f****D
发帖数: 4745 | 1 都是这样的吗
弱问一个文章要写多少字的REVIEW呀？ | v******e
发帖数: 1715 | 2 嗯！似乎多了，匀点给我吧！嗬嗬
【在 f****D 的大作中提到】
: 都是这样的吗
: 弱问一个文章要写多少字的REVIEW呀？
| T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 3 Try to get on the TPC (technical program committee), if possible, that is
better for you to boast about. Your efforts to review 8 papers are already
what a TPC member would contribute anyway.
Review really has no definite requirements. Probably different fields are
different in this requirement as well. You may read what others reviewed
about your papers, and do the similar thing.
For myself, I typically write in this 八股文:
1. What I understand about this paper on its purpose and result. Which part
is new, good, or promising, etc. This is so called "praising" phase.
2. What questions I have about the paper, which parts are not clear, or need
more experiments, what comparison (with other algorithms, or on different
datasets, etc) I am expecting, etc. This is so called "criticizing" phase.
3. Regarding the structure, grammar, and general presentation, I may say a
few things, point out the typos I've noticed, etc.
Finally you need to make a decision, just follow your judgement, accepting
or rejecting is both okay.
【在 f****D 的大作中提到】
: 都是这样的吗
: 弱问一个文章要写多少字的REVIEW呀？
| g********e
发帖数: 1142 | 4 最好是能不同的会，多个review，多点diversity比较好。 |
|
