D****N
发帖数: 430 | 1 为什么大家都这么不高兴魔戒得奖呢？我觉得fantasy题材
的电影拍到这个水平很难得，魔戒的小说自从出版以来一直
是英语国家读者的最爱，批评剧情不如批评表现手法，而仅
就表现手法而言，这部电影算是相当成功而忠实的改编了。
拍摄成员几年来辛苦也不是一个“商业化”可以简单否定的。
各种Awards的艺术价值本来就是值得争论的问题，就算它能
代表主流艺术动向吧，我看了一下Academy Awards过去几十年
的Best Picture名单，几乎没有一部sf/fantasy主题的电影，
（最近一部是1956年的Aroundthe World in 80 Days)，相比
之下观众读者和导演们对sci-fi/fantasy的热情简直显得有点
儿奇怪，看来不是观众导演不承认sf作品，而是所谓艺术把它
们拦在门外。 |
a*****i
发帖数: 4391 | 2 no acting er yi.
拿那些奖也是无可厚非的事情了。
【在 D****N 的大作中提到】
: 为什么大家都这么不高兴魔戒得奖呢？我觉得fantasy题材
: 的电影拍到这个水平很难得，魔戒的小说自从出版以来一直
: 是英语国家读者的最爱，批评剧情不如批评表现手法，而仅
: 就表现手法而言，这部电影算是相当成功而忠实的改编了。
: 拍摄成员几年来辛苦也不是一个“商业化”可以简单否定的。
: 各种Awards的艺术价值本来就是值得争论的问题，就算它能
: 代表主流艺术动向吧，我看了一下Academy Awards过去几十年
: 的Best Picture名单，几乎没有一部sf/fantasy主题的电影，
: （最近一部是1956年的Aroundthe World in 80 Days)，相比
: 之下观众读者和导演们对sci-fi/fantasy的热情简直显得有点
|
s***l
发帖数: 2236 | 3 关键是什么奖都给它了，不得不怀疑有问题。
【在 D****N 的大作中提到】
: 为什么大家都这么不高兴魔戒得奖呢？我觉得fantasy题材
: 的电影拍到这个水平很难得，魔戒的小说自从出版以来一直
: 是英语国家读者的最爱，批评剧情不如批评表现手法，而仅
: 就表现手法而言，这部电影算是相当成功而忠实的改编了。
: 拍摄成员几年来辛苦也不是一个“商业化”可以简单否定的。
: 各种Awards的艺术价值本来就是值得争论的问题，就算它能
: 代表主流艺术动向吧，我看了一下Academy Awards过去几十年
: 的Best Picture名单，几乎没有一部sf/fantasy主题的电影，
: （最近一部是1956年的Aroundthe World in 80 Days)，相比
: 之下观众读者和导演们对sci-fi/fantasy的热情简直显得有点
|
R*s
发帖数: 2041 | 4 谁谁谁说得对，应该分几项给前两年，没必要全压在今年，
害得其他今年出来的片子全跟着倒霉。
事实上今年这一锅端实质上也不是award 最后一集， 而是award
了全部三集的work. 某种意义上说对其他片子不公平。
【在 D****N 的大作中提到】
: 为什么大家都这么不高兴魔戒得奖呢？我觉得fantasy题材
: 的电影拍到这个水平很难得，魔戒的小说自从出版以来一直
: 是英语国家读者的最爱，批评剧情不如批评表现手法，而仅
: 就表现手法而言，这部电影算是相当成功而忠实的改编了。
: 拍摄成员几年来辛苦也不是一个“商业化”可以简单否定的。
: 各种Awards的艺术价值本来就是值得争论的问题，就算它能
: 代表主流艺术动向吧，我看了一下Academy Awards过去几十年
: 的Best Picture名单，几乎没有一部sf/fantasy主题的电影，
: （最近一部是1956年的Aroundthe World in 80 Days)，相比
: 之下观众读者和导演们对sci-fi/fantasy的热情简直显得有点
|
k*********r
发帖数: 758 | 5 我支持你, 磨戒实在是拍的太好了太好了
他们那是嫉妒, 哈哈
【在 D****N 的大作中提到】
: 为什么大家都这么不高兴魔戒得奖呢？我觉得fantasy题材
: 的电影拍到这个水平很难得，魔戒的小说自从出版以来一直
: 是英语国家读者的最爱，批评剧情不如批评表现手法，而仅
: 就表现手法而言，这部电影算是相当成功而忠实的改编了。
: 拍摄成员几年来辛苦也不是一个“商业化”可以简单否定的。
: 各种Awards的艺术价值本来就是值得争论的问题，就算它能
: 代表主流艺术动向吧，我看了一下Academy Awards过去几十年
: 的Best Picture名单，几乎没有一部sf/fantasy主题的电影，
: （最近一部是1956年的Aroundthe World in 80 Days)，相比
: 之下观众读者和导演们对sci-fi/fantasy的热情简直显得有点
|
i**x
发帖数: 326 | 6 spt~~~~~
btw, just realized that i can post in this
club. ft
【在 k*********r 的大作中提到】
: 我支持你, 磨戒实在是拍的太好了太好了
: 他们那是嫉妒, 哈哈
|
g*******a
发帖数: 1383 | 7 it's like hiring jin yong as a prof in BJ Uni
i can't stand that kind of "one dude kill 'em all"
movies, why didn't they just give oscore to some
super heros like rambo or die hard or tru lies
【在 D****N 的大作中提到】
: 为什么大家都这么不高兴魔戒得奖呢？我觉得fantasy题材
: 的电影拍到这个水平很难得，魔戒的小说自从出版以来一直
: 是英语国家读者的最爱，批评剧情不如批评表现手法，而仅
: 就表现手法而言，这部电影算是相当成功而忠实的改编了。
: 拍摄成员几年来辛苦也不是一个“商业化”可以简单否定的。
: 各种Awards的艺术价值本来就是值得争论的问题，就算它能
: 代表主流艺术动向吧，我看了一下Academy Awards过去几十年
: 的Best Picture名单，几乎没有一部sf/fantasy主题的电影，
: （最近一部是1956年的Aroundthe World in 80 Days)，相比
: 之下观众读者和导演们对sci-fi/fantasy的热情简直显得有点
|
k*********r
发帖数: 758 | 8 did city of god win anything？
did triplettes of belleville win anything?
