N*T 发帖数: 414 | 1 我跟我学生的工作已经发在一个很好的journal上了,下个月就登出来。后续工作投到
一个不如第一个的journal,而且这个journal还发过一些很不怎么样的文章,但是IF也
有1.0以上。结果今天收到这个journal editor发来的信,告诉我们直接被拒了,而且
没有修改的余地。只有一个reviewer 意见。我怎么感觉这个意见挺奇怪呢。
No paper on the subject of xxx is complete without a thorough explanation of
the work of xxxx and his collaborators, both students and postdocs, at xxxx
in the 1980s. Moreover, there are other contributors to this problem, in
addition to yyyyyy. Please locate and comment on all this prior work before
considering resubmissi |
p**m 发帖数: 11571 | 2 cft
xxxx的工作你也没介绍一下?
of
xxxx
before
【在 N*T 的大作中提到】 : 我跟我学生的工作已经发在一个很好的journal上了,下个月就登出来。后续工作投到 : 一个不如第一个的journal,而且这个journal还发过一些很不怎么样的文章,但是IF也 : 有1.0以上。结果今天收到这个journal editor发来的信,告诉我们直接被拒了,而且 : 没有修改的余地。只有一个reviewer 意见。我怎么感觉这个意见挺奇怪呢。 : No paper on the subject of xxx is complete without a thorough explanation of : the work of xxxx and his collaborators, both students and postdocs, at xxxx : in the 1980s. Moreover, there are other contributors to this problem, in : addition to yyyyyy. Please locate and comment on all this prior work before : considering resubmissi
|
v*******y 发帖数: 5530 | 3 怎么感觉这英语也够别扭的
of
xxxx
before
【在 N*T 的大作中提到】 : 我跟我学生的工作已经发在一个很好的journal上了,下个月就登出来。后续工作投到 : 一个不如第一个的journal,而且这个journal还发过一些很不怎么样的文章,但是IF也 : 有1.0以上。结果今天收到这个journal editor发来的信,告诉我们直接被拒了,而且 : 没有修改的余地。只有一个reviewer 意见。我怎么感觉这个意见挺奇怪呢。 : No paper on the subject of xxx is complete without a thorough explanation of : the work of xxxx and his collaborators, both students and postdocs, at xxxx : in the 1980s. Moreover, there are other contributors to this problem, in : addition to yyyyyy. Please locate and comment on all this prior work before : considering resubmissi
|
a**********d 发帖数: 2293 | 4 这段话是谁写的?我们这行editor写的的decision letter一般都比这要委婉不少,
reviewer不会说resubmit as a new paper这种话。 |
N*T 发帖数: 414 | 5 我觉得我们的paper质量还可以,肯定能找到发表的地方。只是觉得这个reviewer
comments太奇怪了。xxxx我压根儿都不知道这么个人,看来是我孤陋寡闻了。不知道这
个reviewer是不是xxx的学生。觉得我们是走错门了。
【在 p**m 的大作中提到】 : cft : xxxx的工作你也没介绍一下? : : of : xxxx : before
|
p**m 发帖数: 11571 | 6 我也因为没有引用这种只有review认识的xxx的文章被巨。
【在 N*T 的大作中提到】 : 我觉得我们的paper质量还可以,肯定能找到发表的地方。只是觉得这个reviewer : comments太奇怪了。xxxx我压根儿都不知道这么个人,看来是我孤陋寡闻了。不知道这 : 个reviewer是不是xxx的学生。觉得我们是走错门了。
|
c******a 发帖数: 633 | |
a**********d 发帖数: 2293 | 8 我最近一个rejection,其中一个reviewer让我看三篇文章,其中两篇
是同一个人的,从来没听说过这厮,而且这两篇文章都还是forthcoming,tnnd.
【在 p**m 的大作中提到】 : 我也因为没有引用这种只有review认识的xxx的文章被巨。
|
p**m 发帖数: 11571 | 9 有人的地方就有江湖啊。
【在 a**********d 的大作中提到】 : 我最近一个rejection,其中一个reviewer让我看三篇文章,其中两篇 : 是同一个人的,从来没听说过这厮,而且这两篇文章都还是forthcoming,tnnd.
