j******g
发帖数: 1098 | 1 大家能谈谈这几个平价电车的优缺点吗？
BMW i3,
MB B,
Audi A3 Etron,
VW e golf,
Chevy volt,
Ford focus跟cmax,
Nissan Leaf.
这种平价电车需要带一个汽油Range extender吗？ | f********r
发帖数: 3155 | 2 可以看看chevy bolt， 200 miles, 30k
【在 j******g 的大作中提到】
: 大家能谈谈这几个平价电车的优缺点吗？
: BMW i3,
: MB B,
: Audi A3 Etron,
: VW e golf,
: Chevy volt,
: Ford focus跟cmax,
: Nissan Leaf.
: 这种平价电车需要带一个汽油Range extender吗？
| F***Q
发帖数: 6599 | 3
read the reviews first, then narrow down your question to something more
specific
http://www.plugincars.com/cars
【在 j******g 的大作中提到】
: 大家能谈谈这几个平价电车的优缺点吗？
: BMW i3,
: MB B,
: Audi A3 Etron,
: VW e golf,
: Chevy volt,
: Ford focus跟cmax,
: Nissan Leaf.
: 这种平价电车需要带一个汽油Range extender吗？
| j******g
发帖数: 1098 | 4 GM在电车上很牛啊，
查了一下，这个今年年底才上市。
【在 f********r 的大作中提到】
: 可以看看chevy bolt， 200 miles, 30k
| j******g
发帖数: 1098 | 5 我想目前还没有review来对比这些电车的碰撞性能，很多款也没有iihs 碰撞分数。
但是有不少车子是在汽油机款上改出来的，比如a a3 etron，e golf，e focus，可以
查到这些车子汽油机款的iihs分数。
i3只有NCAP的碰撞分数。
不知道大家能对比一下不
【在 F***Q 的大作中提到】
:
: read the reviews first, then narrow down your question to something more
: specific
: http://www.plugincars.com/cars
| c*****z
发帖数: 1211 | 6 开leaf，其实，这类电车，大多数时间是地面道路，开洲际的时间少而又少，所以我倒
是不担心。 | F***Q
发帖数: 6599 | 7
what is your purpose? are you writing a review, or want to decide what your
next ride is going to be?
iihs scores are the last things you need to concern about when purchasing an
EV. Your budget, AER (all electric range), seating capacity, frequency for
road trips, charging requirements and resources, car fun factors, color/
styles, features, all of these are way more important when it comes to
decision making.
The reason is simple, all cars produced today are significantly safer than
cars made 5 years go. If you are comfortable driving an 5-yr (or older) car,
there is no reason for you to concern about the new car in this regards. To
the minimum, sitting on top of a battery is almost certainly magnitude
safer than sitting on top of a big tank filled with flammable fluid.
so, my advice, forget about the collision scores. find the EV that suites
your needs.
【在 j******g 的大作中提到】
: 我想目前还没有review来对比这些电车的碰撞性能，很多款也没有iihs 碰撞分数。
: 但是有不少车子是在汽油机款上改出来的，比如a a3 etron，e golf，e focus，可以
: 查到这些车子汽油机款的iihs分数。
: i3只有NCAP的碰撞分数。
: 不知道大家能对比一下不
| j******g
发帖数: 1098 | 8 单程高速commute 30miles，还是需要关注一下碰撞性能。
【在 c*****z 的大作中提到】
: 开leaf，其实，这类电车，大多数时间是地面道路，开洲际的时间少而又少，所以我倒
: 是不担心。
| j******g
发帖数: 1098 | 9 随便给你举个栗子。
Audi A4 从09到16都是B8平台，16的比09的significantly safer？
your
an
for
car,
To
【在 F***Q 的大作中提到】
:
: what is your purpose? are you writing a review, or want to decide what your
: next ride is going to be?
: iihs scores are the last things you need to concern about when purchasing an
: EV. Your budget, AER (all electric range), seating capacity, frequency for
: road trips, charging requirements and resources, car fun factors, color/
: styles, features, all of these are way more important when it comes to
: decision making.
: The reason is simple, all cars produced today are significantly safer than
: cars made 5 years go. If you are comfortable driving an 5-yr (or older) car,
| F***Q
发帖数: 6599 | 10
same platform != same safety features
even the same car, same MY, different trims and options can also make a
difference in terms of safety.
so the argument on safety is rather poorly defined.
【在 j******g 的大作中提到】
: 随便给你举个栗子。
: Audi A4 从09到16都是B8平台，16的比09的significantly safer？
:
: your
: an
: for
: car,
: To
| p*********e
发帖数: 32207 | 11 事实就是MY16的A4相对MY09的，并未significantly safer
而且5年前很多车的IIHS形变成绩比同级别今年新车表现还好
【在 F***Q 的大作中提到】
:
: same platform != same safety features
: even the same car, same MY, different trims and options can also make a
: difference in terms of safety.
: so the argument on safety is rather poorly defined.
| c*****z
发帖数: 1211 | 12 哦，如果每天六七十迈interstate并且保持时速70+的话，leaf之类纯电可能不太合适。
【在 j******g 的大作中提到】
: 单程高速commute 30miles，还是需要关注一下碰撞性能。
| F***Q
发帖数: 6599 | 13
this may be true, but my point stands - collision scores are not the most
important factors when considering an EV.
buying a newer model will almost always be better in terms of safety (IIHS
scores may not reflect all the improvements because of its quantized nature)
, especially given increasing federal mandates.
【在 p*********e 的大作中提到】
: 事实就是MY16的A4相对MY09的，并未significantly safer
: 而且5年前很多车的IIHS形变成绩比同级别今年新车表现还好
| F***Q
发帖数: 6599 | 14
Gen 1 Chevy Volt has been on the IIHS TSP list for all model years (2011-
2015, 2014 as TSP+). I am sure Gen 2 volt will be on the list once tested.
Nissan Leaf also made to the list for 2011-2013 MYs.
http://www.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/TSP-List/2015
Not listed, but Tesla Mode S is known for its safety.
also checkout this
http://www.hybridcars.com/young-woman-in-chevy-volt-survives-se
【在 j******g 的大作中提到】
: 我想目前还没有review来对比这些电车的碰撞性能，很多款也没有iihs 碰撞分数。
: 但是有不少车子是在汽油机款上改出来的，比如a a3 etron，e golf，e focus，可以
: 查到这些车子汽油机款的iihs分数。
: i3只有NCAP的碰撞分数。
: 不知道大家能对比一下不
|
|
