b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 1 也算是阅读笔记，和大家同享。
AAO decision的原文在
http://www.uscis.gov/uscis-ext-templating/uscis/jspoverride/errFrameset.jsp
1. 2009年1月 deny. 理由: The evidence of record does not establish that the
petitioner has distinguished himself to such an
extent that he may be said to have achieved sustained national or
international acclaim or to be
within the small percentage at the very top of his field
这个IO的意思是国际认可以及业内顶尖两项有一即可。不同IO的尺度各不一样，很多IO会要求两项都有。
2. 2009年1月 deny. 理由: The plain language of the regulatory criterion |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 2 3. 2009年1月,deny. 理由:
The November 20, 2006 RFE states that the evidence previously submitted concerning the petitioner S "accomplishments
and accolades as a competitive swimmer" was not dispositive of her claim for eligibility as a swimming coach and does not imply that all evidence concerning all competitive swimming is irrelevant. The
petitioner's misunderstanding as to what was required of her does not amount to a failure by USCIS to follow its regulations nor a failure to adequately place th |
T*****E
发帖数: 1785 | |
T*****E
发帖数: 1785 | 4 The petitioner submitted articles about him in publications such as ABC, Sur
, El Mundo, and El Pais. In response to the director's request for evidence,
the petitioner submitted circulation statistics and
Spanish newspaper rankings showing that these publications qualify as major
media. As such, the petitioner has established that he meets this criterion.
这一项不同IO的尺度差异很大。这个case的IO要求不高，但我本人的
original submission里已说明了很多publication并证明相应杂志are among the top
且我的文章被引用上百次，但IO还是要求我出示更多材料证明这些文章的original an |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 5 4. 2009年1月,deny. 理由:
Although documentation of these various awards appears in the record,
information about the significance of and national or international
recognition of the festivals is notably absent...In addition, the petitioner
did not submit secondary evidence, such as news articles or letters from
sponsoring organizations, documenting the prestige associated with his
awards that would indicate their national or international recognition as
awards for excellence in his field.
其实这个申请者不少奖 |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 6 对哦，偶看错了。刚改过来了。
The petitioner submitted articles about him in publications such as ABC, Sur
, El Mundo, and El Pais. In response to the director's request for evidence,
the petitioner submitted circulation statistics and
Spanish newspaper rankings showing that these publications qualify as major
media. As such, the petitioner has established that he meets this criterion.
【在 T*****E 的大作中提到】
: The petitioner submitted articles about him in publications such as ABC, Sur
: , El Mundo, and El Pais. In response to the director's request for evidence,
: the petitioner submitted circulation statistics and
: Spanish newspaper rankings showing that these publications qualify as major
: media. As such, the petitioner has established that he meets this criterion.
: 这一项不同IO的尺度差异很大。这个case的IO要求不高，但我本人的
: original submission里已说明了很多publication并证明相应杂志are among the top
: 且我的文章被引用上百次，但IO还是要求我出示更多材料证明这些文章的original an
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 7 5. 2009年1月,deny. 理由:
(申请人帮推荐人搞定某东东)
While 推荐人 stated that the beneficiary assisted him in his work, he does
not indicate that the petitioner has made any major contributions to the
field of zoology. In fact, he indicated that the
petitioner's work is what is expected of the purpose of scientific research.
The evidence does not establish that the petitioner meets this criterion.
范围太窄了。只对一个人有用，自然不被承认有多大贡献
The petitioner submitted a "sample of the synopsis' of her lecture,
-." The petitioner submit |
a*****n
发帖数: 5158 | 8
concerning the petitioner S "accomplishments
for eligibility as a swimming coach and does not imply that all evidence
concerning all competitive swimming is irrelevant. The
amount to a failure by USCIS to follow its regulations nor a failure to
adequately place the petitioner on notice of deficiencies in her original
submission.
many
as
这个我看到有个律师将IO驳倒了
说Nobel 得奖者要进入美国的话，他肯定不是在做一模一样的东西，同一个林鱼的运动
员与
coach是in the same field
103
accompanied
and
."
publications
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 3. 2009年1月,deny. 理由:
: The November 20, 2006 RFE states that the evidence previously submitted concerning the petitioner S "accomplishments
: and accolades as a competitive swimmer" was not dispositive of her claim for eligibility as a swimming coach and does not imply that all evidence concerning all competitive swimming is irrelevant. The
: petitioner's misunderstanding as to what was required of her does not amount to a failure by USCIS to follow its regulations nor a failure to adequately place th
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 9 6. 2009年1月,deny. 理由:
Secondly, while these awards may result from nationally or internationally
recognized festivals, they do not
amount to awards from a major, internationally recognized film festival.
