由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Faculty版 - 怎么做好一个会议panel的moderator
相关主题
NSF panel 这个问题需要指出来吗?这个invitation要接受吗?
有没有人听到关于CAREER的消息了first time in a proposal review panel
Panel Session 对应的中文是什么请教NSF PANEL REVIEW的程序
真心求教被邀请NSF的panlist现在nsf就是撞大运
NSF panel summaryIs it ok to contact NSF program manager around 4.8 months after proposal submission?
NSF是不是变态了就没戏了postdoc 能胜任NSF panel吗?
[合集] 当PANELIST的麻烦NSF Review Panel
NSF panelistCAREER悲剧了
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: moderator话题: scope话题: discussion话题: panel话题: need
进入Faculty版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
m********t
发帖数: 9426
1
第一次被邀请做,完全没有经验
一个会议的panel,一整天
由一个moderator主持,四个panelist,然后上午是broad discussion
我需要做介绍,同时给个大方向的talk,四个panelists(本方向越牛的越好)加入,各
自给talk
然后下午会有几个paper sessions
请教版上有经验的前辈,这个moderator的定位是什么?主持人?有什么要注意的么?
panelists需要是big names,都比我出名多了,怎么协调?
谢谢!
m********t
发帖数: 9426
2
re
请有经验的指点一下

【在 m********t 的大作中提到】
: 第一次被邀请做,完全没有经验
: 一个会议的panel,一整天
: 由一个moderator主持,四个panelist,然后上午是broad discussion
: 我需要做介绍,同时给个大方向的talk,四个panelists(本方向越牛的越好)加入,各
: 自给talk
: 然后下午会有几个paper sessions
: 请教版上有经验的前辈,这个moderator的定位是什么?主持人?有什么要注意的么?
: panelists需要是big names,都比我出名多了,怎么协调?
: 谢谢!

S*****s
发帖数: 242
3
You don't really have to do too much as a moderator or chair but behave as a
policeman to keep things in order, such as order of talks, keeping the time
, etc
In your talk, you will need to prepare several slides (one or two slides are
normally sufficient) as an overview for today’s topics and scope. You need
to know what those guys are going to talk about. However, this is going to
be VERY brief because you are talking in front of experts and you don’t
want to get in troubles with the details.
For the broad discussion, it will be a little challenge. A better session
will need to be under the control. You will need to come up an overall scope
of discussion, summary of each topic before transition to others and a
brief summary of important points/highlights. It happens sometime that the
discussion is out of control (getting into lengthy arguments, out of scope
etc). It is your job to get the session back to the track. There is no way
to prepare for these situations but you should sense these "dangers" and
find some ways to cool things down, such as have a "right" joke, look at a
clock saying “we are running out time” etc.
It is a good experience to chair a panel with a couple of guys who are big
names in the field because this is a very good way to know each other.
However don’t be shy to express yourself. You are invited to be a moderator
and you are somebody already, right?

【在 m********t 的大作中提到】
: 第一次被邀请做,完全没有经验
: 一个会议的panel,一整天
: 由一个moderator主持,四个panelist,然后上午是broad discussion
: 我需要做介绍,同时给个大方向的talk,四个panelists(本方向越牛的越好)加入,各
: 自给talk
: 然后下午会有几个paper sessions
: 请教版上有经验的前辈,这个moderator的定位是什么?主持人?有什么要注意的么?
: panelists需要是big names,都比我出名多了,怎么协调?
: 谢谢!

m********t
发帖数: 9426
4
thanksssss!

a
time
are
need
to
scope

【在 S*****s 的大作中提到】
: You don't really have to do too much as a moderator or chair but behave as a
: policeman to keep things in order, such as order of talks, keeping the time
: , etc
: In your talk, you will need to prepare several slides (one or two slides are
: normally sufficient) as an overview for today’s topics and scope. You need
: to know what those guys are going to talk about. However, this is going to
: be VERY brief because you are talking in front of experts and you don’t
: want to get in troubles with the details.
: For the broad discussion, it will be a little challenge. A better session
: will need to be under the control. You will need to come up an overall scope

1 (共1页)
进入Faculty版参与讨论
相关主题
CAREER悲剧了NSF panel summary
NSF panelNSF是不是变态了就没戏了
NSF 如何审理和决定重投的proposal[合集] 当PANELIST的麻烦
NSF panel的住宿问题NSF panelist
NSF panel 这个问题需要指出来吗?这个invitation要接受吗?
有没有人听到关于CAREER的消息了first time in a proposal review panel
Panel Session 对应的中文是什么请教NSF PANEL REVIEW的程序
真心求教被邀请NSF的panlist现在nsf就是撞大运
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: moderator话题: scope话题: discussion话题: panel话题: need