x******a 发帖数: 6336 | |
h****n 发帖数: 2250 | 2 麻烦了,他们用的是Hernandez 的图,是要pro AA的。 |
x******a 发帖数: 6336 | 3 看了一下评论,一边倒
读者一般比较conservative
【在 h****n 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 麻烦了,他们用的是Hernandez 的图,是要pro AA的。
|
k****m 发帖数: 4670 | 4 这只能说明,有些人高中毕业,没有能力考上大学
而不能用来证明,大学就该降低标准来录取,或直接加入种族标准 |
h****g 发帖数: 2216 | 5 现在还怕谁pro啊。你还真以为这是说理的事?
现在就政治斗争。劳模未必在乎这几个上大学民额,老中在乎。所以关键是发动亚裔投
票捐款,联系议员。议员都不傻,现在不是已经有两个出来说暂不支持SCA-5了吗?只
要再搞定一到两个,那把握就大多了。
为了自己的利益出卖选民这种事议员干得出来,为了Hernandez牺牲自己的政治前途,
没有哪个民主党议员会干的。
【在 h****n 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 麻烦了,他们用的是Hernandez 的图,是要pro AA的。
|
k****m 发帖数: 4670 | 6 这已经不是AA产生的年代
是很多人已经反感
并认为是反歧视的时代 |
b*****o 发帖数: 6080 | 7 对, 主要是有见地的黑裔自己认识到AA未必有什么好。
【在 k****m 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 这已经不是AA产生的年代 : 是很多人已经反感 : 并认为是反歧视的时代
|
c******r 发帖数: 225 | 8 这篇文章春秋笔法,是PRO-209的呀,把mismatch theory用研究者的话说出来了。
Researchers say minority students have benefited in some ways from changes
to affirmative action. In a 2013 paper, a group of economists at Duke
University and the London School of Economics found that "underrepresented
minorities were 4.4 percentage points more likely to graduate" systemwide
after Prop. 209 went into effect, which they attribute in part to the
schools "focusing more resources on the retention of their enrolled students
."
...
把高院的态度抬出来,并且表明race-neutral approaches已经在实施。
Following a Supreme Court ruling last year on how to consider race-conscious
admissions in pursuit of diversity, the Justice Department and Department
of Education provided guidance. A school "should consider whether it can
meet its compelling interest in diversity by using race-neutral approaches,"
the guidance states.
In cases where race is taken into account, it "cannot be given so much
weight that applicants are defined primarily by their race and are largely
accepted or rejected on that basis."
...
最后这一句是点睛之笔,这个文章的态度就是,income-level的diversity已经做得很
好了,毕业率大大提高了,209是非常有效的政策,你干嘛还要开历史倒车。
According to the university, the percentage of first-generation
undergraduate students rose to 42% in 2013 from 34% 10 years earlier. And
more than 40% of the system's undergraduates are from low-income families.
大家看到了吧,主流媒体定调不是一边倒的,WSJ的这篇文章非常好,用H的图正好,比
自己另拿张图另起炉灶好,2/3的行文都在批驳H的说法。这是强有力的武器啊。
【在 x******a 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230473280457
|
k****m 发帖数: 4670 | |