There is no evidence establishing the
international significance and magnitude of these competitions. For example,
the petitioner submitted no
evidence to show that the winner of these festivals received international
media attention in the general or film
media of multiple countries worldwide or |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 10 7. 2009年1月15日,deny. 理由:
We also note that the article was dated 1998, almost nine years before this
petition was filed and is not consistent with sustained acclaim
猛发一篇文章后沉寂多年，这种不持续也是被拒的理由之一。 |
|
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 11 8. 2009年1月22日,refused. 理由: 格式不符
9. 2009年1月23日,deny. 理由: 不知所云 |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 12 10. 2009年1月27日,deny. 理由:
Not only does the evidence not show that outstanding achievements are
required for membership, but it also does not show that VSD membership
applications are judged by national or international experts in
the field.
值得一提的是，outstanding和extraordinary achievement的membership 门槛才能被
认可。IEEE senior member要求的significant contribution，以前足够了，但现在也
不够。
The regulation at 8 C.F.R. tj 103.2(b)(3) requires that a foreign language
document "be accompanied by a full English language transl |
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 13 RFE 通常给多长时间啊？
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 10. 2009年1月27日,deny. 理由:
: Not only does the evidence not show that outstanding achievements are
: required for membership, but it also does not show that VSD membership
: applications are judged by national or international experts in
: the field.
: 值得一提的是，outstanding和extraordinary achievement的membership 门槛才能被
: 认可。IEEE senior member要求的significant contribution，以前足够了，但现在也
: 不够。
: The regulation at 8 C.F.R. tj 103.2(b)(3) requires that a foreign language
: document "be accompanied by a full English language transl
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 14 我的给了1个月。我的材料准备得差不多了，打算这个周末开始打印装订。
【在 A*********r 的大作中提到】
: RFE 通常给多长时间啊？
|
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 15 nice!!!!! Bless!!!!
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 我的给了1个月。我的材料准备得差不多了，打算这个周末开始打印装订。
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 16 谢谢！ 唉，我要早这么认真就好了。
【在 A*********r 的大作中提到】
: nice!!!!! Bless!!!!
|
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 17 不知者不罪了。祝马到成功！！！！
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 谢谢！ 唉，我要早这么认真就好了。
|
w***c
发帖数: 709 | |
v****h
发帖数: 245 | |
g****x
发帖数: 3862 | 20 very useful! thanks a lot!
Hope we can form a study group!
the
IO会要求两项都有。
8
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 也算是阅读笔记，和大家同享。
: AAO decision的原文在
: http://www.uscis.gov/uscis-ext-templating/uscis/jspoverride/errFrameset.jsp
: 1. 2009年1月 deny. 理由: The evidence of record does not establish that the
: petitioner has distinguished himself to such an
: extent that he may be said to have achieved sustained national or
: international acclaim or to be
: within the small percentage at the very top of his field
: 这个IO的意思是国际认可以及业内顶尖两项有一即可。不同IO的尺度各不一样，很多IO会要求两项都有。
: 2. 2009年1月 deny. 理由: The plain language of the regulatory criterion
|
|
|
s***2
发帖数: 106 | |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 22 11. 2009年1月28日,deny. 理由:
Part 6 of the Form 1-140 petition,"Basic information about the proposed
employment," states that the petitioner "will continue to instruct students
in the Isshinryu form of karate, as well as compete in tournaments." The
record, however, does not include evidence showing that the petitioner, age
47 at the time of filing, has worked as an instructor
未来计划不能空想。
The petitioner claims to have satisfied this criterion by virtue of her
membership in at least three organizations |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 23 12. 2009年1月29日,deny. 理由:
Similarly, the research fellowship does not amount to a nationally or
internationally recognized prize or award for excellence in the field of
endeavor...Again, the petitioner presents no information concerning the
significance of and national or international recognition of the award, the
selection criteria, or information about ACLAM. For all of the above reasons
, the petitioner fails to meet this criterion.
