p*********r
发帖数: 24 | 1 should simply be "wu-speaking areas", which include southern jiangsu, the
whole shanghai, much of zhejiang, and small tips in southeastern anhui.
then there is a distinction b/w northern wu and southern wu. in a more
strict version, jiangnan only denotes northern wu area, which does not
include zhejiang's taizhou, jinghua, wenzhou, quzhou.
northern wu is very coherent -- any two people can communicate, while
southern wu is very diversified, often not intelligible across one mountain. | p***n
发帖数: 344 | 2 人家江西号称江南西道，你这不把人家排除了？
mountain.
【在 p*********r 的大作中提到】
: should simply be "wu-speaking areas", which include southern jiangsu, the
: whole shanghai, much of zhejiang, and small tips in southeastern anhui.
: then there is a distinction b/w northern wu and southern wu. in a more
: strict version, jiangnan only denotes northern wu area, which does not
: include zhejiang's taizhou, jinghua, wenzhou, quzhou.
: northern wu is very coherent -- any two people can communicate, while
: southern wu is very diversified, often not intelligible across one mountain.
| s*******e
发帖数: 3077 | 3 胡说八道
典型的上海人狭隘思维
江南从来就不是靠语言来定义的
mountain.
【在 p*********r 的大作中提到】
: should simply be "wu-speaking areas", which include southern jiangsu, the
: whole shanghai, much of zhejiang, and small tips in southeastern anhui.
: then there is a distinction b/w northern wu and southern wu. in a more
: strict version, jiangnan only denotes northern wu area, which does not
: include zhejiang's taizhou, jinghua, wenzhou, quzhou.
: northern wu is very coherent -- any two people can communicate, while
: southern wu is very diversified, often not intelligible across one mountain.
| i*********n
发帖数: 324 | 4 这问题扯不清楚
【在 s*******e 的大作中提到】
: 胡说八道
: 典型的上海人狭隘思维
: 江南从来就不是靠语言来定义的
:
: mountain.
| s*******e
发帖数: 3077 | 5 的确扯不清楚
所以摆脱楼主不要轻易说什么precise definition
【在 i*********n 的大作中提到】
: 这问题扯不清楚
| d*****l
发帖数: 8441 | 6 那么吴王统治的地方算不算啊？
mountain.
【在 p*********r 的大作中提到】
: should simply be "wu-speaking areas", which include southern jiangsu, the
: whole shanghai, much of zhejiang, and small tips in southeastern anhui.
: then there is a distinction b/w northern wu and southern wu. in a more
: strict version, jiangnan only denotes northern wu area, which does not
: include zhejiang's taizhou, jinghua, wenzhou, quzhou.
: northern wu is very coherent -- any two people can communicate, while
: southern wu is very diversified, often not intelligible across one mountain.
|
|
