h*****g
发帖数: 35 | 1 去年5月独立投了一篇文章到一top journal,到9月收到了reviews, Associate Editor
建议"Both referees who are experts in the field are very positive about the
paper.I therefore agree with Referee 1 in that this paper could be published
in xxx. " 赶紧按referees的建议修改了,11月就投了过去, 到了今年一月份收到第二
轮review, "Associate Editor 建议 The paper has improved a lot with the last
revision. However, both referees make a series of comments which need to be
addressed for the paper to be publishable.I recommend to give the author
another opportunity | x********4
发帖数: 405 | 2 你也太心急了， 改个一两个月就投回去。下次最好多等一下， 这样referee也会觉得
你比较serious...既然第三轮了， 希望应该比较大了吧。不过你中间知改了一个月就
送回去， 有点太快了。。。我们这个profession，有的时候欲速则不达。anyway,
good luck!
Editor
the
published
last
be
【在 h*****g 的大作中提到】
: 去年5月独立投了一篇文章到一top journal,到9月收到了reviews, Associate Editor
: 建议"Both referees who are experts in the field are very positive about the
: paper.I therefore agree with Referee 1 in that this paper could be published
: in xxx. " 赶紧按referees的建议修改了,11月就投了过去, 到了今年一月份收到第二
: 轮review, "Associate Editor 建议 The paper has improved a lot with the last
: revision. However, both referees make a series of comments which need to be
: addressed for the paper to be publishable.I recommend to give the author
: another opportunity
| F****r
发帖数: 345 | 3 我觉得文章被接受的可能性很大。问题是大家很少看到顶级杂志上只需要一年就发表的
文章。审稿人大概觉得你太顺了，晾你几个月，呵呵，很正常的。另外，现在是暑假，
挺多人到处出差开会，也可能没有功夫理你的文章。
还是忙手头的其它活吧。
Editor
the
published
last
be
【在 h*****g 的大作中提到】
: 去年5月独立投了一篇文章到一top journal,到9月收到了reviews, Associate Editor
: 建议"Both referees who are experts in the field are very positive about the
: paper.I therefore agree with Referee 1 in that this paper could be published
: in xxx. " 赶紧按referees的建议修改了,11月就投了过去, 到了今年一月份收到第二
: 轮review, "Associate Editor 建议 The paper has improved a lot with the last
: revision. However, both referees make a series of comments which need to be
: addressed for the paper to be publishable.I recommend to give the author
: another opportunity
| s****0
发帖数: 42 | | d**o
发帖数: 5158 | |
|