有朋友几年前申请EB1A，那时他从学校拿到的research fellowship被算做有效award。
现在一般的国家 |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 24 12. 2009年1月29日,deny. 理由:
Similarly, the research fellowship does not amount to a nationally or
internationally recognized prize or award for excellence in the field of
endeavor...Again, the petitioner presents no information concerning the
significance of and national or international recognition of the award, the
selection criteria, or information about ACLAM. For all of the above reasons
, the petitioner fails to meet this criterion.
有朋友几年前申请EB1A，那时他从学校拿到的research fellowship被算做有效award。
现在一般的国家 |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 25 12. 2009年1月29日,deny. 理由:
Similarly, the research fellowship does not amount to a nationally or
internationally recognized prize or award for excellence in the field of
endeavor...Again, the petitioner presents no information concerning the
significance of and national or international recognition of the award, the
selection criteria, or information about ACLAM. For all of the above reasons
, the petitioner fails to meet this criterion.
有朋友几年前申请EB1A，那时他从学校拿到的research fellowship被算做有效award。
现在一般的国家 |
J********i
发帖数: 50662 | 26 赞
12. 2009年1月29日,deny. 理由:
Similarly, the research fellowship does not amount to a nationally or
internationally recognized prize or award for excellence in the field of
endeavor...Again, the petitioner presents no information concerning the
significance of and national or international recognition of the award, the
selection criteria, or information about ACLAM. For all of the above reasons
, the petitioner fails to meet this criterion.
有朋友几年前申请EB1A，那时他从学校拿到的research fellowship被算做有效award。
现在一般
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 12. 2009年1月29日,deny. 理由:
: Similarly, the research fellowship does not amount to a nationally or
: internationally recognized prize or award for excellence in the field of
: endeavor...Again, the petitioner presents no information concerning the
: significance of and national or international recognition of the award, the
: selection criteria, or information about ACLAM. For all of the above reasons
: , the petitioner fails to meet this criterion.
: 有朋友几年前申请EB1A，那时他从学校拿到的research fellowship被算做有效award。
: 现在一般的国家
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 27 13. 2009年1月30日,deny. 理由:
The petitioner also submitted an article posted in the "Biz Roundup" section
of The Business Monthly's internet site. With regard to the preceding
articles, we note that their author was not identified as required by the
plain language of this regulatory criterion. Further, there is no evidence
showing that The Business Monthly and N24's online edition qualify as major
media.
这儿看到个新鲜玩意：媒体报导的作者如果匿名，似乎报导就不算数了。
We acknowledge the petitioner's submission of several reference |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 28 没时间一个个看了。从最新的开始。
2009年9月30日,deny. 理由:
To qualify as major media, the publication should have significant national
or international distribution. An alien would not earn acclaim at the
national level from a local publication. Some newspapers, such as the New
York Times, nominally serve a particular locality but would qualify as major
media because of significant national distribution, unlike small local
community papers
这个套话看到很多遍了。好奇IO的模板是怎样的 :)
申请人claim这项:
Published material about the alien in p |
a*****n
发帖数: 5158 | 29
national
major
field
,
published
his
Regarding
the
do
to
addressed
3)
other
过？
citation用来支持authorship可以
但他用来支持media report不行
很显然petitioner claim了authorship, media report and...
that
is
to
original
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 没时间一个个看了。从最新的开始。
: 2009年9月30日,deny. 理由:
: To qualify as major media, the publication should have significant national
: or international distribution. An alien would not earn acclaim at the
: national level from a local publication. Some newspapers, such as the New
: York Times, nominally serve a particular locality but would qualify as major
: media because of significant national distribution, unlike small local
: community papers
: 这个套话看到很多遍了。好奇IO的模板是怎样的 :)
: 申请人claim这项:
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 30 那就是这方面不同IO的尺度也差异很大啦。在我自己的case里，IO就认为footnote
citation说服力不够。
http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t0/Immigration/31658115.html
citation用来支持authorship可以
但他用来支持media report不行
很显然petitioner claim了authorship, media report and...
【在 a*****n 的大作中提到】
:
: national
: major
: field
: ,
: published
: his
: Regarding
: the
: do
|
|
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 31 2009年9月29日,deny. 理由:
As stated above, in 1995, the petitioner was invited to judge JCT Limited's
Asia Fashion Design Competition based on her receipt of an award during the
1994 competition. The director determined
that because the petitioner's award at this competition, the sole basis for
her selection as a judge, was insufficient to meet the awards criterion at 8
C.F.R. $204.5(h)(3)(i), her service as a judge could not
serve to meet this criterio.
