w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 1 poems A and B are all attribute to author H in ancient times. But these 2
poems differ greatly in tone and vocabulary and in certain details of the
fictional world they depict. So they are almost certainly not the work of
the same poet.
Ask for weakening:
A) several hymns that were also attribute to H in ancient times differ more
from the A in the respects mentioned than does the B.
B) works known to have been written by the same modern writer are as
different from each other in the respects men |
g*********i
发帖数: 281 | 2 B?
more
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: poems A and B are all attribute to author H in ancient times. But these 2
: poems differ greatly in tone and vocabulary and in certain details of the
: fictional world they depict. So they are almost certainly not the work of
: the same poet.
: Ask for weakening:
: A) several hymns that were also attribute to H in ancient times differ more
: from the A in the respects mentioned than does the B.
: B) works known to have been written by the same modern writer are as
: different from each other in the respects men
|
h*****o
发帖数: 342 | 3 I think it is A
It is hard to compare the situation in antient time to now as everything
changes
【在 g*********i 的大作中提到】
: B?
:
: more
|
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 4 "the same modern writer"? Huh?
Who is this modern writer? |
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 5 Modern writer is modern writer. It doesn't matter who he is.
B basically say as some other writer's work has similar phenomena observed
in author H, the phenomena of H is justified. |
w**********d
发帖数: 155 | 6 I am not sure about the answer either.
I think A is correct, but some say B is correct. Just want to see what do
you guys think. |
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 7 I think B is better.
Since for B, works dramatically different are "known" to be written by the
same writer. It provides a real example with certainty that the situation in
the stimulus happens.
As for option A, the said hymns are merely "attributed" to H and this
attribution could be wrong just as that of poem A or B. Uncertain facts can
't be used as reference to judge other uncertain facts.
My two cents. |
c******r
发帖数: 889 | 8 在加点儿: hymns与A和B与A的关系其实是一样的, 甚至更糟糕. 根据作者的思路,
hymns更应该和A不属一个作者.因为大家都是"attribution",而hymns和A更不同. 所以
选项A有一个错误的前提, 就是hymns确实是H的作品. 看, 他们和A更不同, 都是一个作
者的, 没有理由认为H写不出来B啊.
但是这前提是有问题的, 因为他并不是确实知道H写了那些hymn, 而只是有观点把hymn
归于H. |
j****i
发帖数: 496 | 9 Clearly B.
"The same" modern writer here got to refer to the poet who writes poems A
and B, which both attribute to author H. So answer B is saying that this
modern writer/poet's other works are as different from each other as are A
and B. Therefore, A and B are more likely to be from the same modern writer
/poet.
Answer A basically is saying that other works attributable to H are more
like B than A, which bears no weight on whether A and B are more or less
likely to be from the work of the sa
【在 w**********d 的大作中提到】
: poems A and B are all attribute to author H in ancient times. But these 2
: poems differ greatly in tone and vocabulary and in certain details of the
: fictional world they depict. So they are almost certainly not the work of
: the same poet.
: Ask for weakening:
: A) several hymns that were also attribute to H in ancient times differ more
: from the A in the respects mentioned than does the B.
: B) works known to have been written by the same modern writer are as
: different from each other in the respects men
|
j****i
发帖数: 496 | 10 P.S.: I think people get confused because they don't get the idea that a
modern writer/poet could recreate an ancient fiction by an ancient author.
Imagine the idea from A and B are attributable to H, but the expression of A
/B is created by the modern guy.
writer
【在 j****i 的大作中提到】
: Clearly B.
: "The same" modern writer here got to refer to the poet who writes poems A
: and B, which both attribute to author H. So answer B is saying that this
: modern writer/poet's other works are as different from each other as are A
: and B. Therefore, A and B are more likely to be from the same modern writer
: /poet.
: Answer A basically is saying that other works attributable to H are more
: like B than A, which bears no weight on whether A and B are more or less
: likely to be from the work of the sa
|
D**********s
发帖数: 320 | 11 B.
A) is irrelevant because hymns are different from poems. The fact that the
author's hymns differ more greatly from poem A than poem B does could not
provide a basis for the comparison between A and B. |
