由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
CS版 - Why I think the paper is junk, but it still gets good simulation result?
相关主题
Why this not working?Pseudorandom Number Generator question
Re: [转载] 有关做研究谁知道这1是什么问题
How to disable cache effect这个题目怎么做?多谢。可以用DP做吗?
有没有能在单台机子上调试mpi程序的simulator? (转载)谁能提供 peer-to-peer java simulation?
Research paper vs. Industrial papervalgrind谁用过?
大家说说你们都是怎么读paper的吧.How is this conference: ECBS?
请教:到底会议的文章能不能再发journal?USC Gets $100 Million Army Contract
why is this board still not changed?ISCA results out
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: simulation话题: why话题: result话题: junk话题: still
进入CS版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
t**e
发帖数: 208
1
I think the paper is junk, but it still gets good simulation result, how to
refuse it?
Their claims seem unvalid, but they still get good simulation result, now my
boss ask me why? How to deal with such things??
m***t
发帖数: 46
2
For me, the very basic rule of thumb is to never trust a paper based on its
simulation results.
No one knows the authors' way of obtaining these results.

【在 t**e 的大作中提到】
: I think the paper is junk, but it still gets good simulation result, how to
: refuse it?
: Their claims seem unvalid, but they still get good simulation result, now my
: boss ask me why? How to deal with such things??

h****e
发帖数: 2125
3
呵呵,大学时候实验老师嫌我们小组实验结果不好,拿个女生的实验报告出来给我们看,
说你看看人家这个图表,多完美。我也没客气,冷冷的说你想要的话我半个小时后给你份
更好看的。

【在 t**e 的大作中提到】
: I think the paper is junk, but it still gets good simulation result, how to
: refuse it?
: Their claims seem unvalid, but they still get good simulation result, now my
: boss ask me why? How to deal with such things??

d******y
发帖数: 1039
4
今天据了篇文章,也是类似的问题。simulation means nothing if theoretical
results
are not sound.

【在 t**e 的大作中提到】
: I think the paper is junk, but it still gets good simulation result, how to
: refuse it?
: Their claims seem unvalid, but they still get good simulation result, now my
: boss ask me why? How to deal with such things??

p****c
发帖数: 27
5
这位兄弟这句话有严重歧视女生的嫌疑哦




【在 h****e 的大作中提到】
: 呵呵,大学时候实验老师嫌我们小组实验结果不好,拿个女生的实验报告出来给我们看,
: 说你看看人家这个图表,多完美。我也没客气,冷冷的说你想要的话我半个小时后给你份
: 更好看的。

l******e
发帖数: 153
6
而且实验和程序还是很不一样的
女生程序写的漂亮的可真是不多见...

【在 p****c 的大作中提到】
: 这位兄弟这句话有严重歧视女生的嫌疑哦
:
: ,
: 份

1 (共1页)
进入CS版参与讨论
相关主题
ISCA results outResearch paper vs. Industrial paper
sigmod 05 results is out ..大家说说你们都是怎么读paper的吧.
谁给一点思路,关于找最小值的问题请教:到底会议的文章能不能再发journal?
VLDB review is outwhy is this board still not changed?
Why this not working?Pseudorandom Number Generator question
Re: [转载] 有关做研究谁知道这1是什么问题
How to disable cache effect这个题目怎么做?多谢。可以用DP做吗?
有没有能在单台机子上调试mpi程序的simulator? (转载)谁能提供 peer-to-peer java simulation?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: simulation话题: why话题: result话题: junk话题: still