h******d
发帖数: 4761 | 1 http://www.handloads.com/misc/stoppingpower.asp?Caliber=2&Weigh
22 Long Rifle Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Quik Shok HP 10 4 40% 0" 6.7"
CCI Stinger HP 465 178 38% 0.28" 7.3"
Winchester HP 654 196 30% 0.29" 9.6"
Federal HP 722 214 30% 0.26" 8.8"
Remington HP 988 296 29% 0.25" 9.1"
Winchester Solid 1644 348 21% 0.22" 11.8"
223 Remington Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Remington 69 gr JHP 40 39 98% 0.32" 16.9"
Winchester 68 gr Match 38 37 97% 0.37" 18.5"
Federal 40 gr 162 156 96% 0" 9.8" Fragments
SS109 62 gr 283 272 96% 0" 15.7" Breaks into 2 pieces
Winchester 52 gr 41 39 95% 0" 8.8" Fragments
Winchester 64 gr PP 21 20 95% 0" 9.1" Fragments
Federal 52 gr Match 37 35 95% 0" 9.4" Fragments
Federal 55 gr JHP 112 105 94% 0" 9.2" Fragments
Federal 55 gr Nosler 27 25 93% 0.38" 11.8"
Winchester 55 gr JSP 41 38 93% 0" 10.4" Breaks into 2
pieces
Remington 55 gr JSP 36 33 92% 0" 8.7" Breaks into 2
pieces
Federal 62 gr JHP 48 44 92% 0" 9.7" Fragments
Remington 55 gr FMJ 46 42 91% 0" 10.3" Breaks into 2
pieces
Winchester 55 gr FMJ 123 113 83% 0" 12.3" Breaks into 2
pieces
308 Winchester Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Winchester 168 gr Match 28 27 98% 0" 23.8" Breaks into
2 pieces
Federal 168 gr Match 112 110 98% 0" 24.9" Breaks into 2
pieces
IMI 168 gr Match 213 209 98% 0" 25.1" Breaks into 2
pieces
Military 168 gr Match 124 122 98% 0" 0" Through and
through, routinely exited human target
Remington 168 gr Match 40 39 98% 0" 24.7" Breaks into 2
pieces
Black Hills 168 gr Match 38 37 97% 0" 22.7" Breaks into
2 pieces
Federal 165 gr TBBC 40 38 95% 0.58" 0" Through and
through, routinely exited human target |
h******d
发帖数: 4761 | 2 9 mm Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Federal 124 gr HS 243 202 83% 0.67" 14.5"
Federal 124 gr Nyclad 265 220 83% 0.69" 14.3"
Winchester 115 gr ST 421 349 83% 0.64" 13.7"
Remington 115 gr JHP 265 217 82% 0.58" 14.3"
Federal 115 gr JHP 382 317 82% 0.56" 13.6"
Federal 124 gr Nyclad 44 36 82% 0.56" 13.1" 4" barrel
or less
Winchester 115 gr ST 40 32 80% 0.55" 11.1" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 115 gr JHP 54 43 80% 0.53" 11.5" 4" barrel or
less
Remington 115 gr JHP 49 39 80% 0.5" 12.8" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 147 gr HS 74 59 80% 0.46" 13.9" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 135 gr HS 10 8 80% 0.53" 10.9" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 135 gr HS 334 267 80% 0.52" 14.9"
Speer 115 gr JHP 121 97 80% 0.59" 14.6"
Federal 124 gr HS 25 20 80% 0.52" 12.6" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 147 gr HS 304 240 79% 0.51" 17.1"
Winchester 147 gr BT 84 66 79% 0.47" 15.3" 4" barrel or
less
