d*****g
发帖数: 357 | | m*********e
发帖数: 121 | 2 Seems to me to be a new, policy oriented journal. carries some articles by
well-known people. but can't be compared to any academic journal. so your
question has really no answer. | h*****n
发帖数: 924 | 3 i do not have a real answer, but suggest you check out the journal list of
domestic universities. such lists would clearly show if bijiao counts as an
academic journal, as well as its ranking.
china economic quarterly editted by peking univ did not count as academic jo
urnal in the past, because it was published as a book outside the official j
ournal series, but some good univs recognize publications
in it due to its high quality.
in sum, you need to consult an insider of the economics academia
【在 m*********e 的大作中提到】
: Seems to me to be a new, policy oriented journal. carries some articles by
: well-known people. but can't be compared to any academic journal. so your
: question has really no answer.
| m*********e
发帖数: 121 | 4 You are right. But on the other hand, journals like "foreign poilcy" and "
foreign affairs" are often counted as academic journals by American
universities, but I really do not regard them as academic journals. Depends
on your definition of "academic journals". I guess "Bijiao" is somewhere
between a policy and an academic journal.
an
jo
j
【在 h*****n 的大作中提到】
: i do not have a real answer, but suggest you check out the journal list of
: domestic universities. such lists would clearly show if bijiao counts as an
: academic journal, as well as its ranking.
: china economic quarterly editted by peking univ did not count as academic jo
: urnal in the past, because it was published as a book outside the official j
: ournal series, but some good univs recognize publications
: in it due to its high quality.
: in sum, you need to consult an insider of the economics academia
| d*****g
发帖数: 357 | 5 Thank you for your replies. I was hoping to run into an "academic insider"
of China on this forum :-) | h*****n
发帖数: 924 | 6 yes, i totally agree. the funny thing in china is, all journals and books ne
ed a series number approved by the gov't, and this number specifies it is wh
ether a book or a journal.
i guess the standard to be a journal is higher, such that some journals cann
ot be officially journals, but books. only official journals have "levels,"
s
omething stupid called level 1, level 2, authority... These levels are be
nchmarks for promotion decisions.
US academia has something similar, but it is very depart
【在 m*********e 的大作中提到】
: You are right. But on the other hand, journals like "foreign poilcy" and "
: foreign affairs" are often counted as academic journals by American
: universities, but I really do not regard them as academic journals. Depends
: on your definition of "academic journals". I guess "Bijiao" is somewhere
: between a policy and an academic journal.
:
: an
: jo
: j
|
|
