r*****u 发帖数: 94 | 1 收到Mathematical Reviews(MR)的邀请去做reviewer。
觉得比较搞笑,哪有reviewer还要发正式邀请信的。
由于不是数学领域的,所以花时间网上查了一下,也没有看出个所以然来。
好像就说这个杂志的reviewer大部分是editor选出来的。
不知道有没有人有类似的经验?这个东西算professional service吗?
谢谢了. |
X******2 发帖数: 5859 | 2 没什么鸟用,不用去浪费时间了。
【在 r*****u 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 收到Mathematical Reviews(MR)的邀请去做reviewer。 : 觉得比较搞笑,哪有reviewer还要发正式邀请信的。 : 由于不是数学领域的,所以花时间网上查了一下,也没有看出个所以然来。 : 好像就说这个杂志的reviewer大部分是editor选出来的。 : 不知道有没有人有类似的经验?这个东西算professional service吗? : 谢谢了.
|
z**5 发帖数: 221 | 3 (1) It is NORMAL to issue invitation letters for review requests. Almost all
scientific journals I know use this method.
(2) MR is NOT a journal in the regular sense. It is more like an indexing/
review service by AMS.
(3) Reviewing for MR can be counted as professional service.
【在 r*****u 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 收到Mathematical Reviews(MR)的邀请去做reviewer。 : 觉得比较搞笑,哪有reviewer还要发正式邀请信的。 : 由于不是数学领域的,所以花时间网上查了一下,也没有看出个所以然来。 : 好像就说这个杂志的reviewer大部分是editor选出来的。 : 不知道有没有人有类似的经验?这个东西算professional service吗? : 谢谢了.
|
n***p 发帖数: 7668 | 4 MR 应该只保留它的Indexing Service 而将 Review 去掉。我实在不觉得它的Review
有什么用处。
all
【在 z**5 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : (1) It is NORMAL to issue invitation letters for review requests. Almost all : scientific journals I know use this method. : (2) MR is NOT a journal in the regular sense. It is more like an indexing/ : review service by AMS. : (3) Reviewing for MR can be counted as professional service.
|
z**5 发帖数: 221 | 5 Math is a unique discipline in which most people do not understand what most
other people are doing. The reviews from MR serve as a quick explanation of
the paper's merits and weaknesses to those who do not understand it.
【在 n***p 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : MR 应该只保留它的Indexing Service 而将 Review 去掉。我实在不觉得它的Review : 有什么用处。 : : all
|
n***p 发帖数: 7668 | 6 I think the abstract serves that purpose.
most
of
【在 z**5 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : Math is a unique discipline in which most people do not understand what most : other people are doing. The reviews from MR serve as a quick explanation of : the paper's merits and weaknesses to those who do not understand it.
|