Winchester 147 gr BT 259 203 78% 0.53" 16.3"
Federal 147 gr JHP 71 55 78% 0.62" 18.3"
Winchester 115 gr FMJ 315 221 70% 0.35" 17.5"
Winchester 115 gr FMJ 24 14 58% 0.35" 17.2" 4" barrel
or less
9 mm +P Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Corbon 115 gr JHP 51 45 88% 0.73" 11.2"
Speer 124 gr GD 74 65 88% 0.71" 13.6"
Remington 124 gr GS 50 43 86% 0.52" 12.2" 4" barrel or
less
Remington 124 gr GS 14 12 86% 0.67" 13.9"
Speer 124 gr GD 55 47 85% 0.56" 11.6" 4" barrel or less
Corbon 115 gr JHP 10 8 80% 0.59" 10.2" 4" barrel or
less
45 ACP Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Remington 185 gr GS 83 80 96% 0.69" 12.4"
Federal 230 gr HS 173 166 96% 0.76" 13.9"
CCI 230 gr GD 45 42 93% 0.68" 12.2"
Corbon 185 gr JHP 20 18 90% 0.78" 11.1"
Remington 185 gr GS 39 35 90% 0.62" 11.3" 4" barrel or
less
Remington 230 gr GS 10 9 90% 0.73" 12.9"
Federal 230 gr HS 28 25 89% 0.68" 12.9" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 185 gr HS 78 69 88% 0.67" 12.9"
Federal 185 gr JHP 128 112 88% 0.71" 11.6"
CCI 200 gr JHP 139 122 88% 0.73" 12.4"
Winchester 230 gr BT 96 84 88% 0.75" 13.9"
Winchester 185 gr ST 121 106 88% 0.78" 11.5"
Winchester 185 gr ST 27 23 85% 0.67" 10.2" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 165 gr HS PD 38 32 84% 0.59" 14.7"
Winchester 230 gr BT 26 21 81% 0.69" 13.1" 4" barrel or
less
Remington 185 gr JHP 145 117 81% 0.64" 13.6"
Remington 230 gr FMJ 151 94 62% 0.45" 19.1"
Winchester 230 gr FMJ 209 130 62% 0.45" 19.9"
Federal 230 gr FMJ 215 134 62% 0.45" 20.4"
Federal 230 gr FMJ 15 9 60% 0.45" 14.2" 4" barrel or
less
Winchester 230 gr FMJ 34 20 59% 0.45" 13.7" 4" barrel
or less
Remington 230 gr FMJ 14 8 57% 0.45" 14.2" 4" barrel or
less
45 Colt Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Federal 225 gr LHP 36 29 81% 0.51" 14.9"
Winchester 225 gr ST 45 36 80% 0.58" 13.1"
Winchester 255 gr LRN 21 15 71% 0.45" 16.8"
Remington 250 gr LRN 10 7 70% 0.45" 18.3"
40 S&W Stopping Power, all bullet weights
Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
Penetration Notes
Remington 165 gr GS 146 137 94% 0.7" 13.9"
CCI 155 gr GD 59 55 93% 0.67" 14.2"
Federal 155 gr HS 88 82 93% 0.73" 13.6"
Corbon 135 gr JHP 9 8 89% 0.69" 10.4" 4" barrel or less
Speer 155 gr GD 18 16 89% 0.65" 11.9" 4" barrel or less
Corbon 135 gr JHP 56 50 89% 0.74" 10.9"
Federal 155 gr JHP 139 124 89% 0.68" 11.8"
Remington 165 gr GS 61 54 89% 0.68" 12.6" 4" barrel or
less
Corbon 150 gr JHP 40 35 88% 0.71" 11.3"
Federal 155 gr HS 24 21 88% 0.69" 12.6" 4" barrel or
less
Remington 155 gr 41 36 88% 0.63" 12.9"
Winchester 155 gr ST 106 93 88% 0.74" 11.2"
Federal 180 gr HS 65 57 88% 0.66" 15.6"
Federal 180 gr HS 30 26 86% 0.59" 12.9" 4" barrel or
less
Remington 180 gr GS 78 67 86% 0.63" 12.7"
