w********r 发帖数: 1431 | 1 认真严肃真心求教。
然后顺便看看哪个辞典再进来跟我定义什么是shameful. | X******2 发帖数: 5859 | 2 算不上吧,他博士老板就占了两个名额。
【在 w********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 认真严肃真心求教。 : 然后顺便看看哪个辞典再进来跟我定义什么是shameful.
| w******n 发帖数: 371 | | w********r 发帖数: 1431 | 4 呵呵,我觉得问rao能不能进top 10本身就是对他的赞扬(至少在现阶段是赞扬)
【在 w******n 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 这个板上很多rao的学生,小心小心
| c********r 发帖数: 1125 | 5 我个人觉得有困难。。。前提还是香港/台湾不算,只算大陆解放后过去得。
果蝇里面xu tian和luo liqun就比他强不少。。pan duojia也很强。
线虫里面: yuan junying肯定比rao强, han min是hhmi, xue ding文章不比rao 差,
新生代shen kang。
神经里面:jin yishi(hhmi),he zhigang,新生代 song hongjun
其他领域:wang xiaodong, kuan kunliang,zhang yi(hhmi),shi yang,zheng yixian(hhmi&jcb editor)
植物里面: zhu jiankang(nas) deng xingwang,
免疫:liu yongjun, 新生代dong chen
新兴领域: zhuang xiaowei, ding sheng,
结构里面中国hhmi有好几个吧。
这还是保守估计。。还有很多。。。
前50-100差不多吧。。。 | D**A 发帖数: 311 | | o**4 发帖数: 35028 | 7 你列的这些里面,有些跟饶毅水平相差不多,
我是我同意你的结论,饶毅应该进不了前20?
yixian(hhmi&jcb editor)
【在 c********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 我个人觉得有困难。。。前提还是香港/台湾不算,只算大陆解放后过去得。 : 果蝇里面xu tian和luo liqun就比他强不少。。pan duojia也很强。 : 线虫里面: yuan junying肯定比rao强, han min是hhmi, xue ding文章不比rao 差, : 新生代shen kang。 : 神经里面:jin yishi(hhmi),he zhigang,新生代 song hongjun : 其他领域:wang xiaodong, kuan kunliang,zhang yi(hhmi),shi yang,zheng yixian(hhmi&jcb editor) : 植物里面: zhu jiankang(nas) deng xingwang, : 免疫:liu yongjun, 新生代dong chen : 新兴领域: zhuang xiaowei, ding sheng, : 结构里面中国hhmi有好几个吧。
| y******8 发帖数: 1764 | 8 Your list is like comparing apples and oranges.
If you list all HHMIs, I think Rao is at least better than one third of them
. HHMI funding meant a lot before, but now it is just two R01 grants.
yixian(hhmi&jcb editor)
【在 c********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 我个人觉得有困难。。。前提还是香港/台湾不算,只算大陆解放后过去得。 : 果蝇里面xu tian和luo liqun就比他强不少。。pan duojia也很强。 : 线虫里面: yuan junying肯定比rao强, han min是hhmi, xue ding文章不比rao 差, : 新生代shen kang。 : 神经里面:jin yishi(hhmi),he zhigang,新生代 song hongjun : 其他领域:wang xiaodong, kuan kunliang,zhang yi(hhmi),shi yang,zheng yixian(hhmi&jcb editor) : 植物里面: zhu jiankang(nas) deng xingwang, : 免疫:liu yongjun, 新生代dong chen : 新兴领域: zhuang xiaowei, ding sheng, : 结构里面中国hhmi有好几个吧。
| y******8 发帖数: 1764 | 9 Why do you care about this kind of ranking?
Research-wise, RY is smart and certainly with distinguished achievements.
