z***j
发帖数: 17 | 1 It seems very few scholars are studying Chinese economic history. Except C.
Shiue at Colorado, anyone else? |
j**p
发帖数: 1257 | 2 看做哪一块
1500-1900 Great Divergence 是很热的话题，历史那边很多人在做
C.
【在 z***j 的大作中提到】
: It seems very few scholars are studying Chinese economic history. Except C.
: Shiue at Colorado, anyone else?
|
z***j
发帖数: 17 | 3 I know Pomeranz in history has a book on divergence. Also, Wang Guobin (
Wong) at UCLA has a 2011 coauthored book on divergence. However, in
economics, not many scholars working on this. |
t*******i
发帖数: 255 | 4 Se Yan, at Guanghua, PKU
It seems very few scholars are studying Chinese economic history. Except C.
Shiue at Colorado, anyone else?
【在 z***j 的大作中提到】
: It seems very few scholars are studying Chinese economic history. Except C.
: Shiue at Colorado, anyone else?
|
z***j
发帖数: 17 | 5 It is difficult to find someone working on Chinese economic history in North
America.
Ray Huang (Wanli 15th nian) passed away many years ago. His macrohistory
actually borrowed from macroeconomics.
K. Chao from Wisconsin retired many years ago. |
t*******i
发帖数: 255 | 6 Also Dr Debin Ma at LSE,UK
Se Yan, at Guanghua, PKU
It seems very few scholars are studying Chinese economic history. Except C.
Shiue at Colorado, anyone else?
【在 t*******i 的大作中提到】
: Se Yan, at Guanghua, PKU
:
: It seems very few scholars are studying Chinese economic history. Except C.
: Shiue at Colorado, anyone else?
|
j**p
发帖数: 1257 | 7 能过qualify的econ博士，做经济史的本来就已经是少数了
做中国经济史当然更少。
North
【在 z***j 的大作中提到】
: It is difficult to find someone working on Chinese economic history in North
: America.
: Ray Huang (Wanli 15th nian) passed away many years ago. His macrohistory
: actually borrowed from macroeconomics.
: K. Chao from Wisconsin retired many years ago.
|
p***c
发帖数: 2403 | 8 不过qualify还能继续留在那里读么？
【在 j**p 的大作中提到】
: 能过qualify的econ博士，做经济史的本来就已经是少数了
: 做中国经济史当然更少。
:
: North
|
j**p
发帖数: 1257 | 9 想做历史可以读历史博士
econ qualify太难了
【在 p***c 的大作中提到】
: 不过qualify还能继续留在那里读么？
|
z***j
发帖数: 17 | 10 Those western scholars in economic history, like D. North and his associates
, know very limited about China, their research are Europe oriented and
actually could not explain the emergence of industralization.
Those so called western scholars in Chinese history, also know very limited
about China. For example, that famous Fei ZhenQing (J. Fairbank) could not
even speak Chinese. |
|
|
j**p
发帖数: 1257 | 11 费正清有个笑话：
某人去燕京学社访问，费正清问计划做什么研究，他回答“范仲淹”
费正清问：“who is Fan zhongyan？”
associates
limited
not
【在 z***j 的大作中提到】
: Those western scholars in economic history, like D. North and his associates
: , know very limited about China, their research are Europe oriented and
: actually could not explain the emergence of industralization.
: Those so called western scholars in Chinese history, also know very limited
: about China. For example, that famous Fei ZhenQing (J. Fairbank) could not
: even speak Chinese.
|
BR
发帖数: 4151 | 12 Astonished. How did he write all those books then?
associates
limited
not
【在 z***j 的大作中提到】
: Those western scholars in economic history, like D. North and his associates
: , know very limited about China, their research are Europe oriented and
: actually could not explain the emergence of industralization.
: Those so called western scholars in Chinese history, also know very limited
: about China. For example, that famous Fei ZhenQing (J. Fairbank) could not
: even speak Chinese.
|
z***j
发帖数: 17 | 13 Fairbank is more like a "manager". He was good at finding research grants.
He had Chinese "assistants" to help his research. Anyway, his book like "
China: a modern history" is not deep at all. |
z***j
发帖数: 17 | 14 Demand could also be a factor. At this time with China growing fast, the
demand should increase.
Qualify may not be a very large factor. I observed many passed
comprehensive exams but couuld not finish dissertations.
【在 j**p 的大作中提到】
: 能过qualify的econ博士，做经济史的本来就已经是少数了
: 做中国经济史当然更少。
:
: North
|
z***j
发帖数: 17 | 15 For He Bingdi, when he studied for his phd at Columbia, he majored in
British history. Once he got his phd, he switched to Chinese history and
became famous. He's comparative advantage lies in Chinese history even
though he did well in British history. |
