
that |
|
l******5
发帖数: 3030 | 31 差不多都是这样， 你以为俺老大吹得不脸红？ 找人签推荐时都感觉脸皮厚极了。 重
递一个CASE要比APPEAL快得多。 |
|
|
|
f******l
发帖数: 17 | 34 还是重新来过吧。下次一定过。
刚寄出了NOID的回复给359. 担心呀。你是什么时候收到答复的？ 谢谢了。
highlight
and
that |
|
c**m
发帖数: 757 | 35 我运气不好，当然自身条件也不好。
祝你好运。我是收到后8天给的答复。 |
|
|
|
l*******n
发帖数: 8388 | 38 发信人: Westgatejim (Famillerose), 信区: EB23
标 题: Re: 【EB2九月第12绿】TSC, EB2, Card production
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Mon Sep 15 12:02:23 2014, 美东)
谢谢版花！六月提前做完体检， sr三次，参众议员联系， io1，2 电话无数，律师催
绿等等一路不停， 上周五还去参议员处催。tsc officer xm359 |
|
W*********m
发帖数: 90 | 39 谢谢版花！六月提前做完体检， sr三次，参众议员联系， io1，2 电话无数，律师催
绿等等一路不停， 上周五还去参议员处催。tsc officer xm359。 |
|
