w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 1 What is the trick in solving such problems? Thanks.
===========================================
Since Jackie is such a big fan of MV’s music, she will probably like the CH
’s new album. Like MV, CH on this album plays complex rock music that
employs the acoustic instrumentation and harmonic sophistication of early 60
’s jazz. The CH also has very witty lyrics full of puns and sardonic humor,
like some of MV’s best lyrics.
Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
A, Jac |
y*****i
发帖数: 588 | 2 这两个里面我选d,不过多年不做了也有点力不从心...这是真题吗？
CH
60
humor,
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: What is the trick in solving such problems? Thanks.
: ===========================================
: Since Jackie is such a big fan of MV’s music, she will probably like the CH
: ’s new album. Like MV, CH on this album plays complex rock music that
: employs the acoustic instrumentation and harmonic sophistication of early 60
: ’s jazz. The CH also has very witty lyrics full of puns and sardonic humor,
: like some of MV’s best lyrics.
: Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
: A, Jac
|
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 3 Yes, it's an actual question of last Dec.
The answer is A :)
I am confused too. Some of the questions recently seems does not follow the previous patterns.
【在 y*****i 的大作中提到】
: 这两个里面我选d,不过多年不做了也有点力不从心...这是真题吗？
:
: CH
: 60
: humor,
|
g*********i
发帖数: 281 | 4 I think it's A
D lacks logical links
CH
60
humor,
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: What is the trick in solving such problems? Thanks.
: ===========================================
: Since Jackie is such a big fan of MV’s music, she will probably like the CH
: ’s new album. Like MV, CH on this album plays complex rock music that
: employs the acoustic instrumentation and harmonic sophistication of early 60
: ’s jazz. The CH also has very witty lyrics full of puns and sardonic humor,
: like some of MV’s best lyrics.
: Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
: A, Jac
|
a***a
发帖数: 204 | 5 haha, A is my answer, I think A better strengthens the argument, not to say
D doesn't, but just not as strong.
the previous patterns.
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: Yes, it's an actual question of last Dec.
: The answer is A :)
: I am confused too. Some of the questions recently seems does not follow the previous patterns.
|
g*********i
发帖数: 281 | 6 the "all" in D seems particularly a weak argument.
say
【在 a***a 的大作中提到】
: haha, A is my answer, I think A better strengthens the argument, not to say
: D doesn't, but just not as strong.
:
: the previous patterns.
|
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 7 how come?! could you explain more?
here is what I think:
because all the musics Jackie likes have rock music component, and CH's new
album has rock music component, so Jackie probably likes it.
A pretty much says because the new album of CH has an arranger (what is
arranger?) from a favorite star of Jackie, so she probably likes that album.
-- that does not have a strong connection with the logic in the stimuli, as
nothing about arranger is taught.
【在 g*********i 的大作中提到】
: the "all" in D seems particularly a weak argument.
:
: say
|
a***a
发帖数: 204 | 8 i think you made a very dangerous mistake, for the purpose of lsat
All musics she likes have been rock doesn't mean she likes anything rock, no
logical relationship here
new
album.
as
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: how come?! could you explain more?
: here is what I think:
: because all the musics Jackie likes have rock music component, and CH's new
: album has rock music component, so Jackie probably likes it.
: A pretty much says because the new album of CH has an arranger (what is
: arranger?) from a favorite star of Jackie, so she probably likes that album.
: -- that does not have a strong connection with the logic in the stimuli, as
: nothing about arranger is taught.
|
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 9 I know. That's why I use "probably" here, and compared to D, I think at
least there is a link.
no
【在 a***a 的大作中提到】
: i think you made a very dangerous mistake, for the purpose of lsat
: All musics she likes have been rock doesn't mean she likes anything rock, no
: logical relationship here
:
: new
: album.
: as
|
y*******y
发帖数: 71 | |
|
|
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 11 My two cents:
The stimulus explicitly states that the music of the two is of the same
genre: "Like MV, CH on this album plays complex rock music...."
D basically restates what is already known and doesn't add any new
information. So it's doesn't provide much extra support to the conclusion.
A provides some new info that helps the conclusion. |
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 12 By the way, where did you find these questions from last test? |
y*******y
发帖数: 71 | 13 Possible explanation:
Argument at issue: like MV-->Like CH's new album.
support given: CH's new album is similar to MV in various aspects("rock
music"; "witty lyrics").
answer A: CH is similar to MV in one more aspect ("musical arranger").(
ignore the part before the comma.)
answer D: failed to strengthen "like MV-->Like CH's new album" even if it
strengthened the point "Like CH's new album." Remember, you need to
strengthen the ARGUMENT, not just the conclusion that "Jackie likes CH's new
album
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: What is the trick in solving such problems? Thanks.
: ===========================================
: Since Jackie is such a big fan of MV’s music, she will probably like the CH
: ’s new album. Like MV, CH on this album plays complex rock music that
: employs the acoustic instrumentation and harmonic sophistication of early 60
: ’s jazz. The CH also has very witty lyrics full of puns and sardonic humor,
: like some of MV’s best lyrics.
: Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
: A, Jac
|
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 14 Nice.
new
【在 y*******y 的大作中提到】
: Possible explanation:
: Argument at issue: like MV-->Like CH's new album.
: support given: CH's new album is similar to MV in various aspects("rock
: music"; "witty lyrics").
: answer A: CH is similar to MV in one more aspect ("musical arranger").(
: ignore the part before the comma.)
: answer D: failed to strengthen "like MV-->Like CH's new album" even if it
: strengthened the point "Like CH's new album." Remember, you need to
: strengthen the ARGUMENT, not just the conclusion that "Jackie likes CH's new
: album
|
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 15 Thanks very much! Your analysis correct a misunderstanding regarding this
type of questions.
new
【在 y*******y 的大作中提到】
: Possible explanation:
: Argument at issue: like MV-->Like CH's new album.
: support given: CH's new album is similar to MV in various aspects("rock
: music"; "witty lyrics").
: answer A: CH is similar to MV in one more aspect ("musical arranger").(
: ignore the part before the comma.)
: answer D: failed to strengthen "like MV-->Like CH's new album" even if it
: strengthened the point "Like CH's new album." Remember, you need to
: strengthen the ARGUMENT, not just the conclusion that "Jackie likes CH's new
: album
|
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 16 Ask any friends that took the test. They will have a copy of the exam 2 or 3
weeks after the exam.
【在 c******r 的大作中提到】
: By the way, where did you find these questions from last test?
|
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 17 Please check you mail box. Thanks!
3
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: Ask any friends that took the test. They will have a copy of the exam 2 or 3
: weeks after the exam.
|
J*********r
发帖数: 5921 | 18 应该是A吧，摇滚乐也有很多分类，喜欢的是一种带有MV风格的摇滚乐，当然和制作人
有很大关系。简单说喜欢摇滚乐太泛泛了，不够强势。
the previous patterns.
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: Yes, it's an actual question of last Dec.
: The answer is A :)
: I am confused too. Some of the questions recently seems does not follow the previous patterns.
|
