d********f
发帖数: 43471 | 1 【 以下文字转载自 Physics 讨论区 】
发信人: tyhj (tyhj), 信区: Physics
标 题: 和REFEREE 讨论转行, 得到如下回复， 是啥意思
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Mon Oct 4 18:11:21 2010, 美东)
Finally, the paper ends with a question to the referee, asking for an
opinion
concerning going to a graduate school to study FINANCE. This question,
I guess,
is not supposed to appear in the printed version, so I suggest to
remove it from
the next version of the paper. In response to this question, I have to
say that I do
not have enough information, based only on the paper I read, to give
any advice.
Perhaps a better person to ask for advice would be her postdoctoral
mentor. Nevertheless, if the author would like some more feedback
from me, I would suggest to her to write a separate letter and ask the
editor to
forward it to me. In this case, with the editor's permission, I will be
happy to
send my reply to the journal so that it could be anonymously forwarded
back to
the author. |
|
