z****h 发帖数: 24 | 1 绿卡真是折磨人啊!3月中提交的case被NOID了,claimed的三条全部被一个模板文件否
决,性别和专业都是错的。6月中回复NOID并且加了PP,心想横竖就是一个死活,正反
给个说法吧。结果又等来一个RFE by TSC XM#1105。潜水了这么久很少看到被折磨两
回的,没想到自己是within this kind of SMALL percentage。。。
RFE很短,#1105 只质疑了Contribution,但是并没有提到其他两条(authorship和
review)是否通过。大家的RFE有这种情况么?我在板上看到的case好像都是有明确表
示每一个claimed item是否accepted。RFE的全文如下:
Orignal Contribution:
In order to satifisfy this criterion, you must provide documentary evidences
demonstrating...has made a demonstrative original contribution of major
significa |
w***j 发帖数: 241 | 2 XM1105 seems to like to challenge all cases with this kind of RFE.
Good luck!! |
m**g 发帖数: 573 | 3 You have a good chance to pass. I think the IO have the intention to let
you pass. |
v*******a 发帖数: 759 | 4 1105, same here!
claimed authorship, contribution, review, media and received rfe on
contribution and media
exactly the same words in my rfe on contributions...
我觉得不提的两条应该是承认了吧? |
z****h 发帖数: 24 | 5 我记得你就是先被1105 RFE然后通过的吧?
你收到的是一模一样的RFE letter么?能够share你的RFE回复么?非常感谢
【在 w***j 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : XM1105 seems to like to challenge all cases with this kind of RFE. : Good luck!!
|
z****h 发帖数: 24 | 6 hand/
你打算怎么回复?有律师还是DIY的?
【在 v*******a 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 1105, same here! : claimed authorship, contribution, review, media and received rfe on : contribution and media : exactly the same words in my rfe on contributions... : 我觉得不提的两条应该是承认了吧?
|
z********o 发帖数: 3895 | |
l****6 发帖数: 220 | 8 bless!应该说好好回复的话,过的机会很大啊。
觉得还是要强调硬证据啊,你那么好的硬证据不用,去引一大段的reference很不划算
啊!至少你要坚持把硬证据的东西加进去,IO就喜欢看点比例,top多少的东东。
good luck! |
a****z 发帖数: 182 | |
v*******a 发帖数: 759 | 10 hand hand!
我是DIY的,准备强调一下文章,引用排名啥的,还有一些review对我文章的引用,
希望能过吧,也祝你好运!
【在 z****h 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : hand/ : 你打算怎么回复?有律师还是DIY的?
|
|
|
t******6 发帖数: 1657 | |
k*******n 发帖数: 2399 | 12 bless,,, you r stron..
evidences
【在 z****h 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 绿卡真是折磨人啊!3月中提交的case被NOID了,claimed的三条全部被一个模板文件否 : 决,性别和专业都是错的。6月中回复NOID并且加了PP,心想横竖就是一个死活,正反 : 给个说法吧。结果又等来一个RFE by TSC XM#1105。潜水了这么久很少看到被折磨两 : 回的,没想到自己是within this kind of SMALL percentage。。。 : RFE很短,#1105 只质疑了Contribution,但是并没有提到其他两条(authorship和 : review)是否通过。大家的RFE有这种情况么?我在板上看到的case好像都是有明确表 : 示每一个claimed item是否accepted。RFE的全文如下: : Orignal Contribution: : In order to satifisfy this criterion, you must provide documentary evidences : demonstrating...has made a demonstrative original contribution of major
|
z****h 发帖数: 24 | 13 So you will only defend contribution and assume the other two are accepted?
My lawyer suggested to get two more recommendation letters, though I think
hard evidence is more important...
【在 v*******a 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : hand hand! : 我是DIY的,准备强调一下文章,引用排名啥的,还有一些review对我文章的引用, : 希望能过吧,也祝你好运!
|
v*******a 发帖数: 759 | 14 yes, I will just defend against each of his/her questions. I think it's a
relatively easy rfe to reply as most of the questions were very specific,
e.g. meeting sizes, big shots attending the meetings, expert
recognition...
good luck!
accepted?
think
【在 z****h 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : So you will only defend contribution and assume the other two are accepted? : My lawyer suggested to get two more recommendation letters, though I think : hard evidence is more important...
|
A*********r 发帖数: 8271 | 15 这个律师好怪。通常法律写作的,大抵都喜欢用大标题,小标题,数字的。大家都喜欢
bullet points。不过,我个人就不喜欢把图表放到论述中去。我个人也喜欢用文字的。 |
g****x 发帖数: 3862 | 16 真不敢相信这么强的case都没组织好。或许这个IO 就是喜欢发RFE吧。
既然强调了"documented evidence", 那明显的就是要拿硬证据拉。
Bless! |
j****g 发帖数: 587 | 17 你的律师有问题.
1a,按照老大讲的,主要是硬证据.甚至,极端点的ID讲,推荐信都不需要.
你律师搞的结构,先空话,再家推荐人讲话,完全是和EB1A背道而驰. |
F**p 发帖数: 1046 | 18 我想移民局审case的混乱程度,大家可以想象了:NOID之后RFE,每次都套用模板。我
估计这个IO根本就没有意识到,这是一个NOID的回复。
再组织一下材料吧。没什么证据好挖,IO不会介意你以前都交了什么的。 |
l*****g 发帖数: 740 | 19 Whatever, you got another chance, big bless! |
z*****a 发帖数: 1214 | 20 好奇一问,有没有推荐信通过的1a实例吗?
