由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
MedicalCareer版 - 请建议,哪几封LOR有用?
相关主题
关于observation的书籍和LOR的几个问题今年Match的同学能帮我们这些没Match的审一下材料吗?
请问在ERAS最多可以finalize几封推荐信呀?2012麦地毕业生credential
observership and some advice for pathology candidatesERAS 问题:Finalize 推荐信
关于ERAS要的LOR DSF表的问题,还有个推荐人问题。由谁来寄推荐信
[考版人生征文]分享match的点滴经验推荐信上的 SPECIALTY 怎样选?
汇总笔记:9/2 ERAS 填表 & 与申请有关 Q/A 座谈会笔记About Waive again?
[合集] 汇总笔记:9/2 ERAS 填表 & 与申请有关 Q/A 座谈会笔记紧急 请教:designate a new LoR writter?
[合集] 汇总笔记:9/2 ERAS 填表 & 与申请有关 Q/A 座谈会笔记Reserve slots for your 推荐信
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: phd话题: md话题: 很强话题: prof
进入MedicalCareer版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
h****a
发帖数: 234
1
我1999-2002在国内上海一大医院有临床经验,可以拿到当时主任(某外科,国内大牛,教
授,中华医学会某专业副主任委员)的很强的推荐信.
来美后一直做RESEARCH, 虽跟几个MD有合作,但他们都和我不是一个城市,我没有做过
OBSERVER.
现在还和其中一个MD有合作,我向他要推荐信时,他说可以给我写个强的信. 但是关于临
床经验我最好在国内拿一封,他可以PARAPHRASE那封信中的关于临床的评价.
我可不可以SHOW给他那封国内的信,让他PARAPHRASE,但是不给ERAS那封国内的信啊?
我现在手头还有跟那些外城市MD的合作课题,目前无法做FULL TIME的OBSERVER,PART
TIME的还没找到.
我想MATCH ANESTHESIOLOGY (与我现在的RESEARCH一致),目前可以拿到的LOR如下:
1.目前的BOSS, PHD,老美,很强的信
2.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的RESEARCH DIRECTOR, PHD,老美, 很强的信
3.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的MD&PHD, ASSOCIATE PROF,老美, 很
e*****a
发帖数: 1334
2
Only you know which letter(s) will be strong. Because you said every letter
will be strong, I'd pick the following:
1.目前的BOSS, PHD,老美,很强的信
2.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的RESEARCH DIRECTOR, PHD,老美, 很强的信
3.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的MD&PHD, ASSOCIATE PROF,老美, 很强的信 (关于临
床会PARAPHRASE国内的信)
5.美国大医院的cardiology的MD&PHD,PROF,老中,很强的信(but not sure what he
will write for my clinical experience)
h****a
发帖数: 234
3
thanks a lot ,eric.
I mean " more appropriate" :)
Do you think I can give my letter from China to referee #3 to paraphrase,
but not using that letter in ERAS?

letter

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: Only you know which letter(s) will be strong. Because you said every letter
: will be strong, I'd pick the following:
: 1.目前的BOSS, PHD,老美,很强的信
: 2.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的RESEARCH DIRECTOR, PHD,老美, 很强的信
: 3.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的MD&PHD, ASSOCIATE PROF,老美, 很强的信 (关于临
: 床会PARAPHRASE国内的信)
: 5.美国大医院的cardiology的MD&PHD,PROF,老中,很强的信(but not sure what he
: will write for my clinical experience)

e*****a
发帖数: 1334
4
Yes. If everything is equal, the preference for LOR is
American doctor/prof. > Chinese doctor/prof. in U.S. > Chinese doctor/prof
in China.
For anesthesia no more than two letteres should come from anesthesiologists, and
the other letters should come from surgeons or IM physicians.
The letter from your Ph.D. boss should be fine.
If you think #6 will be very strong and will cover your clinical experince, you may consider replacing #3 or #5 with #6.

【在 h****a 的大作中提到】
: thanks a lot ,eric.
: I mean " more appropriate" :)
: Do you think I can give my letter from China to referee #3 to paraphrase,
: but not using that letter in ERAS?
:
: letter

h****a
发帖数: 234
5
what if I also want to apply for pathology?

and
, you may consider replacing #3 or #5 with #6.

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: Yes. If everything is equal, the preference for LOR is
: American doctor/prof. > Chinese doctor/prof. in U.S. > Chinese doctor/prof
: in China.
: For anesthesia no more than two letteres should come from anesthesiologists, and
: the other letters should come from surgeons or IM physicians.
: The letter from your Ph.D. boss should be fine.
: If you think #6 will be very strong and will cover your clinical experince, you may consider replacing #3 or #5 with #6.

e*****a
发帖数: 1334
6
You may assign different LORs to different programs. For pathology, you may
include the pathologist's letter.

【在 h****a 的大作中提到】
: what if I also want to apply for pathology?
:
: and
: , you may consider replacing #3 or #5 with #6.

e*****a
发帖数: 1334
7
If you worry about the clinical experience coverage:
Anesthesia:
1.目前的BOSS, PHD,老美,很强的信
the stronger one of
[2.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的RESEARCH DIRECTOR, PHD,老美, 很强的信
or 3.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的MD&PHD, ASSOCIATE PROF,老美, 很强的信 ]
5.美国大医院的cardiology的MD&PHD,PROF,老中,很强的信(but not sure what he
will write for my clinical experience)
6.国内的BOSS, 上海一大医院,某外科主任,国内大牛,教授,中华医学会某外科专业副主
任委员,很强的信
Pathology:
1.目前的BOSS, PHD,老美,很强的信
the stronger one of
[2.美国大医院的ANESTHESIOLOGY的RESEARCH DIRECTOR, PHD,老美, 很强的信
or 3.美国大医院的AN
h****a
发帖数: 234
8
thanks a lot.

may

【在 e*****a 的大作中提到】
: You may assign different LORs to different programs. For pathology, you may
: include the pathologist's letter.

y*****t
发帖数: 264
9
好像病理看重的是你的commitment,别忘了加进去.
w********7
发帖数: 46
10
eric is so nice...Zan!
h****a
发帖数: 234
11
谢谢,呵呵,只是觉得无从下手啊...

【在 y*****t 的大作中提到】
: 好像病理看重的是你的commitment,别忘了加进去.
1 (共1页)
进入MedicalCareer版参与讨论
相关主题
Reserve slots for your 推荐信[考版人生征文]分享match的点滴经验
请问如何查documents有没有到?汇总笔记:9/2 ERAS 填表 & 与申请有关 Q/A 座谈会笔记
LOR还没全到ERAS,是应该现在申还是等LOR上全了?[合集] 汇总笔记:9/2 ERAS 填表 & 与申请有关 Q/A 座谈会笔记
目前没有一封推荐信完成扫描,能申请吗?[合集] 汇总笔记:9/2 ERAS 填表 & 与申请有关 Q/A 座谈会笔记
关于observation的书籍和LOR的几个问题今年Match的同学能帮我们这些没Match的审一下材料吗?
请问在ERAS最多可以finalize几封推荐信呀?2012麦地毕业生credential
observership and some advice for pathology candidatesERAS 问题:Finalize 推荐信
关于ERAS要的LOR DSF表的问题,还有个推荐人问题。由谁来寄推荐信
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: phd话题: md话题: 很强话题: prof