j*******3
发帖数: 940 | 1 并没有单独claim membership, 只是放在contribution里提了，在noid信里还是被io质
疑我的membership。具体如下：
1. Documentation of the alien's membership in associations in the academic
field which require outstanding achievements of their members.
The petitioner submitted evidence that the beneficiary became a Fellow of
the American xxx in 2011. In addition, the evidence shows that the process
for becoming a Fellow includes application, the submission of written
material, and an oral exam, The materials explain that scientific candidates
such as the beneficiary must have at least three scientific publications,
and that the oral examination is based upon the credentials and written
materials submitted by the candidate, Minimum requirements such as education
, employment in the field, payment of dues or, in this case, a minimum level
of work product, are not outstanding achievements and thus cannot serve to
meet the requirements of this criterion.
2. The petitioner has submitted evidence of the beneficiary's membership as
a Fellow in the XXXX. As discussed above, the evidence does not establish
that this membership is indicative of international recognition in the field
of xxx, The materials indicate that the process of becoming a fellow "is
designed to help the candidate develop as a professional," and there is no
indication that it is meant as an indicator of outstanding professional
achievement"
我现在在准备回复，打算放弃关于membership这一点。具体应该怎么写，怎么措辞？请
大家帮忙。有包子。 | j*******3
发帖数: 940 | | l****i
发帖数: 2772 | 3 我觉得，直接不要提membership，重点回复其他的几点。纯个人意见。good luck! | h*****l
发帖数: 785 | 4 既然提到了membership，就说说这个协会的reputation是多大多大，member的遴选是多
严格多严格，最后强调只有最优秀的人、最被公认的人才能入选。
bless | j*******3
发帖数: 940 | 5 "The materials indicate that the process of becoming a fellow "is
designed to help the candidate develop as a professional," and there is no
indication that it is meant as an indicator of outstanding professional
achievement"
IO从我交的材料里揪出这句话"is designed to help the candidate develop as a
professional,"。所以我觉得再怎么解释他都觉得这个membership不够格，我也咨询了
律师，打算索性放弃，因为我本来也没有单独claim。 | h*****l
发帖数: 785 | 6 没试过放弃一个claim，担心如果放弃一个，可能会被认为找到软肋了，进而招致更严
的评判。如果是1A，会比较冒险。如果是1b或是niw，应该问题不大。 | j*******3
发帖数: 940 | 7 谢谢！包子奉上。
我是1b, claim的是老三样，membership是放在contribution里说的，觉得IO一下就注
意到了这个membership,然后就认为不能证明我outstanding，随后就到处找碴，忽视。
。所以觉得索性放弃和他argue这个membership，集中精力回复其他的。
【在 h*****l 的大作中提到】
: 没试过放弃一个claim，担心如果放弃一个，可能会被认为找到软肋了，进而招致更严
: 的评判。如果是1A，会比较冒险。如果是1b或是niw，应该问题不大。
|
|
