N*******g
发帖数: 287 | 1 just received a paper review invitation from a journal, and find that the
senior author was my college professor (not my advisor but very good friend)
. wondering that shall i accept or decline the invitation b/c of the teacher
-student relation b/w me and the author? |
m**n
发帖数: 9010 | 2 You can choose to decline.
On the other hand, there is no obligation for you to do so.
To be precise, you are the only one who can determine
how close the relation is between you and the author, and
whether it will interfer with your professional opinion.
friend)
teacher
【在 N*******g 的大作中提到】
: just received a paper review invitation from a journal, and find that the
: senior author was my college professor (not my advisor but very good friend)
: . wondering that shall i accept or decline the invitation b/c of the teacher
: -student relation b/w me and the author?
|
s***p
发帖数: 189 | 3 not necessary
as long as you review it in a fair way
doesn't matter
friend)
teacher
【在 N*******g 的大作中提到】
: just received a paper review invitation from a journal, and find that the
: senior author was my college professor (not my advisor but very good friend)
: . wondering that shall i accept or decline the invitation b/c of the teacher
: -student relation b/w me and the author?
|
w***y
发帖数: 1313 | 4 没啥关系吧
我一个同学做过我们一片文章的reviewer
他直接放弃匿名权了:)
friend)
teacher
【在 N*******g 的大作中提到】
: just received a paper review invitation from a journal, and find that the
: senior author was my college professor (not my advisor but very good friend)
: . wondering that shall i accept or decline the invitation b/c of the teacher
: -student relation b/w me and the author?
|
