t***u
发帖数: 230 | 1 这回看的是2002年的director's cut，足足的3个小时，怎一个爽字了得!想知道这一个小
时到底加了什么？散场的时候听很多人说更喜欢original version,
可是我对这个director's cut已经喜欢的不得了了。
意大利的电影真是感情饱满啊！好东东。 | R****e
发帖数: 878 | 2 我还没看过DC版。听说结尾有点多余. 不过据我以前看的几个director's cut，"Leon",
"big blue", "almost famous"什么的，有些情节是挺拖沓的。尤其big blue, 太冗长了
。
小
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: 这回看的是2002年的director's cut，足足的3个小时，怎一个爽字了得!想知道这一个小
: 时到底加了什么？散场的时候听很多人说更喜欢original version,
: 可是我对这个director's cut已经喜欢的不得了了。
: 意大利的电影真是感情饱满啊！好东东。
| b********t
发帖数: 992 | 3 can't agree more, director's cut sometimes is boring
cut，"Leon",
了
个
【在 R****e 的大作中提到】
: 我还没看过DC版。听说结尾有点多余. 不过据我以前看的几个director's cut，"Leon",
: "big blue", "almost famous"什么的，有些情节是挺拖沓的。尤其big blue, 太冗长了
: 。
:
: 小
| z***f
发帖数: 1182 | 4 I like the first part of this movie
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: 这回看的是2002年的director's cut，足足的3个小时，怎一个爽字了得!想知道这一个小
: 时到底加了什么？散场的时候听很多人说更喜欢original version,
: 可是我对这个director's cut已经喜欢的不得了了。
: 意大利的电影真是感情饱满啊！好东东。
| t***u
发帖数: 230 | 5 En, I agree. The latter part about finding his old lover seems quite
redundant and strays from the mellow sentimental feelings of the first
part. That must be the extra one hour of the director's cut.
Xixi, I suspect there's a personal reason for the director. Especially
with his other movie Melena. Who can 8g?
【在 z***f 的大作中提到】
: I like the first part of this movie
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 6 恩?i've seen malena, but didn't see cinema paradiso dir's cut. you
think the dir had a crush on a woman when he was young?
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: En, I agree. The latter part about finding his old lover seems quite
: redundant and strays from the mellow sentimental feelings of the first
: part. That must be the extra one hour of the director's cut.
: Xixi, I suspect there's a personal reason for the director. Especially
: with his other movie Melena. Who can 8g?
| R****e
发帖数: 878 | 7 如果Melena有Director's Cut, 一定得找来看，hehe.
一个小
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: En, I agree. The latter part about finding his old lover seems quite
: redundant and strays from the mellow sentimental feelings of the first
: part. That must be the extra one hour of the director's cut.
: Xixi, I suspect there's a personal reason for the director. Especially
: with his other movie Melena. Who can 8g?
| g*****s
发帖数: 157 | 8 The original Cinema Paradiso leaves me wanting for more, as it does
feel like have a hole. But the Director's cut makes me think that I'd
rather not know what's going on, and knowing the stories behind actually
reveals the shorcomings of the original one. that is, the hole is big one.
and, forget about the big blue, one of the most visially nice, artistically
lacking movie produced by Luc Besson. transporting and wasabi being another
two.
【在 R****e 的大作中提到】
: 我还没看过DC版。听说结尾有点多余. 不过据我以前看的几个director's cut，"Leon",
: "big blue", "almost famous"什么的，有些情节是挺拖沓的。尤其big blue, 太冗长了
: 。
:
: 小
| d***e
发帖数: 710 | 9 somehow i feel i can understand the director. you want
to show the audience everything you have, but you just
make them less impressed.
i think a very important part of making a striking piece of work
is the ability to cut out everything that is not absolutely necessary.
If you have too much pity for yourself, u won't capture others'
attention.
【在 g*****s 的大作中提到】
: The original Cinema Paradiso leaves me wanting for more, as it does
: feel like have a hole. But the Director's cut makes me think that I'd
: rather not know what's going on, and knowing the stories behind actually
: reveals the shorcomings of the original one. that is, the hole is big one.
: and, forget about the big blue, one of the most visially nice, artistically
: lacking movie produced by Luc Besson. transporting and wasabi being another
: two.
| t***u
发帖数: 230 | 10 坚决同意，见过很多导演，心一软就超过2个小时了。
Some movies are 3 hours for a reason (say, 轱岭街少年杀人事件）,但太多的时候是
导演太惯着自己了。
But nevertheless, Cinema Paradiso is one impressive movie.
artistically
another
cut，"Leon",
冗长了
【在 d***e 的大作中提到】
: somehow i feel i can understand the director. you want
: to show the audience everything you have, but you just
: make them less impressed.
: i think a very important part of making a striking piece of work
: is the ability to cut out everything that is not absolutely necessary.
: If you have too much pity for yourself, u won't capture others'
: attention.
| g*****s
发帖数: 157 | 11 the original one is one of my favorite.
【在 t***u 的大作中提到】
: 坚决同意，见过很多导演，心一软就超过2个小时了。
: Some movies are 3 hours for a reason (say, 轱岭街少年杀人事件）,但太多的时候是
: 导演太惯着自己了。
: But nevertheless, Cinema Paradiso is one impressive movie.
:
: artistically
: another
: cut，"Leon",
: 冗长了
|
|
