p****l
发帖数: 175 | 1 Submit last November, got decline email yesterday. In the review comment,
the program director said: if you would like to chat in the next several
weeks, I can sent email to him to arrange a time to chat, so he could have
time to better prepare for the conversation. My reviews EVGGG.
我读了comments，有些不赞成，明显reviewer没有明白，我应该电话里如何跟director
讨论？谢谢大家建议！ |
r*****e
发帖数: 620 | 2 这么好的review, 要一个eager是有可能的吧
director
【在 p****l 的大作中提到】
: Submit last November, got decline email yesterday. In the review comment,
: the program director said: if you would like to chat in the next several
: weeks, I can sent email to him to arrange a time to chat, so he could have
: time to better prepare for the conversation. My reviews EVGGG.
: 我读了comments，有些不赞成，明显reviewer没有明白，我应该电话里如何跟director
: 讨论？谢谢大家建议！
|
p****l
发帖数: 175 | 3 如何问director要eager呀？还是director会提如果他觉得合适？根据以前的经验，
good is not good at nsf. |
f********n
发帖数: 54 | |
s********n
发帖数: 4346 | 5 is it the first submission? Then I definitely will ask for feedback to
improve the proposal for resubmission. You can also ask him about the
reviewer's comments if you think they misunderstand and see what PO says.
【在 p****l 的大作中提到】
: 如何问director要eager呀？还是director会提如果他觉得合适？根据以前的经验，
: good is not good at nsf.
|
p****l
发帖数: 175 | 6 MCB. Yes,1st submission. |
s********n
发帖数: 4346 | 7 Then don't give up. Revise and resubmit. Pay extra attention to panel
summery.
【在 p****l 的大作中提到】
: MCB. Yes,1st submission.
|
e****e
发帖数: 158 | 8 同问如何要EAGER？
【在 p****l 的大作中提到】
: 如何问director要eager呀？还是director会提如果他觉得合适？根据以前的经验，
: good is not good at nsf.
|
|
p****l
发帖数: 175 | 9 刚刚跟director电话谈了一个小时，就是给了建议，问了EAGER，说不能给，如果有别
的idea可以联系。 |
n******g
发帖数: 14 | |
r*********g
发帖数: 1160 | 11 请问你这个是MCB哪个子program？
director
【在 p****l 的大作中提到】
: Submit last November, got decline email yesterday. In the review comment,
: the program director said: if you would like to chat in the next several
: weeks, I can sent email to him to arrange a time to chat, so he could have
: time to better prepare for the conversation. My reviews EVGGG.
: 我读了comments，有些不赞成，明显reviewer没有明白，我应该电话里如何跟director
: 讨论？谢谢大家建议！
|
