n*******e
发帖数: 2057 | 1 今晚终于看了一下。之前以为这部片子拍出啥突破了，一看，一点惊喜都没有。典型国
产片的平庸之
作。很扯的情节，无谓的镜头，故事讲的支离破碎。整体感觉还是代入感太差，人物都
是脸谱化的，很
难让人真正进入影片。
演员还行，但是让编剧和导演也糟蹋的不成样子了。
唉，国产电影能烂到今天这样子，不是一日之功。这片子也就是imdb上面3－4之间的分
数。 |
s****n
发帖数: 4902 | 2 不好意思imdb给了7.2分so far, 至于你说的代入感太差，有一个粉说了以下的话：
It's nearly impossible to find words to describe quickly I was sucked into
the plot and became a member of the family of four portrayed in this
masterpiece. I was in awe of the human tragedy this earthquake was and the
amazing technology used to recreate it. However, nothing could have possibly
prepared me for the tragic, sad, warm and beautiful human drama that would
follow.
I was hoping to say I enjoyed this as much as or even more than any other
mo |
j***b
发帖数: 5901 | 3 飞刀房子imdb 7.6呢。
possibly
would
【在 s****n 的大作中提到】
: 不好意思imdb给了7.2分so far, 至于你说的代入感太差，有一个粉说了以下的话：
: It's nearly impossible to find words to describe quickly I was sucked into
: the plot and became a member of the family of four portrayed in this
: masterpiece. I was in awe of the human tragedy this earthquake was and the
: amazing technology used to recreate it. However, nothing could have possibly
: prepared me for the tragic, sad, warm and beautiful human drama that would
: follow.
: I was hoping to say I enjoyed this as much as or even more than any other
: mo
|
s****n
发帖数: 4902 | 4 本人在本贴只是顺着楼主的话说IMDB上给的分并不是楼主说的3，4分，有人作出和楼主
完全相反的评论。本人没有评价唐山的好坏，也没有说IMDB的平均得分能代表一部电影
的质量高低，更没有说IMDB的平均得分能代表单个影迷认为的影片质量。
【在 j***b 的大作中提到】
: 飞刀房子imdb 7.6呢。
:
: possibly
: would
|
m*******p
发帖数: 1978 | |
s****n
发帖数: 4902 | 6 谁的标准？和您自个给中文电影设的标准比？
我看the dark knight之类的英文电影倒是评分标准低，居然盘踞第12名。
【在 m*******p 的大作中提到】
: 好像大家打分对中文片子的标准超低。
|
