t********g
发帖数: 47 | 1 标题是 Triage Invitation Letter - The Journal of xxx
Dear xxx,
I am interested in your input on the above-mentioned manuscript. I am
considering triaging this article, and would appreciate your thoughts
regarding the article's chances of surviving the full review process for the
Journal.
We are only able to accept xxx% of papers submitted. In order to save time
for our reviewers and save time for authors, we are performing a preliminary
review of submissions. Would you be able to provide a rapid, preliminary
review of this paper - within about 5 days?
For this purpose, I am not asking for a full review. I am primarily
interested in your opinion (yes or no) regarding whether this paper (1) does
or could make an important and substantial contribution to the literature,
and so should get a full review or (2) would unlikely survive the review
process, and so should be triaged. If you think that the paper should be
triaged, I would appreciate a short paragraph stating your reasons, which
might be helpful to the authors.
第一次收到这种类型的评审邀请,基本明白了这封信的意思,但还是不知道具体应该写点
什么.不知道有没有经历过的指点下这样的应该如何写, 写多长比较合适? | j*****d
发帖数: 787 | 2 这信写的真罗嗦。你有时间就给个full review，没时间就针对特别的问题特别的回答
下贝。我今天用两个工作日弄了个full review.
the
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb - 中文网站浏览器
【在 t********g 的大作中提到】
: 标题是 Triage Invitation Letter - The Journal of xxx
: Dear xxx,
: I am interested in your input on the above-mentioned manuscript. I am
: considering triaging this article, and would appreciate your thoughts
: regarding the article's chances of surviving the full review process for the
: Journal.
: We are only able to accept xxx% of papers submitted. In order to save time
: for our reviewers and save time for authors, we are performing a preliminary
: review of submissions. Would you be able to provide a rapid, preliminary
: review of this paper - within about 5 days?
| t********g
发帖数: 47 | 3 是啊,还不如直接让我评审就完了.我哪知道推荐送审后能不能通过啊...
【在 j*****d 的大作中提到】
: 这信写的真罗嗦。你有时间就给个full review，没时间就针对特别的问题特别的回答
: 下贝。我今天用两个工作日弄了个full review.
:
: the
: ★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb - 中文网站浏览器
| v*****s
发帖数: 20290 | 4 就是叫你不要挑细节，从大局观上看看这个文章符不符合这个杂志的档次。
你的意见应该不会转给reviewer的，除非是据，也不会转给author。
我觉得你没必要搞full review，就写一段话行了。当然我没收过这种邀请，上面说的
都是我个人的推测。
【在 t********g 的大作中提到】
: 是啊,还不如直接让我评审就完了.我哪知道推荐送审后能不能通过啊...
| t********g
发帖数: 47 | |
|
