o*********s
发帖数: 275 | 1 A significant portion of the AZ immigration law, as I have expected, is
struck down due to preemption. The most controversial section, however, is
left intact. The morning headline - blow to obama - was just misleading.
This is a split victory. Roberts breaking ranks from the conservatives
helped a lot.
Kennedy is again his lenient self when it comes to criminal law - no state
mandated life without parole for juvenile convicts. |
c**d
发帖数: 3888 | 2 It's going to be a fun week at SCOTUS |
a**********m
发帖数: 2098 | 3 I don't think the "victory" claimed by the GOP is as huge as Obama's. The ot
her three struck down provisions would be economically more devastating agai
nst illegal immigrants. The upheld one is still in limbo in my opinion, whic
h will surely be challenged again in future if the enforcement shows substan
tial bias against Hispanics.
【在 o*********s 的大作中提到】
: A significant portion of the AZ immigration law, as I have expected, is
: struck down due to preemption. The most controversial section, however, is
: left intact. The morning headline - blow to obama - was just misleading.
: This is a split victory. Roberts breaking ranks from the conservatives
: helped a lot.
: Kennedy is again his lenient self when it comes to criminal law - no state
: mandated life without parole for juvenile convicts.
|
a**********m
发帖数: 2098 | 4 SCOTUS is playing safe politically this time. Hope the next one will come ou
t the same result.
【在 c**d 的大作中提到】
: It's going to be a fun week at SCOTUS
|
c**d
发帖数: 3888 | 5 That's why con law at SCOTUS doesn't excite me. It's more about politics
than legal principles
ou
【在 a**********m 的大作中提到】
: SCOTUS is playing safe politically this time. Hope the next one will come ou
: t the same result.
|
