h********s
发帖数: 20 | 1 Retraction
Retraction Notice to: Betatrophin: A Hormone that Controls Pancreatic β
Cell Proliferation
Peng Yi, Ji-Sun Park, Douglas A. Melton
(Cell 153, 747–758; May 9, 2013)
In this article, we claimed that Angptl-8, which we termed betatrophin and
is also referred to in the literature as TD26, RIFL, C19orf80, and Lipasin,
was the agent by which the insulin antagonist S961 induces robust β cell
replication in mice. Gusarova et al., in a Matters Arising article,
subsequently showed that targeted Angptl-8/betatrophin overexpression in
mice increases blood triglycerides but does not induce β cell growth (Cell,
2014, 159, 691–696). When we repeated our original experiments with a
larger number of mice, we also failed to observe β-cell expansion upon
Angptl-8/betatrophin overexpression and reported these results in a
Correspondence (Cell, 2014, 159, 467–468). We have subsequently repeated a
series of blinded experiments with the Kushner lab and have now determined
conclusively that our conclusion that Angptl-8/betatrophin causes specific
β cell replication is wrong and cannot be supported (PLoS One, 2016, 11,
e0159276). Therefore, the most appropriate course of action is to retract
the paper. We regret and apologize for this mistake.
貌似第一作者靠这篇文章找到了很好的工作（https://joslinresearch.org/
investigators/Peng-Yi），老板饭碗也不会丢，韩春雨主动发个retraction是不是也
没事？副教授照当，2亿经费也不会被追回？ |
P****R
发帖数: 22479 | 2 try.
,
【在 h********s 的大作中提到】
: Retraction
: Retraction Notice to: Betatrophin: A Hormone that Controls Pancreatic β
: Cell Proliferation
: Peng Yi, Ji-Sun Park, Douglas A. Melton
: (Cell 153, 747–758; May 9, 2013)
: In this article, we claimed that Angptl-8, which we termed betatrophin and
: is also referred to in the literature as TD26, RIFL, C19orf80, and Lipasin,
: was the agent by which the insulin antagonist S961 induces robust β cell
: replication in mice. Gusarova et al., in a Matters Arising article,
: subsequently showed that targeted Angptl-8/betatrophin overexpression in
|
D********d
发帖数: 2154 | |
l*********d
发帖数: 315 | 4 发Retraction的是Melton, 不是小伙子. |
p*******1
发帖数: 495 | 5 他还有一篇science 呢！背后的老板更是超级大牛！ |
l*********d
发帖数: 315 | 6 发Retraction的是Melton, 不是小伙子. |
D********d
发帖数: 2154 | 7 发Retraction的第一作者仍然是这小子：
Retraction Notice to: Betatrophin: A Hormone that Controls Pancreatic β
Cell Proliferation
Peng Yi, Ji-Sun Park, Douglas A.
Publication stage: In Press Corrected Proof
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2016.12.017
又增加了一片Cell 一作啊。 |
n******7
发帖数: 12463 | 8 尼玛
现在这圈子跟官场一样了
不搞点贪腐幕后交易很难混
搞了之后会不会爆出来就看运气了
利益太大，漏网太多，所以趋之若骛啊 |
w***9
发帖数: 804 | 9 天地万物皆以无为本.