Management-wise, he is surely worse than some directors of top Chinese
institutions. | h*****9 发帖数: 4028 | 10 我觉得评价一个科学家的成就和地位最重要的(对外行来说)就是那没拿到本领域内的
国际/权威大奖。这个比CNS要远能经受得住考验。
不知道饶同学拿过那些神经生物学领域的大奖。知情的可以列出来看看。
【在 w********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 认真严肃真心求教。 : 然后顺便看看哪个辞典再进来跟我定义什么是shameful.
| | | l*******h 发帖数: 455 | 11 does RY even do research ???
he's just a manager of a research team
【在 y******8 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : Why do you care about this kind of ranking? : Research-wise, RY is smart and certainly with distinguished achievements. : Management-wise, he is surely worse than some directors of top Chinese : institutions.
| n********k 发帖数: 2818 | 12 DIng Yi Xia:))
【在 y******8 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : Why do you care about this kind of ranking? : Research-wise, RY is smart and certainly with distinguished achievements. : Management-wise, he is surely worse than some directors of top Chinese : institutions.
| n********k 发帖数: 2818 | 13 I cannot help Strongly DING YI Xia!
them
【在 y******8 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : Your list is like comparing apples and oranges. : If you list all HHMIs, I think Rao is at least better than one third of them : . HHMI funding meant a lot before, but now it is just two R01 grants. : : yixian(hhmi&jcb editor)
| n********k 发帖数: 2818 | 14 like Oct4, i would agree with your conclusion: RY is likely not within top
20 (at least) or not even 50/100...
However,
线虫里面: yuan junying肯定比rao强,
What made you think so? For works after their independence, I am not sure
who is better between the two or can be compared...
新兴领域: zhuang xiaowei, ding sheng:
As one in the related field, I know Ding sheng is hot hot hot...but again
I don't see what made him definitely better than RY...For sure, Ding's
stuff is very hot and trendy...contribution wise esp after independence...I
am not sure...
HHMI structu....no comments...
han min是hhmi, xue ding文章不比rao 差,
yixian(hhmi&jcb editor)
【在 c********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 我个人觉得有困难。。。前提还是香港/台湾不算,只算大陆解放后过去得。 : 果蝇里面xu tian和luo liqun就比他强不少。。pan duojia也很强。 : 线虫里面: yuan junying肯定比rao强, han min是hhmi, xue ding文章不比rao 差, : 新生代shen kang。 : 神经里面:jin yishi(hhmi),he zhigang,新生代 song hongjun : 其他领域:wang xiaodong, kuan kunliang,zhang yi(hhmi),shi yang,zheng yixian(hhmi&jcb editor) : 植物里面: zhu jiankang(nas) deng xingwang, : 免疫:liu yongjun, 新生代dong chen : 新兴领域: zhuang xiaowei, ding sheng, : 结构里面中国hhmi有好几个吧。
| h********r 发帖数: 519 | 15 大哥,这么恐怖的英文就不要出来练了。
sure
again
I
【在 n********k 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : like Oct4, i would agree with your conclusion: RY is likely not within top : 20 (at least) or not even 50/100... : However, : 线虫里面: yuan junying肯定比rao强, : What made you think so? For works after their independence, I am not sure : who is better between the two or can be compared... : 新兴领域: zhuang xiaowei, ding sheng: : As one in the related field, I know Ding sheng is hot hot hot...but again : I don't see what made him definitely better than RY...For sure, Ding's : stuff is very hot and trendy...contribution wise esp after independence...I
| n********k 发帖数: 2818 | 16 Shame on you and on my English as well (i don't give a dime:)) though)
【在 h********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 大哥,这么恐怖的英文就不要出来练了。 : : sure : again : I
| h********r 发帖数: 519 | 17 你有空还是好好shame shame你的broken英语,
否则怎么跟人交流。
要不去ets给你出托福改错题也不错。
【在 n********k 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : Shame on you and on my English as well (i don't give a dime:)) though)
| g****1 发帖数: 261 | 18
Not even close to top 10.
【在 w********r 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 认真严肃真心求教。 : 然后顺便看看哪个辞典再进来跟我定义什么是shameful.
|
|