【在 j****g 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 你的律师有问题. : 1a,按照老大讲的,主要是硬证据.甚至,极端点的ID讲,推荐信都不需要. : 你律师搞的结构,先空话,再家推荐人讲话,完全是和EB1A背道而驰.
|
|
|
d*********s 发帖数: 390 | |
g****x 发帖数: 3862 | 22 MUST HAVE. SOME OLD TEMPLATES ARE ALL ABOUT QUOTES FROM REFERNECE LETTERS.
【在 z*****a 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 好奇一问,有没有推荐信通过的1a实例吗?
|
l******5 发帖数: 3030 | 23 你的律师是帮你捡了个RFE. 大段地论述, 你以为IO会愿意看? 有硬证据为什么不用,
实在不行甩了律师自己做吧。 俺老大提醒你一句, 只要IO未提及YOU MET, 这一条你
就要当成RFE来回复。 所以俺老大认为你不能光是回复CONTRIBUTION。
evidences
【在 z****h 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 绿卡真是折磨人啊!3月中提交的case被NOID了,claimed的三条全部被一个模板文件否 : 决,性别和专业都是错的。6月中回复NOID并且加了PP,心想横竖就是一个死活,正反 : 给个说法吧。结果又等来一个RFE by TSC XM#1105。潜水了这么久很少看到被折磨两 : 回的,没想到自己是within this kind of SMALL percentage。。。 : RFE很短,#1105 只质疑了Contribution,但是并没有提到其他两条(authorship和 : review)是否通过。大家的RFE有这种情况么?我在板上看到的case好像都是有明确表 : 示每一个claimed item是否accepted。RFE的全文如下: : Orignal Contribution: : In order to satifisfy this criterion, you must provide documentary evidences : demonstrating...has made a demonstrative original contribution of major
|
y***u 发帖数: 1467 | 24 I got RFE from same XM1105 and the RFE is very smilar to your case ( on
contribution) but the letter even shorter ( just the first paragraph of your
RFE)
Bless to all of us!
evidences
【在 z****h 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 绿卡真是折磨人啊!3月中提交的case被NOID了,claimed的三条全部被一个模板文件否 : 决,性别和专业都是错的。6月中回复NOID并且加了PP,心想横竖就是一个死活,正反 : 给个说法吧。结果又等来一个RFE by TSC XM#1105。潜水了这么久很少看到被折磨两 : 回的,没想到自己是within this kind of SMALL percentage。。。 : RFE很短,#1105 只质疑了Contribution,但是并没有提到其他两条(authorship和 : review)是否通过。大家的RFE有这种情况么?我在板上看到的case好像都是有明确表 : 示每一个claimed item是否accepted。RFE的全文如下: : Orignal Contribution: : In order to satifisfy this criterion, you must provide documentary evidences : demonstrating...has made a demonstrative original contribution of major
|
z*********c 发帖数: 47 | 25 I got RFE from the same person 1105.
He/she challenged 2 of my 4 claims with just one sentence for each, then
denied all the 4 claims when he/she got the responding letter! |
r*****f 发帖数: 176 | 26 crap, I am preparing the RFE for this IO now...
【在 z*********c 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : I got RFE from the same person 1105. : He/she challenged 2 of my 4 claims with just one sentence for each, then : denied all the 4 claims when he/she got the responding letter!
|
w****e 发帖数: 2210 | 27 1105看来是个RFE狂人。
我也收到类似的不着边际的RFE. |
w****e 发帖数: 2210 | |
F**p 发帖数: 1046 | 29 我猜是1105拿了一堆PP的eb1,然后发了一堆没有目的的RFE,99%的可能是没有看材料
。把以前发过的,重新整理一下,发出去好了。 |
v*******a 发帖数: 759 | 30 scared!
【在 z*********c 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : I got RFE from the same person 1105. : He/she challenged 2 of my 4 claims with just one sentence for each, then : denied all the 4 claims when he/she got the responding letter!
|
|
|
y******g 发帖数: 40 | 31 I got a great help from Guo for my RFE and it was approved today. He is a
trustable lawyer compared with a lot of lawyers on the
mitbbs web and he will offer a nice service and very reseanable price.
Daniel Guo, Attorney At Law
The Law Office of Daniel Guo, P.C.
San Diego, CA 92122
phone: (858) 869-9208
email: l******************[email protected]
web: www.lawofficeofdanielguo.com
5) June 16, sent out RFE
6) June 29, got update mail from USCIS, said it will give the answer in 60
days
7) Contact my law |
y******g 发帖数: 40 | 32 I got a great help from Guo for my RFE and it was approved today. He is a
trustable lawyer compared with a lot of lawyers on the
mitbbs web and he will offer a nice service and very reseanable price.
Daniel Guo, Attorney At Law
The Law Office of Daniel Guo, P.C.
San Diego, CA 92122
phone: (858) 869-9208
email: l******************[email protected]
web: www.lawofficeofdanielguo.com
5) June 16, sent out RFE
6) June 29, got update mail from USCIS, said it will give the answer in 60
days
7) Contact my law |
w****e 发帖数: 2210 | 33 我的被1105RFE后,已经aproved了。
我可以负责人的说XM#1105是个好同志。 |