a*****i
发帖数: 4391 | 1 '2001: A Space Odyssey' is THE most overratted films of all time. Kubrick and
Clarke are trying to express something meaningful, but ultimately is turns
self-indulgent and stupid. Trying to express something meaningful doesn't make
it meaningful, although many people have been tricked or think there is
something profound in this 2 1/2 hour farce. 'Space Odyssey' can be divided
into three parts; the monkey sequence, the middle, the Hal sequence, and the
Odyssey. The monkey sequence is probably be |
a*****i
发帖数: 4391 | 2 Yeah, this and that never-ending scene of the ship floating in space,
never-ending scene of guy running in the hamster round, (exercising)
this is a movie at its worst. Steven Segul's movie has more entertaining values.
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: '2001: A Space Odyssey' is THE most overratted films of all time. Kubrick and
: Clarke are trying to express something meaningful, but ultimately is turns
: self-indulgent and stupid. Trying to express something meaningful doesn't make
: it meaningful, although many people have been tricked or think there is
: something profound in this 2 1/2 hour farce. 'Space Odyssey' can be divided
: into three parts; the monkey sequence, the middle, the Hal sequence, and the
: Odyssey. The monkey sequence is probably be
|
b****n
发帖数: 865 | 3 你写的么？如此宏文，很了不起啊。
不过坚决不同意结论。
and
make
day
thinking
somewhere.
this
what
trying
'theories'
do
heads.
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: Yeah, this and that never-ending scene of the ship floating in space,
: never-ending scene of guy running in the hamster round, (exercising)
: this is a movie at its worst. Steven Segul's movie has more entertaining values.
|
b********t
发帖数: 992 | 4 不喜欢还能洋洋不绝，
and
make
day
thinking
somewhere.
this
what
trying
'theories'
do
heads.
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: Yeah, this and that never-ending scene of the ship floating in space,
: never-ending scene of guy running in the hamster round, (exercising)
: this is a movie at its worst. Steven Segul's movie has more entertaining values.
|
a*****i
发帖数: 4391 | 5 No. hoho.
Why would I bother to write something about a thing I dont like? @@
【在 b****n 的大作中提到】
: 你写的么？如此宏文，很了不起啊。
: 不过坚决不同意结论。
:
: and
: make
: day
: thinking
: somewhere.
: this
: what
|
b****n
发帖数: 865 | 6 Well, SOME guy obviously did.
Kubrick
turns
doesn't
divided
the
live
One
any
nothing
the
this
from
ask,
Odyssey',
seems
It
to
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: No. hoho.
: Why would I bother to write something about a thing I dont like? @@
|
b********t
发帖数: 992 | 7 嘿嘿，这个观点和俺的一样，俺不喜欢的东西看到标题统统跳过
Kubrick
turns
doesn't
divided
the
live
One
any
nothing
the
this
from
ask,
Odyssey',
seems
It
to
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: No. hoho.
: Why would I bother to write something about a thing I dont like? @@
|
b****n
发帖数: 865 | 8 搞了半天，还是不知道你是哪一头的。
is
and
of
Clarke
【在 b********t 的大作中提到】
: 嘿嘿，这个观点和俺的一样，俺不喜欢的东西看到标题统统跳过
:
: Kubrick
: turns
: doesn't
: divided
: the
: live
: One
: any
|
R****e
发帖数: 878 | 9 这东西看着很像imbd的user comment， 我猜他写完了这些接着就去影院来了个"Scorpion
King"和"Sweetest thing"的double dose，爽的不行。
and
make
day
thinking
somewhere.
this
what
trying
'theories'
do
heads.
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: No. hoho.
: Why would I bother to write something about a thing I dont like? @@
|
b********t
发帖数: 992 | 10 WHY？仅仅因为他/她不喜欢，电影这个玩意是很个人化口味的东西，就和欣赏音乐/油画
一样，同一个作品，有人欣赏的不得了，而不喜欢觉得无聊的人未必就是完全不懂得艺术
我猜他写完了这些接着就去影院来了个"Scorpion
divided
the
any
nothing
this
seems
to
【在 R****e 的大作中提到】
: 这东西看着很像imbd的user comment， 我猜他写完了这些接着就去影院来了个"Scorpion
: King"和"Sweetest thing"的double dose，爽的不行。
:
: and
: make
: day
: thinking
: somewhere.
: this
: what
|
b****n
发帖数: 865 | 11 确实象。
建议要看反驳的也去imdb,肯定少不了。
另外，听到很多评论说2001是一定要在剧院里看的电影。
我猜他写完了这些接着就去影院来了个"Scorpion
divided
the
any
nothing
this
seems
to
【在 R****e 的大作中提到】
: 这东西看着很像imbd的user comment， 我猜他写完了这些接着就去影院来了个"Scorpion
: King"和"Sweetest thing"的double dose，爽的不行。
:
: and
: make
: day
: thinking
: somewhere.
: this
: what
|
R****e
发帖数: 878 | 12 true. 但是电影音乐的确也有好坏之分，否则就没有讨论的必要了。这个评论的效果就和
"2001 sucks"这一句话的效果一样，啥也没说出来。不喜欢一部电影一般有两种原因：没
看明白，感觉被愚弄；看明白了，不喜欢。这个作者属于前者。当然喜欢也有可能没看明
白。电影我不敢说，反正音乐我是不指望某些人能理解某些音乐的。
画
术
Kubrick
turns
doesn't
live
One
the
from
ask,
Odyssey',
It
【在 b********t 的大作中提到】
: WHY？仅仅因为他/她不喜欢，电影这个玩意是很个人化口味的东西，就和欣赏音乐/油画
: 一样，同一个作品，有人欣赏的不得了，而不喜欢觉得无聊的人未必就是完全不懂得艺术
:
: 我猜他写完了这些接着就去影院来了个"Scorpion
: divided
: the
: any
: nothing
: this
: seems
|