|
N*T 发帖数: 414 | 10 用google scholar 找了一下,找到一篇题目看起来有点相关的xxx的80年的文章,一共
16次引用。而我们做这个领域几乎没有不知道yyy的,他的这个topic的文章一大把,引
用加起来好几百。我家LD分析的是,估计不知道怎么得罪主编了,故意给了一个对头
reviewer哪里,而且一般都是送3个review,我这个只有一个人review,意见还莫名其
妙。
换一处地方投吧。
【在 c******a 的大作中提到】 : 看来你真的要看看xxxx的文章了
|
|
|
t**********t 发帖数: 12071 | 11 以前还碰到过要我一定引国内某个大学发表在某个没听说过的JOURNAL上的文章,而且
是跟我的文章没有关系的。 |
r****e 发帖数: 3109 | 12 just send it somewhere else, since you haven't wasted much time anyway.
of
xxxx
before
【在 N*T 的大作中提到】 : 我跟我学生的工作已经发在一个很好的journal上了,下个月就登出来。后续工作投到 : 一个不如第一个的journal,而且这个journal还发过一些很不怎么样的文章,但是IF也 : 有1.0以上。结果今天收到这个journal editor发来的信,告诉我们直接被拒了,而且 : 没有修改的余地。只有一个reviewer 意见。我怎么感觉这个意见挺奇怪呢。 : No paper on the subject of xxx is complete without a thorough explanation of : the work of xxxx and his collaborators, both students and postdocs, at xxxx : in the 1980s. Moreover, there are other contributors to this problem, in : addition to yyyyyy. Please locate and comment on all this prior work before : considering resubmissi
|
y***e 发帖数: 6082 | 13 这种情况很大程度上就是这个editor或者editorial board里面的人
我跟我学生的工作已经发在一个很好的journal上了,下个月就登出来。后续工作投到
一个不如第一个的journal,而且这个journal还发过一些很不怎么样的文章,但是IF也
有1.0以上。结果今天收到这个journal editor发来的信,告诉我们直接被拒了,而且
没有修改的余地。只有一个reviewer 意见。我怎么感觉这个意见挺奇怪呢。
No paper on the subject of xxx is complete without a thorough explanation of
the work of xxxx and his collaborators, both students and postdocs, at xxxx
in the 1980s. Moreover, there are other contributors to this problem, in
addition to yyyyyy. Please locate and comment on all thi
【在 N*T 的大作中提到】 : 我跟我学生的工作已经发在一个很好的journal上了,下个月就登出来。后续工作投到 : 一个不如第一个的journal,而且这个journal还发过一些很不怎么样的文章,但是IF也 : 有1.0以上。结果今天收到这个journal editor发来的信,告诉我们直接被拒了,而且 : 没有修改的余地。只有一个reviewer 意见。我怎么感觉这个意见挺奇怪呢。 : No paper on the subject of xxx is complete without a thorough explanation of : the work of xxxx and his collaborators, both students and postdocs, at xxxx : in the 1980s. Moreover, there are other contributors to this problem, in : addition to yyyyyy. Please locate and comment on all this prior work before : considering resubmissi
|
t***b 发帖数: 19 | 14 hehe, pls see the following of some reviewer's comments
There are two issues that I take serious objection to in this paper. The
first one I am sure no one will listen to my thoughts on the matter of
concern. I utterly detest the **** acronym. It is just beyond the limits
for me and sounds so inane as to make you wonder why anyone would think it
is either appropriate or worth being associated with it. I am speaking very
bluntly here because I think there is value for the authors to think ab
【在 a**********d 的大作中提到】 : 这段话是谁写的?我们这行editor写的的decision letter一般都比这要委婉不少, : reviewer不会说resubmit as a new paper这种话。
|
x3 发帖数: 616 | 15 very blunt
very
about
a
【在 t***b 的大作中提到】 : hehe, pls see the following of some reviewer's comments : There are two issues that I take serious objection to in this paper. The : first one I am sure no one will listen to my thoughts on the matter of : concern. I utterly detest the **** acronym. It is just beyond the limits : for me and sounds so inane as to make you wonder why anyone would think it : is either appropriate or worth being associated with it. I am speaking very : bluntly here because I think there is value for the authors to think ab
|
n***p 发帖数: 7668 | 16 The acronym may really be insane, if it is not a widely used one.
very
about
a
【在 t***b 的大作中提到】 : hehe, pls see the following of some reviewer's comments : There are two issues that I take serious objection to in this paper. The : first one I am sure no one will listen to my thoughts on the matter of : concern. I utterly detest the **** acronym. It is just beyond the limits : for me and sounds so inane as to make you wonder why anyone would think it : is either appropriate or worth being associated with it. I am speaking very : bluntly here because I think there is value for the authors to think ab
|