Reader版 - Re: 莫扎特的坏笑(转载) & "the name of the rose" |
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
or
发帖数: 720 | 1 //grin Mozart's opera & this movie are essentially different in the sense of
comedy & tradegy. There's a parallel in "the name of the rose". In an
isolated abbey, a hidden aristotle(sp?)'s manuscript filled monks with wonder,
anger, hatred, humiliation and fear, and caused 7 deaths in 7 days. The
manuscript was said to address such "immoral" issue like jesus laughed &
saints cracked jokes. Monks who were narrow-minded & had small perspectives
tried to hide and destroy it; those who were slav | y***s
发帖数: 63 | 2 Your posts here sometimes depress me. Are there just too many books deserving
a glance or I am reading idiotically slow?
Maugham in one of his Ashenton stories said there were many books
worth reading if he could live 1000 years. Well, wish I could also
know how to choose.
【在 or 的大作中提到】
: //grin Mozart's opera & this movie are essentially different in the sense of
: comedy & tradegy. There's a parallel in "the name of the rose". In an
: isolated abbey, a hidden aristotle(sp?)'s manuscript filled monks with wonder,
: anger, hatred, humiliation and fear, and caused 7 deaths in 7 days. The
: manuscript was said to address such "immoral" issue like jesus laughed &
: saints cracked jokes. Monks who were narrow-minded & had small perspectives
: tried to hide and destroy it; those who were slav
| v*******e
发帖数: 3714 | 3
filled monks with?
I am confused. maybe that movie changed the story too much. I havn't got a
chance to see it yet.
【在 or 的大作中提到】
: //grin Mozart's opera & this movie are essentially different in the sense of
: comedy & tradegy. There's a parallel in "the name of the rose". In an
: isolated abbey, a hidden aristotle(sp?)'s manuscript filled monks with wonder,
: anger, hatred, humiliation and fear, and caused 7 deaths in 7 days. The
: manuscript was said to address such "immoral" issue like jesus laughed &
: saints cracked jokes. Monks who were narrow-minded & had small perspectives
: tried to hide and destroy it; those who were slav
| v*******e
发帖数: 3714 | 4 choose whatever library and step inside, you will come to that same
conclusion in a minute. but it doesn't really mean anything.. the
books are only devided into two kinds: the ones worth reading, the
ones not. is definitely the former. good news
is that, the ones that worth reading usually are fun to read..
【在 y***s 的大作中提到】
: Your posts here sometimes depress me. Are there just too many books deserving
: a glance or I am reading idiotically slow?
: Maugham in one of his Ashenton stories said there were many books
: worth reading if he could live 1000 years. Well, wish I could also
: know how to choose.
| or
发帖数: 720 | 5
deserving
i hv a soft spot for old dull books..those off everyone's list probably..pls
dont let this get on your nerves..it meant to be happy to have sth unexplored
ahead..;P
【在 y***s 的大作中提到】
: Your posts here sometimes depress me. Are there just too many books deserving
: a glance or I am reading idiotically slow?
: Maugham in one of his Ashenton stories said there were many books
: worth reading if he could live 1000 years. Well, wish I could also
: know how to choose.
| or
发帖数: 720 | 6
of
wonder,
weren't they monks?;P 60 of them prayed & read & copied & wrote in a desolate
abbey. over 150 servants provided all the physical labor. what the monks
possessed was solely a focused & magnified spiritual life..close contact with
books & visions day & night. i thought the author was very brilliant to set
up such an extreme & isolated condition to explore all sorts of relations btw
ppl & knowledge & religion. there's not a single woman in this novel..not
exactly..there's one who o
【在 v*******e 的大作中提到】
: choose whatever library and step inside, you will come to that same
: conclusion in a minute. but it doesn't really mean anything.. the
: books are only devided into two kinds: the ones worth reading, the
: ones not. is definitely the former. good news
: is that, the ones that worth reading usually are fun to read..
| v*******e
发帖数: 3714 | 7 我意思是书的情节没这么简单，虽然这说法也可算是某种意义上的诠释。
换句话说，要把这本书改编成电影是挺困难的，尤其因为电影依赖于
生硬（相对文字而言），很多言外之意无法顾及。
我觉得还是看书更精彩些，假如时间足够的话。
【在 or 的大作中提到】
:
: of
: wonder,
: weren't they monks?;P 60 of them prayed & read & copied & wrote in a desolate
: abbey. over 150 servants provided all the physical labor. what the monks
: possessed was solely a focused & magnified spiritual life..close contact with
: books & visions day & night. i thought the author was very brilliant to set
: up such an extreme & isolated condition to explore all sorts of relations btw
: ppl & knowledge & religion. there's not a single woman in this novel..not
: exactly..there's one who o
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