PMC 155 gr 49 42 86% 0.65" 13.9"
CCI 180 gr GD 63 54 86% 0.63" 12.6"
Corbon 180 gr JHP 21 18 86% 0.63" 11.4"
Winchester 180 gr BT 157 132 84% 0.68" 15.8"
Starfire 180 gr JHP 51 43 84% 0.61" 14.2"
Federal 180 gr 100 84 84% 0.65" 13.1"
Remington 180 gr GS 25 21 84% 0.62" 12.2" 4" barrel or
less
Federal 180 gr JHP 32 27 84% 0.67" 12.9" 4" barrel or
less
Black Hills 180 gr JHP 44 37 84% 0.67" 13.3"
Winchester 180 gr JHP 159 132 83% 0.61" 14.3"
Federal 165 gr HS 112 93 83% 0.51" 16.8"
Federal 155 gr JHP 22 18 82% 0.54" 11.1" 4" barrel or
less
Winchester 180 gr BT 34 27 79% 0.47" 14.2" 4" barrel or
less
Winchester 180 gr JHP 46 36 78% 0.46" 13.9" 4" barrel
or less
Winchester 180 gr FMJ 94 67 71% 0.4" 19.2"
Winchester 0 gr FMJ 28 17 61% 0.4" 16.7" 4" barrel or
less |
h******d
发帖数: 4761 | 3 看来.45则一定要.45 ACP 的， .45colt弱太多了。
.40SW很不错的！， 9MM有点弱。 |
d**********t
发帖数: 1821 | 4 转来的总结
No.1 manstopper per 1 shot stop percentages and with a long street record is
:.357 Magnum 125 Grain JHP out of a service revolver
With stopping power that was rated at 96%
No. 2. was .45 ACP +P in 230 grain and some 185 grain +p versions. Hard to
argue with a shining service record of a century.
No. 3. (around 90%) switches between 9 and .40, but I think fully stoked
modern .40 has a clear advantage over 9mm +p now |
P****8
发帖数: 678 | 5 这样看着很费劲，能给出网址吗？
【在 h******d 的大作中提到】
: 看来.45则一定要.45 ACP 的， .45colt弱太多了。
: .40SW很不错的！， 9MM有点弱。
|
H****r
发帖数: 16240 | 6 活活，经典台词：
-It's a Colt Python.
-What kind of load do you use?
-158-grain semi-wadcutter manstoppers.
-Sensible weapon.
-I use a factory-accurized Detonics .45 Scoremaster.
It's got the extended barrel, short hammer fall...
...and I load with 230-grain full patch rounds.
It's primarily for stopping power.
-On the other hand, if you want penetration...
...the .357 will crack the engine block of a truck.
-I can see where that would be useful.
is
【在 d**********t 的大作中提到】
: 转来的总结
: No.1 manstopper per 1 shot stop percentages and with a long street record is
: :.357 Magnum 125 Grain JHP out of a service revolver
: With stopping power that was rated at 96%
: No. 2. was .45 ACP +P in 230 grain and some 185 grain +p versions. Hard to
: argue with a shining service record of a century.
: No. 3. (around 90%) switches between 9 and .40, but I think fully stoked
: modern .40 has a clear advantage over 9mm +p now
|
h******d
发帖数: 4761 | 7 看来俺要修订案的手枪口径选择了，暂定．４０ ｓｗ
is
【在 d**********t 的大作中提到】
: 转来的总结
: No.1 manstopper per 1 shot stop percentages and with a long street record is
: :.357 Magnum 125 Grain JHP out of a service revolver
: With stopping power that was rated at 96%
: No. 2. was .45 ACP +P in 230 grain and some 185 grain +p versions. Hard to
: argue with a shining service record of a century.
