b*********s
发帖数: 2 | 1 At bridge, in an unimpeded auction that goes 1 Spade, 3 Spades, 5 Clubs by
North/South players. What is the 5 club bid commonly referred to? | m*e
发帖数: 155 | 2
splinter, to show void in clubs?
【在 b*********s 的大作中提到】
: At bridge, in an unimpeded auction that goes 1 Spade, 3 Spades, 5 Clubs by
: North/South players. What is the 5 club bid commonly referred to?
| a***n
发帖数: 287 | 3
1. Old-fashion splinter is to jump two levels, which in this case
is to bid 6c, to show the singleton or void.
2. To me there are lots of other ways for the "opener" to bid in
this case. If the 3S respond vitually guarantee at least game,
then there's no need to jump to 5 level.
【在 m*e 的大作中提到】
:
: splinter, to show void in clubs?
| S*c
发帖数: 29 | 4 I think it might be to ask for the key card except Club.
【在 b*********s 的大作中提到】
: At bridge, in an unimpeded auction that goes 1 Spade, 3 Spades, 5 Clubs by
: North/South players. What is the 5 club bid commonly referred to?
| c****u
发帖数: 3277 | 5 most experts play it as ERKC: void in club, so responder answers his
roman keycards except CA.
【在 b*********s 的大作中提到】
: At bridge, in an unimpeded auction that goes 1 Spade, 3 Spades, 5 Clubs by
: North/South players. What is the 5 club bid commonly referred to?
| m*e
发帖数: 155 | 6
by
level can be 1 or 2, the key is UNNECESSARY jump. I consider
4c control cuebid, so 5c would be the unnecessary jump.
but sic and cozofu are very right. it should be exclusive key card asking.
【在 a***n 的大作中提到】
:
: 1. Old-fashion splinter is to jump two levels, which in this case
: is to bid 6c, to show the singleton or void.
: 2. To me there are lots of other ways for the "opener" to bid in
: this case. If the 3S respond vitually guarantee at least game,
: then there's no need to jump to 5 level.
| c********n
发帖数: 17 | 7 Ask the partner of the 5c bidder if you play East/West. i think either old
fashion splinter or key card asking should be alertable and written on their
convention card.
If it is a casual game or you are the partner of the 5c bidder (without
previously agreed convention, unfortunately :), take it as key card (excluding
CA) asking is a safe bet and answer it with KC convention you had with your
partner. If you 2 don't even have a key card asking convention, bid 6S (or 7S,
surprisingly you have 2 A
【在 m*e 的大作中提到】
:
: by
: level can be 1 or 2, the key is UNNECESSARY jump. I consider
: 4c control cuebid, so 5c would be the unnecessary jump.
: but sic and cozofu are very right. it should be exclusive key card asking.
|
|
