x****5
发帖数: 1564 | 1 今天打球遇到一个情况，开球右歪，又开一个左歪但明显处于不错的攻果岭位置。到前
面一看，第一个球在一棵树的树根下，树的枝杈很低，肯定没法打，当时没怎么想，把
球掏出来就去打那第二个暂定球了，那个球打个par，再算第一个开球加一个罚杆，就
是双鸡了。后来想起这个球，其实可以趴到树下，用杆把球扒拉出来，也很可能有攻果
岭的线路，如果那样的话，也是有可能打个鸡的。另外一个选择是宣布不可打，在树附
近不更靠近国岭的两杆范围内抛球，这样攻果岭的那一杆是第三杆，也是很有希望抓鸡
的。而且这样看来抛球可能最有利。
这样考虑对不对？如果不是下水或出界，应该抛球最有利？打暂定最亏？ |
c*****c
发帖数: 30 | 2 from http://www.usga.org/ourexpertsexplain.aspx?id=2147497678
If you find your original ball, you must abandon the provisional ball, even
if you decide to deem your original ball unplayable. You cannot use the
provisional ball even if you decide to proceed under Rule 28a, the stroke
and distance option of the unplayable ball Rule.
So you have to play the original ball. |
x****5
发帖数: 1564 | 3 多谢指点，看来俺这一轮disqualified.鱼兄弟不战而胜了。
争取明天再打一场来pk吧。
even
【在 c*****c 的大作中提到】
: from http://www.usga.org/ourexpertsexplain.aspx?id=2147497678
: If you find your original ball, you must abandon the provisional ball, even
: if you decide to deem your original ball unplayable. You cannot use the
: provisional ball even if you decide to proceed under Rule 28a, the stroke
: and distance option of the unplayable ball Rule.
: So you have to play the original ball.
|
n***n
发帖数: 247 | 4 找到原来的球就必须打 (包括别人帮你找到）， 但是你可以不找， 直接去打
provisional. |
u*********r
发帖数: 2735 | 5 another case: assume you did not find the first ball initially, however,
after
you used the provisional ball for the next shot, you saw that "lost" ball.
and the ruling is? I had a big fight over this before ...
even
【在 c*****c 的大作中提到】
: from http://www.usga.org/ourexpertsexplain.aspx?id=2147497678
: If you find your original ball, you must abandon the provisional ball, even
: if you decide to deem your original ball unplayable. You cannot use the
: provisional ball even if you decide to proceed under Rule 28a, the stroke
: and distance option of the unplayable ball Rule.
: So you have to play the original ball.
|
i****e
发帖数: 913 | 6 在你奔Provisional Ball去之前, 你要声明一下, 你的第一个球丢了.
这样即便再"找"回来也不算数了.
关于丢球,出界,暂定球的规则和裁定, 可以看官方的Rule&Decision 27.
https://www.usga.org/Rule-Books/Rules-of-Golf/Rule-27/
https://www.usga.org/Rule-Books/Rules-of-Golf/Decision-27/
【在 u*********r 的大作中提到】
: another case: assume you did not find the first ball initially, however,
: after
: you used the provisional ball for the next shot, you saw that "lost" ball.
: and the ruling is? I had a big fight over this before ...
:
: even
|
ET
发帖数: 10701 | 7 you know Phil's case.
He really wanted to claim his ball lost, but the audience found it so Phil
had to play it
【在 i****e 的大作中提到】
: 在你奔Provisional Ball去之前, 你要声明一下, 你的第一个球丢了.
: 这样即便再"找"回来也不算数了.
: 关于丢球,出界,暂定球的规则和裁定, 可以看官方的Rule&Decision 27.
: https://www.usga.org/Rule-Books/Rules-of-Golf/Rule-27/
: https://www.usga.org/Rule-Books/Rules-of-Golf/Decision-27/
|
t***u
发帖数: 2057 | 8 所以积极帮找球的很多都是坏人，哈哈。
【在 ET 的大作中提到】
: you know Phil's case.
: He really wanted to claim his ball lost, but the audience found it so Phil
: had to play it
|
t***u
发帖数: 2057 | 9 学习了，我一般也是尽量找第一个，争取不罚杆或不可打抛球罚一杆。不过有时抛球不
好抛的，那就纠结了。比如进右侧林子树根下，往左侧出林子两杆距离抛球可以吗？这
样不是离果岭近了？还是必须在球的两杆范围抛球，不出林子。不可以回原地重打吗？
依然有点困惑，还得回去啃规则。
even
【在 c*****c 的大作中提到】
: from http://www.usga.org/ourexpertsexplain.aspx?id=2147497678
: If you find your original ball, you must abandon the provisional ball, even
: if you decide to deem your original ball unplayable. You cannot use the
: provisional ball even if you decide to proceed under Rule 28a, the stroke
: and distance option of the unplayable ball Rule.
: So you have to play the original ball.
|
s*****c
发帖数: 753 | 10 You surely can go back to the original location. But you can't call the
provisional ball as your attempt. When you find your original ball, the
provisional ball is invalid. You have to physically went back and hit again
.
Also, you can drop the ball in the line that radiates from hole and passes
through where the ball lies, which will move you back out of the trees.
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: 学习了，我一般也是尽量找第一个，争取不罚杆或不可打抛球罚一杆。不过有时抛球不
: 好抛的，那就纠结了。比如进右侧林子树根下，往左侧出林子两杆距离抛球可以吗？这
: 样不是离果岭近了？还是必须在球的两杆范围抛球，不出林子。不可以回原地重打吗？
: 依然有点困惑，还得回去啃规则。
:
: even
|
