j*******e
发帖数: 2168 | 1 S Qxx
H KJ
D AQJ
C KTxxx
Opened 1NT and went:
1NT 2D
2H 3C
4C(1) 4H(2)
My question:
(1)Do I need to bid 4C to show club support or can I bid 3D to start
cuebidding
immediately?
(2)Is this 4H forcing? | w****b
发帖数: 623 | 2 The popular treatment is, 3 level cuebid is advance cuebid agreeing 2nd suit
(minor) as trump. Bidding the transferred suit agrees on the 1st suit. And
bidding 3NT denies interest in either and show lots of soft values in other
two suits. So you can bid 3D to start cue. This gives you opportunity to do
something before committing past 3NT. Sometimes responder bids with 5-4-2-2
and does not really have serious interest in playing 5m.
In this sequence, responder's 4H should be non-forcing, offerin
【在 j*******e 的大作中提到】
: S Qxx
: H KJ
: D AQJ
: C KTxxx
: Opened 1NT and went:
: 1NT 2D
: 2H 3C
: 4C(1) 4H(2)
: My question:
: (1)Do I need to bid 4C to show club support or can I bid 3D to start
| x***e
发帖数: 2449 | 3
yes cue is better.
not forcing, I smell a slam interests here.
but let us clear it first, what is 3c here?
invite or gf?
looks like you are not sure.
if it is invite, and your 4c shows nothing, but strong slam interests, since
you already pass 3nt, thus the 4h means stop.
if it is game forcing, your 4c still show slam interests but in C, and 4h is
also means stop.
so I guess you need to pass after 4h.
the problem is your 4c, what you need is S, and you voided the chance that pd
could cue it in
【在 j*******e 的大作中提到】
: S Qxx
: H KJ
: D AQJ
: C KTxxx
: Opened 1NT and went:
: 1NT 2D
: 2H 3C
: 4C(1) 4H(2)
: My question:
: (1)Do I need to bid 4C to show club support or can I bid 3D to start
| j*******e
发帖数: 2168 | 4 Thanks, wimptb. This makes sense.
At the table I was a bit concerned about spade control so I passed 4H.
Pd's hand was:
S -
H AQxxx
D Txxx
C AQJx
【在 w****b 的大作中提到】
: The popular treatment is, 3 level cuebid is advance cuebid agreeing 2nd suit
: (minor) as trump. Bidding the transferred suit agrees on the 1st suit. And
: bidding 3NT denies interest in either and show lots of soft values in other
: two suits. So you can bid 3D to start cue. This gives you opportunity to do
: something before committing past 3NT. Sometimes responder bids with 5-4-2-2
: and does not really have serious interest in playing 5m.
: In this sequence, responder's 4H should be non-forcing, offerin
| f*****x
发帖数: 545 | 5 i think pd should bid 4s. His h is so broke, playing 4H will often go down
while 5c shld be cold. He can forsee defense will start with s,shortening ur
trump. 6c is not impossible. with ur hand, 3D shld be a good start. 【 在
josephine (jo) 的大作中提到: 】
suit
other
do
5-4-2-2 | w****b
发帖数: 623 | 6 I don't think so. 4S would be an overbid. Opener can reverse the S with D and
you do not have safety on 5 level. And in fact, in that case, 4H is the last
making contract.
This is a case where cuebidding at 3 level will help greatly. As you can see,
responder has no serious interest in going to C slam to begin with, cuebidding
3D would help. Now a cuebidding of 3S will either show doubt of 3NT or real
interest of C slam (in which case, he could pull out from 3NT). Opener will
assume 3S is to sho
【在 f*****x 的大作中提到】
: i think pd should bid 4s. His h is so broke, playing 4H will often go down
: while 5c shld be cold. He can forsee defense will start with s,shortening ur
: trump. 6c is not impossible. with ur hand, 3D shld be a good start. 【 在
: josephine (jo) 的大作中提到: 】
: suit
: other
: do
: 5-4-2-2
| f*****x
发帖数: 545 | 7 agree 3 level cuebid will help a lot. but still, with so weak heart suit, he
should let pd to decide where to go. In this case, 4H is not bad because pd
has doubleton KJ. but after 4C, i still think 4s is better.
What does a jump to 4H by opener mean after responder's 3c? 【 在 wimptb (一失
足成千古wimp) 的大作中提到: 】
and
see,
cuebidding
once
ur
2nd
to
spot | c****u
发帖数: 3277 | 8 opener can rebid 4S over 3D as splinter. over 3D rebid, one should be able
to show this feature. 3S isn't as descriptive as 4S.
【在 w****b 的大作中提到】
: I don't think so. 4S would be an overbid. Opener can reverse the S with D and
: you do not have safety on 5 level. And in fact, in that case, 4H is the last
: making contract.
: This is a case where cuebidding at 3 level will help greatly. As you can see,
: responder has no serious interest in going to C slam to begin with, cuebidding
: 3D would help. Now a cuebidding of 3S will either show doubt of 3NT or real
: interest of C slam (in which case, he could pull out from 3NT). Opener will
: assume 3S is to sho
| j*******e
发帖数: 2168 | 9 en, ought 4S be rkc voidwood with a void in spades?
If nothing else, it moves beyond 3NT on the strength of just opener's 3D bid,
which I am not sure is right.
and
last
see,
cuebidding
real
will
But
once
down
s,shortening ur
在
2nd
suit.
in
opportunity to
spot
【在 c****u 的大作中提到】
: opener can rebid 4S over 3D as splinter. over 3D rebid, one should be able
: to show this feature. 3S isn't as descriptive as 4S.
| c****u
发帖数: 3277 | 10 it's a splinter in standard treatment. The reason why 4S is enough is that,
when opener bids 3D, he not only implies that he had value in diamonds and
4 card support in clubs, it also shows some doubt in 3NT. Thus, he can't have
a lot of wasted value in spade. A typical hand is:
SJxx HKx DAKQx CKxxx
change his hand to:
SQJTx HKx DAK CKxxx
the right bid would be 3NT over 3C, because he has both spade and
diamonds well stopped.
However, sometimes, his hand isn't that slamish:
SQxxx HKx DAKx CKxxx
【在 j*******e 的大作中提到】
: en, ought 4S be rkc voidwood with a void in spades?
: If nothing else, it moves beyond 3NT on the strength of just opener's 3D bid,
: which I am not sure is right.
:
: and
: last
: see,
: cuebidding
: real
: will
| j*******e
发帖数: 2168 | 11 Thanks for your thoughts.
I forgot to mention that it is MP, which is the reason why
I think 3S would be a more practical call.
have
bid,
able
with D
the
can
【在 c****u 的大作中提到】
: it's a splinter in standard treatment. The reason why 4S is enough is that,
: when opener bids 3D, he not only implies that he had value in diamonds and
: 4 card support in clubs, it also shows some doubt in 3NT. Thus, he can't have
: a lot of wasted value in spade. A typical hand is:
: SJxx HKx DAKQx CKxxx
: change his hand to:
: SQJTx HKx DAK CKxxx
: the right bid would be 3NT over 3C, because he has both spade and
: diamonds well stopped.
: However, sometimes, his hand isn't that slamish:
|
|
