l***y
发帖数: 791 | 1 just want some opinion of her works and Adam Dalgliesh. |
j*******e
发帖数: 2168 | 2 Just my humble opinion:
She's a great writer in terms of literature but a lessor one in terms
of mystery.
She creates a lot of characters, presents them well, weaves them
successfully into complicated plots.
However,
her works do not have the exciting reconstruction/recount of a murder
at the ending, as most of Christie's works do (a most exciting case
in point would be Appointment with Death);
neither do her works contain the unconventional mystery element found
in Tey's works (e.g. Daugher of
【在 l***y 的大作中提到】
: just want some opinion of her works and Adam Dalgliesh.
|
t*a
发帖数: 117 | 3 个人认为 PDJ 的文字很好，不过看多了也有点重复。她的两个侦探
Adam Dalgliesh 和 Cordelia Gray 里面我更喜欢后者，不知道为什么
她只写了两本 CG 的书。
【在 j*******e 的大作中提到】
: Just my humble opinion:
: She's a great writer in terms of literature but a lessor one in terms
: of mystery.
: She creates a lot of characters, presents them well, weaves them
: successfully into complicated plots.
: However,
: her works do not have the exciting reconstruction/recount of a murder
: at the ending, as most of Christie's works do (a most exciting case
: in point would be Appointment with Death);
: neither do her works contain the unconventional mystery element found
|
l***y
发帖数: 791 | 4 this is great! knew i could count on you guys. :)
so-called
【在 t*a 的大作中提到】
: 个人认为 PDJ 的文字很好，不过看多了也有点重复。她的两个侦探
: Adam Dalgliesh 和 Cordelia Gray 里面我更喜欢后者，不知道为什么
: 她只写了两本 CG 的书。
|
or
发帖数: 720 | 5 tea must be a fan of pdj since she piped up each time pdjames was mentioned in
this board.;P
how come you suddenly thot about james?
i am also rererereading agatha christie these days.;P
more
【在 l***y 的大作中提到】
: this is great! knew i could count on you guys. :)
:
: so-called
|
or
发帖数: 720 | 6 try "murder room" eh? i liked that one.
【在 l***y 的大作中提到】
: just want some opinion of her works and Adam Dalgliesh.
|
l***y
发帖数: 791 | 7 chasing somebody's tail here. ;) thought about reading murder in holy order
and name of the rose back to back (talk about endangered species!) but it
seems like pd jame's murder room and her early works are better liked by
the readers.
might as well finish my 'dune' first. :O~
【在 or 的大作中提到】
: try "murder room" eh? i liked that one.
|
t*a
发帖数: 117 | 8
:) I do like her novels a lot, next only to JA.
//hand hand I've been rererere-reading Agatha Christie lately too. Found
out something I haven't noticed much before - Agatha mentioned nursery
rhymes quite often in her novels.
【在 or 的大作中提到】
: tea must be a fan of pdj since she piped up each time pdjames was mentioned in
: this board.;P
: how come you suddenly thot about james?
: i am also rererereading agatha christie these days.;P
:
: more
|
j*******e
发帖数: 2168 | 9 hehe, PD James is herself a fan of JA, as far as I remember.
Yes, many many nursery rhymes in Christie's works, a lot of them used
as titles.
mentioned in
【在 t*a 的大作中提到】
:
: :) I do like her novels a lot, next only to JA.
: //hand hand I've been rererere-reading Agatha Christie lately too. Found
: out something I haven't noticed much before - Agatha mentioned nursery
: rhymes quite often in her novels.
|
or
发帖数: 720 | 10
I guessed so when reading "innocent blood"!
【在 j*******e 的大作中提到】
: hehe, PD James is herself a fan of JA, as far as I remember.
: Yes, many many nursery rhymes in Christie's works, a lot of them used
: as titles.
:
: mentioned in
|