反对韩的人主要是嫉妒，非常原始的心态。要认真学习，提高水平，站在怎么对自己有
利的角度看问题。
不要嫉妒别人的成功，要找自己成功的路。不要抱怨现实社会残酷无耻，要努力改造自
己去适应社会。从来没有什么救世主，只能自己解放自己。 |
g********0
发帖数: 6201 | 10 大家都看到了，这就是得罪了国内黑社会院士大佬的结果，要被手下马仔拿西瓜刀追砍
这么久。 |
|
|
z*******x
发帖数: 103 | 11 我不觉得这小子Peng Yi Tenure 可以轻松过关。 |
g********0
发帖数: 6201 | 12 如果是Joslin，就只能呵呵了。
【在 z*******x 的大作中提到】
: 我不觉得这小子Peng Yi Tenure 可以轻松过关。
|
p*******1
发帖数: 495 | 13 听到过类似的案例，只要博士博士后期间文章有retraction 的，会过滤掉。当然其博
士后老板是西南医学中心的权威大牛，还是要看佛面的。
【在 z*******x 的大作中提到】
: 我不觉得这小子Peng Yi Tenure 可以轻松过关。
|
o*******4
发帖数: 105 | 14 cell 的文章有问题，science的文章能干净的了？ |
r***x
发帖数: 855 | 15 韩主席我看悬
,
【在 h********s 的大作中提到】
: Retraction
: Retraction Notice to: Betatrophin: A Hormone that Controls Pancreatic β
: Cell Proliferation
: Peng Yi, Ji-Sun Park, Douglas A. Melton
: (Cell 153, 747–758; May 9, 2013)
: In this article, we claimed that Angptl-8, which we termed betatrophin and
: is also referred to in the literature as TD26, RIFL, C19orf80, and Lipasin,
: was the agent by which the insulin antagonist S961 induces robust β cell
: replication in mice. Gusarova et al., in a Matters Arising article,
: subsequently showed that targeted Angptl-8/betatrophin overexpression in
|
l*********d
发帖数: 315 | 16 怎么感觉PLOS One更像科学杂志一点
【在 o*******4 的大作中提到】
: cell 的文章有问题，science的文章能干净的了？
|
r***x
发帖数: 855 | 17 韩主席我看悬
,
【在 h********s 的大作中提到】
: Retraction
: Retraction Notice to: Betatrophin: A Hormone that Controls Pancreatic β
: Cell Proliferation
: Peng Yi, Ji-Sun Park, Douglas A. Melton
: (Cell 153, 747–758; May 9, 2013)
: In this article, we claimed that Angptl-8, which we termed betatrophin and
: is also referred to in the literature as TD26, RIFL, C19orf80, and Lipasin,
: was the agent by which the insulin antagonist S961 induces robust β cell
: replication in mice. Gusarova et al., in a Matters Arising article,
: subsequently showed that targeted Angptl-8/betatrophin overexpression in
|
P****R
发帖数: 22479 | 18
【在 p*******1 的大作中提到】
: 听到过类似的案例，只要博士博士后期间文章有retraction 的，会过滤掉。当然其博
: 士后老板是西南医学中心的权威大牛，还是要看佛面的。
|
M**********7
发帖数: 127 | 19 撤稿了对韩主席是个好事，相当于过关了。也不会有进一步的处罚啥的（从目前国内没
有正式调查他就可以看出来） |
P****R
发帖数: 22479 | 20 撤稿是处罚
【在 M**********7 的大作中提到】
: 撤稿了对韩主席是个好事，相当于过关了。也不会有进一步的处罚啥的（从目前国内没
: 有正式调查他就可以看出来）
|
|
|
r*****0
发帖数: 122 | 21 其实 即使撤稿 对大陆疯狂造假没有警示作用
[在 PBSNPR (大刀王五) 的大作中提到：]
:撤稿是处罚 |
P****R
发帖数: 22479 | 22 造假是造假人的事，杂志不能防止造假人出现在杂志上，但是有机制将其踢出去，并且
永不录用。
没有什么警示作用，杂志社不是警察，广大读者是警察。
大陆疯狂造假是好事，帮助全世界不会承认大陆的科技能力，进一步显示大陆没有科研
能力。
【在 r*****0 的大作中提到】
: 其实 即使撤稿 对大陆疯狂造假没有警示作用
: [在 PBSNPR (大刀王五) 的大作中提到：]
: :撤稿是处罚
|
P****R
发帖数: 22479 | 23
【在 z*******x 的大作中提到】
: 我不觉得这小子Peng Yi Tenure 可以轻松过关。
|
