p**********u 发帖数: 15479 | 1 【 以下文字转载自 Dreamer 讨论区 】
发信人: Dreamer (不要问我从哪里来), 信区: Dreamer
标 题: Re: 订婚了,bf给了一克拉钻戒,后来和平分手,钻戒还还吗
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sun Jan 6 23:52:51 2013, 美东)
各州对此界定不同。如果说是breach of contract的话,就得看是谁的breach。
conditional gift的州,condition既然没有met,就应该还。
我会觉得应该还,自己看着也闹心不是么。
你先看看你们州的法律。
No-fault approach
Increasingly, more states are leaning toward a no-fault approach to broken
engagements. In 1999, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled the giver should
always get the engagement ring back. Iowa, Kansas, New Jersey, New Mexico,
New York and Wisconsin also have adopted this approach.
In a nutshell, under the no-fault approach, the courts don't care who's at
fault for the broken engagement. If the engagement is broken, the giver gets
the ring back, regardless of who broke off the engagement, or why. This is
similar to the no-fault approach in divorce law, in which the courts attempt
to avoid the bitter, nasty and private reasons that often go hand-in-hand
with a break-up --reasons such as "nothing in common," "can't stand my
future in-laws," "pets don't get along," "she's on Facebook all the time,"
or "he's a slob."
http://company.findlaw.com/press-center/2012/return-engagement- | G****a 发帖数: 10208 | 2 不结婚, 订婚戒要还男方
离婚, 订婚戒属于女方财产, 不用还
章子怡那鸽子蛋戒指应该是还给犹太老头了
should
【在 p**********u 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 【 以下文字转载自 Dreamer 讨论区 】 : 发信人: Dreamer (不要问我从哪里来), 信区: Dreamer : 标 题: Re: 订婚了,bf给了一克拉钻戒,后来和平分手,钻戒还还吗 : 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sun Jan 6 23:52:51 2013, 美东) : 各州对此界定不同。如果说是breach of contract的话,就得看是谁的breach。 : conditional gift的州,condition既然没有met,就应该还。 : 我会觉得应该还,自己看着也闹心不是么。 : 你先看看你们州的法律。 : No-fault approach : Increasingly, more states are leaning toward a no-fault approach to broken
| M****7 发帖数: 13407 | 3 Now, I can understand why uncles still remain unmarried.
【在 G****a 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 不结婚, 订婚戒要还男方 : 离婚, 订婚戒属于女方财产, 不用还 : 章子怡那鸽子蛋戒指应该是还给犹太老头了 : : should
| d**i 发帖数: 9682 | 4 Now, I can understand why you still remain unconsummated.
【在 M****7 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : Now, I can understand why uncles still remain unmarried.
| M****7 发帖数: 13407 | 5 从这件事上也可以看出章这人不怎么样, 从小家竟很差。 她自己赚得又不少。
【在 G****a 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 不结婚, 订婚戒要还男方 : 离婚, 订婚戒属于女方财产, 不用还 : 章子怡那鸽子蛋戒指应该是还给犹太老头了 : : should
| s****b 发帖数: 2039 | 6 凡事问老盖
【在 M****7 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 从这件事上也可以看出章这人不怎么样, 从小家竟很差。 她自己赚得又不少。
|
|