h***l
发帖数: 90 | 1 因为各种原因，没有做病理的OB,但做了内科的OB，有几个内科MD的推荐信（没有指定
专业），十几篇paper，STEP1,2 >250，cs pass。申请病理可不可能？没有病理的OB是
不是个硬伤？现在再去做还有用吗？ | l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 2 So let pretend to be the PD.
1. This candidate's score is very high, indicates he is a good student
2. This candidate has more than 10 publications, indicates he is more
suitable for research rather than clinic work
3. This candidate only did IM OB, indicates his previous goal was focusing
on IM, he may lack the knowloedge of what pathology is. | h***l
发帖数: 90 | 3 难道说paper对申请是个负面影响？我怎么听人说research background对申请病理
有利？
【在 l*******d 的大作中提到】
: So let pretend to be the PD.
: 1. This candidate's score is very high, indicates he is a good student
: 2. This candidate has more than 10 publications, indicates he is more
: suitable for research rather than clinic work
: 3. This candidate only did IM OB, indicates his previous goal was focusing
: on IM, he may lack the knowloedge of what pathology is.
| l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 4 papers are the results of research work. Patholoist works for diagnosis,
patient reports, not for publications.
don't mix them together. | h***l
发帖数: 90 | 5 那我现在这个情况，如果想申请病理，应该怎么改进呢（处了作病理OB外）？
【在 l*******d 的大作中提到】
: papers are the results of research work. Patholoist works for diagnosis,
: patient reports, not for publications.
: don't mix them together.
| n***a
发帖数: 1373 | 6 You have good chance for both Im and pathology. Go for it. I got more than
10 path interviews without any path work experience or ob. No
recommendation from pathologists. My credentials are not as good as yours.
Your publication definitely helps. Try to do path ob and then you tell them
you have ob during interviews. Good luck.
【在 h***l 的大作中提到】
: 因为各种原因，没有做病理的OB,但做了内科的OB，有几个内科MD的推荐信（没有指定
: 专业），十几篇paper，STEP1,2 >250，cs pass。申请病理可不可能？没有病理的OB是
: 不是个硬伤？现在再去做还有用吗？
| h***l
发帖数: 90 | 7 谢谢你的信息和建议！你的实际经验很有说服力。谢谢。
than
them
【在 n***a 的大作中提到】
: You have good chance for both Im and pathology. Go for it. I got more than
: 10 path interviews without any path work experience or ob. No
: recommendation from pathologists. My credentials are not as good as yours.
: Your publication definitely helps. Try to do path ob and then you tell them
: you have ob during interviews. Good luck.
| h*******y
发帖数: 1220 | 8 <<2. This candidate has more than 10 publications, indicates he is more
suitable for research rather than clinic work>>
See bad in good, nice Chinese philosophy, but I laugh my ass off. | l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 9 The more publication, the more likely indicates you are good at research,
however, clinic work is totally different from research job.
Actually, your boss should more suitable for applying for resident, because
he is the corresponding author.
See bad in good, nice Chinese philosophy, but I laugh my ass off.
So in applying for resident, please be logic. | h*******y
发帖数: 1220 | 10 You misunderstanded the logica of american thinking:
You are good at A, then you are good at B also...esp A and B are associated.
because
【在 l*******d 的大作中提到】
: The more publication, the more likely indicates you are good at research,
: however, clinic work is totally different from research job.
: Actually, your boss should more suitable for applying for resident, because
: he is the corresponding author.
: See bad in good, nice Chinese philosophy, but I laugh my ass off.
: So in applying for resident, please be logic.
| | | h*******y
发帖数: 1220 | 11 Apparently he is a person with extrodinary abilities, great scores, english,
communication skills, and great research: he seems perfect to me, only
thing he needs to prove is his interpersonal skills and personality... | l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 12 According to your theory good at A then should be good at B, then why you
needs to prove interpersonal skills?
LZ please forget about your score, forget about your papers, resident
application is not faculty application.
1. find connection, let PD do you a favor, give you an IV
2. practice spoken English, so you can have a good talk with PD and other
physician
Remember, residency is a training, it is not a career, it is just a bridge
to a new career, so the requirement for resident is that candidate is a
person who can be trained, it is not a person who is well trained. | R*********s
发帖数: 58 | 13 Come on, largebird. Are you born as a pathologist? This is a very strong
candidate who shows great achievement and potential to do a good job
everywhere. Don't mislead people and be helpful, otherwise sounds like "sore
grapes" | n***a
发帖数: 1373 | 14 Misleading people on purpose is not a nice thing to do. Of course, everybody
need to have their judgements.
【在 l*******d 的大作中提到】
: According to your theory good at A then should be good at B, then why you
: needs to prove interpersonal skills?
: LZ please forget about your score, forget about your papers, resident
: application is not faculty application.
: 1. find connection, let PD do you a favor, give you an IV
: 2. practice spoken English, so you can have a good talk with PD and other
: physician
: Remember, residency is a training, it is not a career, it is just a bridge
: to a new career, so the requirement for resident is that candidate is a
: person who can be trained, it is not a person who is well trained.
| l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 15 Obviously, LZ has no much confidence for pathology. I assume LZ were
surrounded by people who behaved like me, misled LZ a lot, so that LZ lost
her confidence.
I beleive LZ will be a strong candidate, because 1. medical knowledge is
solid( please check ecfmg for LZ step 1, 2 score) 2. dedicated to previous
job ( please read reference letter) 3. productive and smart ( please check
pubmed for publications) | h*******y
发帖数: 1220 | 16 Her or his english must be good, becaues of 1st pass in CS... | l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 17 I own an apology to LZ, I should not say so many biased comments on your
post.
I know LZ is an excellent student back school, an excellent scientist in
research field, and again, all her achievements verify her as an excellent
candidate for pathology resident.
resident is a training program, however, not like research field, people
will touch more social issue during residency life, that why PD put more
criteria when screening the applicants. Communication skills, interpersonal
skills are more critical than score and publications.
I am practicing this skills too. |
|