这点很重要。申明judgement时，不但要出示judgement本身，还要证明因为特殊贡献 |
s***2
发帖数: 106 | |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 33 2009年9月29日,deny. 理由:
In addition, the petitioner submitted an article from the Filipino Times &
Asian Review, ... While the article notes the diversified background of the
petitioner, such as ballet, choir, modeling, and founder of a rock band, the
article is not about the petitioner in her field of endeavor as a filmmaker
. The single sentence which references her claimed field indicates that the
petitioner "freelances as an actress and producer to fund her forays into
creating independent film |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 34 2009年9月29日,deny. 理由:
While the beneficiary's development of an interviewer training program and
an employment vendor management program helped to benefit Credit Suisse's
business operations, there is no evidence demonstrating that these programs
constitute original contributions of major significance in the beneficiary's
field. For example, there is no evidence showing that the beneficiary's two
programs have impacted the human resources industry beyond her former
employer.
非original contributio |
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 36 2009年9月29日,deny. 理由:
Counsel's response to the director's request for additional evidence states
that the petitioner does not claim to meet this criterion and counsel does
not challenge the director's failure to address this criterion on appeal. We
note that the petitioner initially submitted evidence of his membership in
Sigma Xi, which requires a "noteworthy" achievement. According to the
material submitted initially, however, a
"noteworthy" achievement is defined as a publication, patent, wri |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 37 2009年9月24日,deny. 理由:
Articles of the society regulates that senior members of the society may be
those who have chief physician, professor, research fellow or corresponding
professional title, high academic prestige, or have be engaged in the circle
for more than 30 years and have got remarkable
achievement and important contribution in acupuncture and moxibustion field,
furthermore can keep membership in the society for a long time, love and
support work of the society and can implement obligat |
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 38 还没交呢。
一篇非一作的文章被引用很多次，其中很多是真引用，赞扬了文章的某种思路。而这种
思路实际是我提出并证明的，只是因为离开了那个group才没挂成第一作者。
反正证据不嫌多，我就请人写信证明我的original contribution。正等信呢。
另外觉得读读AAO还是很有帮助的。打算再读几篇，然后将RFE的回复再改一遍。
【在 A*********r 的大作中提到】
: 你已经交了RFE了么？还是还在写？
|
a*****n
发帖数: 5158 | 39 你去找你的
journal author guide关于authorship的
我发现一般都有
Authorship
All authors should have made substantial contributions to all of the
following: (1) the conception and design of the study, or acquisition of
data, or analysis and interpretation of data, (2) drafting the
article or revising it critically for important intellectual content,
(3) final approval of the version to be submitted.
Authors
Authors are individuals who have significantly contributed to the
research and preparation of the article;
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 还没交呢。
: 一篇非一作的文章被引用很多次，其中很多是真引用，赞扬了文章的某种思路。而这种
: 思路实际是我提出并证明的，只是因为离开了那个group才没挂成第一作者。
: 反正证据不嫌多，我就请人写信证明我的original contribution。正等信呢。
: 另外觉得读读AAO还是很有帮助的。打算再读几篇，然后将RFE的回复再改一遍。
|
A*********r
发帖数: 8271 | 40 应该是。读熟了，你写东西就有移民官想看到的buzz word了。
别弄得太厚。
【在 b*******1 的大作中提到】
: 还没交呢。
: 一篇非一作的文章被引用很多次，其中很多是真引用，赞扬了文章的某种思路。而这种
: 思路实际是我提出并证明的，只是因为离开了那个group才没挂成第一作者。
: 反正证据不嫌多，我就请人写信证明我的original contribution。正等信呢。
: 另外觉得读读AAO还是很有帮助的。打算再读几篇，然后将RFE的回复再改一遍。
|
|
|
b*******1
发帖数: 1352 | 41 你这办法好。谢谢。
不过我暂时不需了。刚收到我以前的老板按我意思写的信，确认被多人赞扬的那个idea
是我提出并证明的。
【在 a*****n 的大作中提到】
: 你去找你的
: journal author guide关于authorship的
: 我发现一般都有
: Authorship
: All authors should have made substantial contributions to all of the
: following: (1) the conception and design of the study, or acquisition of
: data, or analysis and interpretation of data, (2) drafting the
: article or revising it critically for important intellectual content,
: (3) final approval of the version to be submitted.
: Authors
|
