m****r
发帖数: 6639 | 1 we were defending, and declarer led a diamond from dummy.
my partner discards, and I failed to follow suit, and
discarded.
then declarer called for next trick, but before my partner
played, I had realized that I had "revoked", and called to
the opponents, and then the director's attention.
the revoke was established, and we suffered a 2 trick penalty
because I won more tricks after the revoke.
but when I checked the rules book, it seems to suggest that as
long as my partner had not played the ne | w****b
发帖数: 623 | 2 You are right in both cases. The director's ruling is wrong. This should be a
non-established revoke and you should only get penalty for a major penalty
card, i think.
【在 m****r 的大作中提到】
: we were defending, and declarer led a diamond from dummy.
: my partner discards, and I failed to follow suit, and
: discarded.
: then declarer called for next trick, but before my partner
: played, I had realized that I had "revoked", and called to
: the opponents, and then the director's attention.
: the revoke was established, and we suffered a 2 trick penalty
: because I won more tricks after the revoke.
: but when I checked the rules book, it seems to suggest that as
: long as my partner had not played the ne
|
|
