由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
MedicalCareer版 - NBME5, Block 4 Q46 再问
相关主题
请教 NBME5-4-46 呼吸生理求助:NBME成绩不稳定
2道nbme 5 的题目,求讨论及解答。step 1 教训
请教CS CLOSURE的一个问题please help me with NBME5
正在复习STEP1 已经看过生理的同学看过来Step 2 CK: 279/99
Step 3 USMLE CD Answers?我的step1(229/95)
NBME6 blk2-Q50 lung transplantation怎么办呢?
Please help:NBME5-2-15绝望!困惑! 为什么我的NBME分差这么大?
Another Q for NBME5: E or F?关于step1 NBME3 570/238
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: lung话题: pressure话题: frc话题: chest话题: wall
进入MedicalCareer版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
M********r
发帖数: 179
1
Thanks for the previous explanations. However, in a second thought, I tend
to stick to my original answer.
My explanation to this is as following:
at FRC, the PRESSURE of inward (lung) and outward (chest wall) equals to
zero. But that doesn't mean the VOLUME is the same. In fact, because of the
recoil, the pressure of the lung is almost always positive (at FRC, pressure
of the lung=+5). On the other hand, the chest wall always springs out,
therefore the pressure is always negative (at FRC, pressure of the lung=-5).
If this is the case, then the volume should be the difference for the
number on y-axis of chest wall and lung.
Please please please correct me if I'm wrong. Any input is definitely
welcomed.
d****y
发帖数: 2180
2
From the figure, I think the pressure at FRC is +10 for lung and -10 for the
chest wall.
M********r
发帖数: 179
3
The number is not that important, my number is from either UW or Kaplan
notes as i recall. But do you think the concept is right or not? I mean
volume is not equals to pressure.
d****y
发帖数: 2180
4
I think the air volume is only for the lung, don't know how to calculate
the air volume in chest wall.
If the air in the lung and in the chest wall is communicating, then it's
pneumothorax.

【在 M********r 的大作中提到】
: The number is not that important, my number is from either UW or Kaplan
: notes as i recall. But do you think the concept is right or not? I mean
: volume is not equals to pressure.

1 (共1页)
进入MedicalCareer版参与讨论
相关主题
关于step1 NBME3 570/238Step 3 USMLE CD Answers?
今天刚做的step1的NBME4 600/244NBME6 blk2-Q50 lung transplantation
step1 考完了Please help:NBME5-2-15
step1 99/242 简短考经Another Q for NBME5: E or F?
请教 NBME5-4-46 呼吸生理求助:NBME成绩不稳定
2道nbme 5 的题目,求讨论及解答。step 1 教训
请教CS CLOSURE的一个问题please help me with NBME5
正在复习STEP1 已经看过生理的同学看过来Step 2 CK: 279/99
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: lung话题: pressure话题: frc话题: chest话题: wall