g*y
发帖数: 2354 | 1 大意：
Several colleagues had similar experience at the submission stage; the
editor asked them for three more citations to his journal before he would
send their manuscript out for review. Note, these citation requests were not
motivated by omitted content; they simply asked authors to cite related
articles in the editor’s journal.
This practice is controversial. Some view it as inappropriate behavior,
padding citations and diluting the value of the reference list. Others see
it as a legitimate wa |
w********h
发帖数: 12367 | 2 遇见过，也就一次。
不过你既然想在那个杂志上发表，给这个杂志最近的文章一些特别关注也是应该的，
有助于提高杂志的IF，同时对自己也好。。。
not
editor
【在 g*y 的大作中提到】
: 大意：
: Several colleagues had similar experience at the submission stage; the
: editor asked them for three more citations to his journal before he would
: send their manuscript out for review. Note, these citation requests were not
: motivated by omitted content; they simply asked authors to cite related
: articles in the editor’s journal.
: This practice is controversial. Some view it as inappropriate behavior,
: padding citations and diluting the value of the reference list. Others see
: it as a legitimate wa
|
g*y
发帖数: 2354 | 3 有道理。
【在 w********h 的大作中提到】
: 遇见过，也就一次。
: 不过你既然想在那个杂志上发表，给这个杂志最近的文章一些特别关注也是应该的，
: 有助于提高杂志的IF，同时对自己也好。。。
:
: not
: editor
|
c******a
发帖数: 633 | 4 你要是觉得这个杂志和你无关为什么还投它呢？加几个引用不就证明你投对地方了吗？ |
