p*****g
发帖数: 996 | 1 A paper submitted to IEEE Trans. received "Major Revision" (three
reviewers,
one minor revision, one major revision, the third one unknown but he/she
raised some tough comments).
The revised version was first "under review", then after two months, the
status became "Awaiting Decision". However, after about one week, the
status
changed back to "Under Review"....
Seems not good news... Is it because the reviewer comments were too
different that the editor asked for an additional review? Or is it because
some reviewers have not provided their comments prior to the deadline?
Thanks. | l***e
发帖数: 421 | 2 I think it should be fine. Probably eventually you got "major revision" from
the AE.
【在 p*****g 的大作中提到】
: A paper submitted to IEEE Trans. received "Major Revision" (three
: reviewers,
: one minor revision, one major revision, the third one unknown but he/she
: raised some tough comments).
: The revised version was first "under review", then after two months, the
: status became "Awaiting Decision". However, after about one week, the
: status
: changed back to "Under Review"....
: Seems not good news... Is it because the reviewer comments were too
: different that the editor asked for an additional review? Or is it because
| l***e
发帖数: 421 | 3 I think it should be fine. Probably eventually you got "major revision" from
the AE.
【在 p*****g 的大作中提到】
: A paper submitted to IEEE Trans. received "Major Revision" (three
: reviewers,
: one minor revision, one major revision, the third one unknown but he/she
: raised some tough comments).
: The revised version was first "under review", then after two months, the
: status became "Awaiting Decision". However, after about one week, the
: status
: changed back to "Under Review"....
: Seems not good news... Is it because the reviewer comments were too
: different that the editor asked for an additional review? Or is it because
| w********o
发帖数: 10088 | 4 不会是我刚review的吧
【在 p*****g 的大作中提到】
: A paper submitted to IEEE Trans. received "Major Revision" (three
: reviewers,
: one minor revision, one major revision, the third one unknown but he/she
: raised some tough comments).
: The revised version was first "under review", then after two months, the
: status became "Awaiting Decision". However, after about one week, the
: status
: changed back to "Under Review"....
: Seems not good news... Is it because the reviewer comments were too
: different that the editor asked for an additional review? Or is it because
| p*****g
发帖数: 996 | 5 it seems that the journal only allows one "major revision".. :(
from
【在 l***e 的大作中提到】
: I think it should be fine. Probably eventually you got "major revision" from
: the AE.
|
|