【在 g*******a 的大作中提到】
: it's like hiring jin yong as a prof in BJ Uni
: i can't stand that kind of "one dude kill 'em all"
: movies, why didn't they just give oscore to some
: super heros like rambo or die hard or tru lies
|
k*********r
发帖数: 758 | 9 it's a shame that triplettes got nominated along with finding
nemo and didn't win. this is so insulting.
i'd have less complaints if it didn't
getnominated at all.
i saw finding nemo and it was cute. but that's about it.
the triplettes is different. very different.
【在 k*********r 的大作中提到】
: did city of god win anything？
: did triplettes of belleville win anything?
|
g*******a
发帖数: 1383 | 10 it's a shame that music from triplettes didn't beat ring for
orginal music score! nemo, nemo is 100 times better than that
fat ass jackson's crap. it's so phony almost made me puke.
【在 k*********r 的大作中提到】
: it's a shame that triplettes got nominated along with finding
: nemo and didn't win. this is so insulting.
: i'd have less complaints if it didn't
: getnominated at all.
: i saw finding nemo and it was cute. but that's about it.
: the triplettes is different. very different.
|
|
|
a*****i
发帖数: 4391 | 11 I dunno, what is so "phony" about LOTR?
And don't you think "I love movies that only a few had seen" is such
小资 attitude?
【在 g*******a 的大作中提到】
: it's a shame that music from triplettes didn't beat ring for
: orginal music score! nemo, nemo is 100 times better than that
: fat ass jackson's crap. it's so phony almost made me puke.
|
a*****e
发帖数: 1700 | 12 I was utterly disppointed by this too.
Maybe you go and file a petition, we'll all sign ;-)
【在 g*******a 的大作中提到】
: it's a shame that music from triplettes didn't beat ring for
: orginal music score! nemo, nemo is 100 times better than that
: fat ass jackson's crap. it's so phony almost made me puke.
|
g*******a
发帖数: 1383 | 13 when they put up fake emotions like that...i call it phony
like when the fatboy carrying his master w/ that determined
look on his face, that just reminded me our old commie movies.
i suggest we send hero wang cheng to oscar maybe he'll bring
back one or two little statues.
ring is not a bad movie, but i doubt people really vote it
in for its acomplishment. more or less it's rewarding the
hardwork they put into it - and that's wrong. hardwork shouldn't
be a factor for anything.
i love movies w/
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: I dunno, what is so "phony" about LOTR?
: And don't you think "I love movies that only a few had seen" is such
: 小资 attitude?
|
a********o
发帖数: 585 | 14 First, LOTR is great. Good movie, interesting to watch!
But it only represents one kinda of film genre and it is almost pure for
entertaining.
It is great but the pity is the lack of diversity and almost emptiness of
anything related to real humane and society stuff is really a shame on the
academy.
So the result of its dominance is ...... Boring.
【在 a*****i 的大作中提到】
: I dunno, what is so "phony" about LOTR?
: And don't you think "I love movies that only a few had seen" is such
: 小资 attitude?
|
s***l
发帖数: 2236 | 15 aglee.
i like the fighting scence in LOTR but always feel sick about any part
that is related to Frodo.
【在 g*******a 的大作中提到】
: when they put up fake emotions like that...i call it phony
: like when the fatboy carrying his master w/ that determined
: look on his face, that just reminded me our old commie movies.
: i suggest we send hero wang cheng to oscar maybe he'll bring
: back one or two little statues.
: ring is not a bad movie, but i doubt people really vote it
: in for its acomplishment. more or less it's rewarding the
: hardwork they put into it - and that's wrong. hardwork shouldn't
: be a factor for anything.
: i love movies w/
|
t****t
发帖数: 530 | 16 Me 2 me 2
【在 s***l 的大作中提到】
: aglee.
: i like the fighting scence in LOTR but always feel sick about any part
: that is related to Frodo.
|
