L********a
发帖数: 576 | 1 You start to have interest in xxxxxx, why don't to practice in China? Why do
you want to practice in US? |
l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 2 this question is too easy to answer.
you can tell the then because of 3 No 1. US is number, specialty in the US
is NO 1, your program is No1
plus, I believe, No1 program should recruit no. 1 resident, so here I am |
L********a
发帖数: 576 | 3 非常感谢largebird的回答，但是好像没有对题，我的问题是residency training之后
，在美国practice,不是why do I choose your residency program? |
l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 4 then add another No 1, US doctor salary No1 |
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 5 American doctors have the leadership of medical practice. Chinese doctors
have to follow the instruction from Communist party. |
L********a
发帖数: 576 | 6 This is real question I experienced, not joking. |
l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 7 就说三个代表，美国代表了先进（生产力）医学技术，代表了（人民） 病人利益。代
表了未来发展的方向。大披萨人太实诚。面试就是瞎吹，别当真。 |
l*******d
发帖数: 449 | 8 实际上，如果我被问到这个问题，就意味着，面试有问题了，如果program喜欢我，就
不会问我为什不回国去。 |
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 9 I am serious.
http://www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Medicalpractice/51281.html
【在 L********a 的大作中提到】
: This is real question I experienced, not joking.
|
a***r
发帖数: 2677 | 10 It is a rude question, better stay away from them if possible, but if you
have to say something, you can say that you can not go back, like pawns in
the game. |
|
|
g*****d
发帖数: 991 | 11 This is the most common question they will ask if they haven't seen many CMG
before. It is about curiosity, not personal.
Three No.1s are good answer.
Most time, we do need to ask ourself why we choose USA, that will be your
real personal answer, but maybe not perfect for interview.
do
【在 L********a 的大作中提到】
: You start to have interest in xxxxxx, why don't to practice in China? Why do
: you want to practice in US?
|
f****i
发帖数: 129 | 12 That's an interesting answer. Could you please elaborate? Thanks!
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: American doctors have the leadership of medical practice. Chinese doctors
: have to follow the instruction from Communist party.
|
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 13 当年到美国我是发誓不当医生了，国内当了2-3年，没有经历的人不太能理解。
到美国后改变主意不是因为认识提高，而是因为没有适合自己的， 年纪一大把，老本
行还是容易一些，当然钱更是原因。
但做了attending以后，我才开始体会到中国医生和美国医生的不同。 这个体会就是我
说的，考版生不可能认识到这些，但PD想听的应该跟我想到一致，呵呵
不管是医院雇员还是私人开业，你决定你怎样看病，你对你自己的执照负责，医院诊所
的管理者为你创造条件，当然利益是一致的：为医院病人提供最好的服务，为自己带最
多的钱回去。
在中国，党和政府要求医疗工作者向白求恩学习，全心全意地为人民服务，具体的执行
我就不说了。
【在 f****i 的大作中提到】
: That's an interesting answer. Could you please elaborate? Thanks!
|
s*****n
发帖数: 57 | 14 你总是这样歌颂"美国",诋毁"中国",小心被贴上"洋奴"标签.
不是有ID说你是"精神外F"了吗?
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: 当年到美国我是发誓不当医生了，国内当了2-3年，没有经历的人不太能理解。
: 到美国后改变主意不是因为认识提高，而是因为没有适合自己的， 年纪一大把，老本
: 行还是容易一些，当然钱更是原因。
: 但做了attending以后，我才开始体会到中国医生和美国医生的不同。 这个体会就是我
: 说的，考版生不可能认识到这些，但PD想听的应该跟我想到一致，呵呵
: 不管是医院雇员还是私人开业，你决定你怎样看病，你对你自己的执照负责，医院诊所
: 的管理者为你创造条件，当然利益是一致的：为医院病人提供最好的服务，为自己带最
: 多的钱回去。
: 在中国，党和政府要求医疗工作者向白求恩学习，全心全意地为人民服务，具体的执行
: 我就不说了。
|
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 15 你有种别披个马甲上来，早点回国别在这受洋罪。
【在 s*****n 的大作中提到】
: 你总是这样歌颂"美国",诋毁"中国",小心被贴上"洋奴"标签.
: 不是有ID说你是"精神外F"了吗?
|
a***r
发帖数: 2677 | 16 It is not interesting at all. It is unwise to remind people of negative
things related to you.
【在 f****i 的大作中提到】
: That's an interesting answer. Could you please elaborate? Thanks!
|
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 17 Let's put politics aside.
This question is not friendly at all, which I agree, and covering it up does
not help.