: No. 3. (around 90%) switches between 9 and .40, but I think fully stoked
: modern .40 has a clear advantage over 9mm +p now
|
h******d
发帖数: 4761 | |
S**********s
发帖数: 4534 | 9 Afaik, no .357 magnum can do that yet, unless this is some kind of special
tungsten cored magic bullet...
【在 H****r 的大作中提到】
: 活活，经典台词：
: -It's a Colt Python.
: -What kind of load do you use?
: -158-grain semi-wadcutter manstoppers.
: -Sensible weapon.
: -I use a factory-accurized Detonics .45 Scoremaster.
: It's got the extended barrel, short hammer fall...
: ...and I load with 230-grain full patch rounds.
: It's primarily for stopping power.
: -On the other hand, if you want penetration...
|
P****8
发帖数: 678 | 10 Same boat here!
【在 h******d 的大作中提到】
: 看来俺要修订案的手枪口径选择了，暂定．４０ ｓｗ
:
: is
|
|
|
r*******0
发帖数: 706 | |
S*******T
发帖数: 5156 | |
T**r
发帖数: 7016 | |
h******d
发帖数: 4761 | 14 综合指标吧？ 焦耳'速度'空腔'散布.....
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.3
【在 T**r 的大作中提到】
: 请教stop power是用什么做单位的？
|
f*******t
发帖数: 157 | 15 友情提醒一下，刚开始玩枪的喜欢one shot stop，玩到后来都更相信rapid fire的效
果 |
a***a
发帖数: 8941 | 16 Just a number (scalar), no unit
Actually "stopping power" is never a well defined thing. Someone lean more
on bullet diameter or bullet weight, while others emphasize more on energy.
Some people gave some formula to define the so-called stopping power, but
that is only accepted in some people, not a universally accepted definition.
It is just not that simple to calculate stopping power
【在 T**r 的大作中提到】
: 请教stop power是用什么做单位的？
|
h******d
发帖数: 4761 | 17 有道理
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.3
【在 a***a 的大作中提到】
: Just a number (scalar), no unit
: Actually "stopping power" is never a well defined thing. Someone lean more
: on bullet diameter or bullet weight, while others emphasize more on energy.
: Some people gave some formula to define the so-called stopping power, but
: that is only accepted in some people, not a universally accepted definition.
: It is just not that simple to calculate stopping power
|
h**********r
发帖数: 2284 | 18 Choosing good 9mm +P ammo, which is better than some .45 already.
And one can practice more with 9mm. This actually re-enforce the idea of
promoting 9mm +P imho.
【在 h******d 的大作中提到】
: 9 mm Stopping Power, all bullet weights
: Brand Bullet Shootings One Shot Stops Percent Diameter
: Penetration Notes
: Federal 124 gr HS 243 202 83% 0.67" 14.5"
: Federal 124 gr Nyclad 265 220 83% 0.69" 14.3"
: Winchester 115 gr ST 421 349 83% 0.64" 13.7"
: Remington 115 gr JHP 265 217 82% 0.58" 14.3"
: Federal 115 gr JHP 382 317 82% 0.56" 13.6"
: Federal 124 gr Nyclad 44 36 82% 0.56" 13.1" 4" barrel
: or less
|
P****8
发帖数: 678 | |
h*********2
发帖数: 2508 | 20 It's an urban legend. The sound of racking the slide has a lot of stopping
power too.
【在 T**r 的大作中提到】
: 请教stop power是用什么做单位的？
|
h**********r
发帖数: 2284 | 21 I cannot tell the difference between 9mm +p 124gr vs .40sw - given that I've
shot them side-to-side before.
I cannot tell the difference between 9mm +p 124gr vs 9mm 124gr fmj - given
that I've shot them side-to-side before.
I can feel the big difference between .45 and 9mm though (quite a few shot
was off the 1st time I tried .45, but could only master it after quite a few
rounds later).
【在 P****8 的大作中提到】
: 9MM+P子弹的后座力比。40如何？
|
