I*****y
发帖数: 6402 | |
s******t
发帖数: 12883 | 2 公立不能念， 除非父母一方在这里。
【在 I*****y 的大作中提到】
: 还有签证类型也是F1吗？
|
I*****y
发帖数: 6402 | 3 那就只能上私立的了？
【在 s******t 的大作中提到】
: 公立不能念， 除非父母一方在这里。
|
z****0
发帖数: 363 | 4 真有需要，我可以帮你问个明白，如果只是问一问，我就不费那功夫了。 |
i********6
发帖数: 4766 | 5 if the parents don't pay tax, why should their kids enjoy public school? |
w*****g
发帖数: 3922 | 6 what if somedoay doesn't have any kid, or his kids are not in public school,
should he pay the property tax in full?
【在 i********6 的大作中提到】
: if the parents don't pay tax, why should their kids enjoy public school?
|
n*******d
发帖数: 124 | 7 You have the right to attend the public school, but you also have the right
not to enforce it.
school,
【在 w*****g 的大作中提到】
: what if somedoay doesn't have any kid, or his kids are not in public school,
: should he pay the property tax in full?
|
y****i
发帖数: 17878 | 8 I think receiving education is a right, not a privilege
【在 i********6 的大作中提到】
: if the parents don't pay tax, why should their kids enjoy public school?
|
A******M
发帖数: 1587 | 9 F1不能念公立学校。
160表上面有一项，有没有在97年之后持F1签证上公立学校而没有付钱的？ |
i********6
发帖数: 4766 | 10 i never think receiving free education is a right.
right and responsibility are co-existed. for those non-tax payers, where do their responsibility reflect?
Even public Univ. charges triple for those non-resident students, so should public high school.
【在 y****i 的大作中提到】
: I think receiving education is a right, not a privilege
|
|
|
i********6
发帖数: 4766 | 11 Prop tax isn't just for school, but that person's kid will have right to go
to the public school.
school,
【在 w*****g 的大作中提到】
: what if somedoay doesn't have any kid, or his kids are not in public school,
: should he pay the property tax in full?
|
y****i
发帖数: 17878 | 12 well, you can not kick a kid out of a public school just because he/she can
not afford it, that is my bottom line
It is not a child's fault in this case. Blame the parents
do their responsibility reflect?
【在 i********6 的大作中提到】
: i never think receiving free education is a right.
: right and responsibility are co-existed. for those non-tax payers, where do their responsibility reflect?
: Even public Univ. charges triple for those non-resident students, so should public high school.
|
y****i
发帖数: 17878 | 13 higher education is one thing, K-12 is another
do their responsibility reflect?
should public high school.
【在 i********6 的大作中提到】
: i never think receiving free education is a right.
: right and responsibility are co-existed. for those non-tax payers, where do their responsibility reflect?
: Even public Univ. charges triple for those non-resident students, so should public high school.
|
d******t
发帖数: 1242 | 14 So I suppose the way to keep kids of foreign countries from going to US
public k-12 schools is to keep them out of the country? ;)
On the other hand, if one can go to public school so long as he/she or the
parents can pay for it, wouldn't that benefit the public schools on a tight
budget?
can
【在 y****i 的大作中提到】
: well, you can not kick a kid out of a public school just because he/she can
: not afford it, that is my bottom line
: It is not a child's fault in this case. Blame the parents
:
: do their responsibility reflect?
|
i********6
发帖数: 4766 | 15 what's discussing here is, some rich foreign kids come here enjoy free
public school service which are paid my heavy burdened working class of US.
can
【在 y****i 的大作中提到】
: well, you can not kick a kid out of a public school just because he/she can
: not afford it, that is my bottom line
: It is not a child's fault in this case. Blame the parents
:
: do their responsibility reflect?
|
i********6
发帖数: 4766 | 16 exactly.
i have no problem with tons of chinese/hongkongnese/taiwanese young students
walking in UC campus talking in chinese, holding LV/Chanel/Prada, with paying
triple tuition of CA students. but same kids going to public school for free
? no way.
tight
【在 d******t 的大作中提到】
: So I suppose the way to keep kids of foreign countries from going to US
: public k-12 schools is to keep them out of the country? ;)
: On the other hand, if one can go to public school so long as he/she or the
: parents can pay for it, wouldn't that benefit the public schools on a tight
: budget?
:
: can
|
y****i
发帖数: 17878 | 17 how do you verify the income of an alien or an undocumented immigrant?
there are always people who try to game the system when they can afford the
expenses, but you can not deny the majority the right of getting education
simply because of few bad apples
【在 i********6 的大作中提到】
: what's discussing here is, some rich foreign kids come here enjoy free
: public school service which are paid my heavy burdened working class of US.
:
: can
|
y****i
发帖数: 17878 | 18
Yes, once a minor arrives in this country, legally or not, he/she is
entitled to get basic education (K-12).
tight
Don't quite understand what you mean here. care to elaborate?
【在 d******t 的大作中提到】
: So I suppose the way to keep kids of foreign countries from going to US
: public k-12 schools is to keep them out of the country? ;)
: On the other hand, if one can go to public school so long as he/she or the
: parents can pay for it, wouldn't that benefit the public schools on a tight
: budget?
:
: can
|
i********6
发帖数: 4766 | 19 let's talk about it after those kids become undocumented immigrants. now
they are still high income aliens for sure.
the
【在 y****i 的大作中提到】
: how do you verify the income of an alien or an undocumented immigrant?
: there are always people who try to game the system when they can afford the
: expenses, but you can not deny the majority the right of getting education
: simply because of few bad apples
|
y****i
发帖数: 17878 | 20 I'm all ears if you could offer a practical way of weeding out these
deadbeats
【在 i********6 的大作中提到】
: let's talk about it after those kids become undocumented immigrants. now
: they are still high income aliens for sure.
:
: the
|
d******t
发帖数: 1242 | 21 What I was saying is that if the public schools are allowed to admit a
foreign resident child as long as the parents are willing to pay for it,
that tuition might actually help fund the schools.
While I agree children should be entitled to schools regardless if they
enter the country legally or not (like someone above said, they'd better to
be in school than on the streets), I also understand how some can be upset.
Just imagine if kids in Mira Mesa are allowed to go to Carmel Valley or Del
Mar
【在 y****i 的大作中提到】
: I'm all ears if you could offer a practical way of weeding out these
: deadbeats
|
x**m
发帖数: 1825 | 22 around the year 2000, the law did not allow F1 students to study at public
high schools any more. not sure whether it is changed again or not! F1 is
allowed at private high schools. |