这里的考版生问这样的问题是为了消除在interview时PD的疑虑，特别是中国经济情况
好转了，为什么还不回去做？ 说三个代表有马屁之嫌，对不友好的PD是不管用的。
把重点放到自己身上，在美国做resident是为了自己，不是什么爱国不爱国的问题。
【在 a***r 的大作中提到】
: It is not interesting at all. It is unwise to remind people of negative
: things related to you.
|
a***r
发帖数: 2677 | 18 I think at least you can not say anything related to yourself is bad before
PD even it is true. Actually, like FDR said: he may be a son of bitch but he
is ours.
does
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: Let's put politics aside.
: This question is not friendly at all, which I agree, and covering it up does
: not help.
: 这里的考版生问这样的问题是为了消除在interview时PD的疑虑，特别是中国经济情况
: 好转了，为什么还不回去做？ 说三个代表有马屁之嫌，对不友好的PD是不管用的。
: 把重点放到自己身上，在美国做resident是为了自己，不是什么爱国不爱国的问题。
|
p********g
发帖数: 372 | 19 前辈什么时候看了Lion King? 改了签名档？
does
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: Let's put politics aside.
: This question is not friendly at all, which I agree, and covering it up does
: not help.
: 这里的考版生问这样的问题是为了消除在interview时PD的疑虑，特别是中国经济情况
: 好转了，为什么还不回去做？ 说三个代表有马屁之嫌，对不友好的PD是不管用的。
: 把重点放到自己身上，在美国做resident是为了自己，不是什么爱国不爱国的问题。
|
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 20 What makes you think commenting on communism is bad to Chinese? American
hates communism for god's sake and China had a war with U.S in korea, we
Chinese still come to US for education, any problems with that?
The point to answer this type questions is to focus on myself. I want to be
a better physician, I want to control my practice after graduation, so I can
serve the patients better like all other American colleagues. I could not
do this in China any better than in U.S.
If you choose not to comment on politics, tell your PD.
before
he
【在 a***r 的大作中提到】
: I think at least you can not say anything related to yourself is bad before
: PD even it is true. Actually, like FDR said: he may be a son of bitch but he
: is ours.
:
: does
|
|
|
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 21 前辈不敢，lion king在residency以前就看了，签名档是来自我病人对他老婆的抱怨。
呵呵
【在 p********g 的大作中提到】
: 前辈什么时候看了Lion King? 改了签名档？
:
: does
|
a***r
发帖数: 2677 | 22 Well, I totally agree with you that China is not a good place for doctors,
my point is that the comment is unnecessary here.
be
can
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: What makes you think commenting on communism is bad to Chinese? American
: hates communism for god's sake and China had a war with U.S in korea, we
: Chinese still come to US for education, any problems with that?
: The point to answer this type questions is to focus on myself. I want to be
: a better physician, I want to control my practice after graduation, so I can
: serve the patients better like all other American colleagues. I could not
: do this in China any better than in U.S.
:
: If you choose not to comment on politics, tell your PD.
:
|
A*******s
发帖数: 9638 | 23 Do you guys really think those PDs are naive enough not knowing the fact?
My suggestion is only a frame, you can rephrase it in your own words
depending on your judgement on that individule PD. But be yourself and gain
your points on your maturity.
【在 a***r 的大作中提到】
: Well, I totally agree with you that China is not a good place for doctors,
: my point is that the comment is unnecessary here.
:
: be
: can
|
a***r
发帖数: 2677 | 24 I just watering with you. Why are you so serious? hehe.
Sorry that I can not agree with you on this point.
gain
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: Do you guys really think those PDs are naive enough not knowing the fact?
: My suggestion is only a frame, you can rephrase it in your own words
: depending on your judgement on that individule PD. But be yourself and gain
: your points on your maturity.
|
h**s
发帖数: 1757 | 25 applause
Maturity is the most important shinning point for an "old" CMG:>)
I believe that if any one asked this qs , they wouldn't expect an ordinary
answer. They expect a personal real story. In another word, your true
thoughts.
.
gain
【在 A*******s 的大作中提到】
: Do you guys really think those PDs are naive enough not knowing the fact?
: My suggestion is only a frame, you can rephrase it in your own words
: depending on your judgement on that individule PD. But be yourself and gain
: your points on your maturity.
|
w**********u
发帖数: 290 | |
i*d
发帖数: 2640 | 27 说实话，不会错。
自己实际怎么想的，就怎么说。
美国医疗体系完整，水准高，就是效率低点。
美国医生收入高，受尊敬。
do
【在 L********a 的大作中提到】
: You start to have interest in xxxxxx, why don't to practice in China? Why do
: you want to practice in US?
|
k*******0
发帖数: 355 | 28 good
do
【在 L********a 的大作中提到】
: You start to have interest in xxxxxx, why don't to practice in China? Why do
: you want to practice in US?
|
