h*****n
发帖数: 41 | 1 一天同时收到两封decision letters. JDE accepted with minor changes, JF
rejected.
最惋惜的是JF的referee很喜欢并建议修改，而且所有的意见都是可以做的。Editor 也
挺喜欢的，可惜的是AE不喜欢。Editor 在信里说
"I know that it is frustrating to draw a referee that is on the positive
side yet the paper is rejected. Just so you know, about 50% of the positive
recommendations end up being rejected.
I am not as negative as the Associate Editor. I think, with a revision along
the lines that the referee points out, that the paper could place at JFE or
RFS. "
错失一个好机 | U*****e
发帖数: 2882 | 2 you know what I want to say?
Congratulations!
and Gook luck with your next submission!
positive
along
or
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】
: 一天同时收到两封decision letters. JDE accepted with minor changes, JF
: rejected.
: 最惋惜的是JF的referee很喜欢并建议修改，而且所有的意见都是可以做的。Editor 也
: 挺喜欢的，可惜的是AE不喜欢。Editor 在信里说
: "I know that it is frustrating to draw a referee that is on the positive
: side yet the paper is rejected. Just so you know, about 50% of the positive
: recommendations end up being rejected.
: I am not as negative as the Associate Editor. I think, with a revision along
: the lines that the referee points out, that the paper could place at JFE or
: RFS. "
| c**b
发帖数: 474 | 3 恭喜！JDE应该是第二轮修改后的结果吧？如果直接就accepted with minor changes那
可就太牛了。
还有请教一下，通常来说，第一轮被允许修改后，还被拒的事情是不是小概率事件？
positive
along
or
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】
: 一天同时收到两封decision letters. JDE accepted with minor changes, JF
: rejected.
: 最惋惜的是JF的referee很喜欢并建议修改，而且所有的意见都是可以做的。Editor 也
: 挺喜欢的，可惜的是AE不喜欢。Editor 在信里说
: "I know that it is frustrating to draw a referee that is on the positive
: side yet the paper is rejected. Just so you know, about 50% of the positive
: recommendations end up being rejected.
: I am not as negative as the Associate Editor. I think, with a revision along
: the lines that the referee points out, that the paper could place at JFE or
: RFS. "
| s***e
发帖数: 830 | 4 Cong!!!
I am just curious why the AE has such a power to change the prior decision
of the Chief E?
positive
along
or
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】
: 一天同时收到两封decision letters. JDE accepted with minor changes, JF
: rejected.
: 最惋惜的是JF的referee很喜欢并建议修改，而且所有的意见都是可以做的。Editor 也
: 挺喜欢的，可惜的是AE不喜欢。Editor 在信里说
: "I know that it is frustrating to draw a referee that is on the positive
: side yet the paper is rejected. Just so you know, about 50% of the positive
: recommendations end up being rejected.
: I am not as negative as the Associate Editor. I think, with a revision along
: the lines that the referee points out, that the paper could place at JFE or
: RFS. "
| h*****n
发帖数: 41 | 5 JDE是第二轮，一般来说，R&R后被接受的机会很大，因为如果是不确定性很大的修改，
Editor可能就不会给你这个R&R的机会了。
但是对于top journal像AER, JF，R&R被拒的事情还是经常有所听闻。但是也至少有60%
以上机会最后get in 吧。道听途说，不对之处，请高手指正。 |
|
