由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Physics版 - referee are unable to report
相关主题
PRL审稿经历证明有文章被拒以后又跟editor打回来的吗
请教PRL投稿PRE现在审稿时间是不是延长了?
一篇在审 的文章请问PRL一般审稿时间多长?
求助,paper被reject还有可能要求重审吗prl的editor是疯了吗
with editors 快三周了,怎么回事?遭遇PRL流氓审稿人
关于稿件的状态,现在有点晕。。。PRL状态with editors时间越长正面结果可能性越大?
PRL投稿被拒,玉门投prl被拒,哪种情况稍微好些?
人品不好,文章被拒了PRA referee六周不response怎么办?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: unable话题: referees话题: editors话题: report话题: referee
进入Physics版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
e*s
发帖数: 2
1
Hi,
I have a question to experienced people. I submitted a paper a month ago.
Two referees were unable to report. Did anyone meet such a case? I wrote a
letter to Editors suggesting two referees who are experts in my research
area. Do you think the Editors will send the paper to the referees that I
recommended?
-Thanks
i*******n
发帖数: 188
2
They will send the paper to new referees, but not necessarily the two you
recommended.
I once had a paper to PRL, and it turns out 1 unable, 1 negative, so refused
. Then I turn to EPL, and got 1 unable, 1 no reply, 1 positive, and finally
got published. You see, unable often appears.
1 (共1页)
进入Physics版参与讨论
相关主题
PRA referee六周不response怎么办?with editors 快三周了,怎么回事?
PRL在editors 手里9天了,什么情况?关于稿件的状态,现在有点晕。。。
PRL 状态PRL投稿被拒,玉门
一篇普通prb article, 三个referees?人品不好,文章被拒了
PRL审稿经历证明有文章被拒以后又跟editor打回来的吗
请教PRL投稿PRE现在审稿时间是不是延长了?
一篇在审 的文章请问PRL一般审稿时间多长?
求助,paper被reject还有可能要求重审吗prl的editor是疯了吗
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: unable话题: referees话题: editors话题: report话题: referee