e******e
发帖数: 2530 | 1 理由如下：
#1:
The wage offer range listed in the SWA job order, $XX,000-YY,000 per year,
is less than the wage offered the foreign worker, $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year,
as listed on the ETA form 9089.
#2:
The notice of fililng for the Application for Permanent Employment
Certification submitted by the employer contains a wage, $XX,000-$YY,000 per
year, which is lower than the offered wage of $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year
listed in item G.1 of the ETA form 9089.
律师的说辞是typo，我这个case被audit过，当时没问工资不符合的问题，最后拿这个
理由把我拒了。律师说Department of Labor也有责任。
律师建议不要appeal，说会花很长时间，建议重新申请。但是如果重新申请的话，我之
前的PD就作废了，而且律师还会收我律师费，虽然不是全价（5k的perm 律师费都已经
交了），但是说给50%的discount
，但是我们公司管这个的人和我都觉得这个很不合理啊，明明是律师把工资填错了，造
成case被拒，重新申请居然还要我们掏钱。
请问各位，我这样的case appeal会有可能成功吗？30天内必须要做决定，急啊。多谢
大家了。 | i******t
发帖数: 11048 | 2 typo是不会申辩成功的。
,
per
【在 e******e 的大作中提到】
: 理由如下：
: #1:
: The wage offer range listed in the SWA job order, $XX,000-YY,000 per year,
: is less than the wage offered the foreign worker, $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year,
: as listed on the ETA form 9089.
: #2:
: The notice of fililng for the Application for Permanent Employment
: Certification submitted by the employer contains a wage, $XX,000-$YY,000 per
: year, which is lower than the offered wage of $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year
: listed in item G.1 of the ETA form 9089.
| e******e
发帖数: 2530 | 3 typo我觉得是律师的说辞，根本就是律师的mistake，这种东西也能搞错。
这样我的case还有希望吗？
【在 i******t 的大作中提到】
: typo是不会申辩成功的。
:
: ,
: per
| c**2
发帖数: 8496 | 4 if your offered wage range is outside of the ad wage range, or any of the
two ranges above is lower than PWD, then DOL had made a correct decision.
And usually you(or a single position) put one exact number in your offer
wage, not a range. Range would be useful if there are multiple positions of
the same title/duties for this company. | e******e
发帖数: 2530 | 5 Thanks a lot.
If I have to apply PERM again, do I need to obtain another Prevailing Wage
Request?
of
【在 c**2 的大作中提到】
: if your offered wage range is outside of the ad wage range, or any of the
: two ranges above is lower than PWD, then DOL had made a correct decision.
: And usually you(or a single position) put one exact number in your offer
: wage, not a range. Range would be useful if there are multiple positions of
: the same title/duties for this company.
| m*******t
发帖数: 1359 | | s********9
发帖数: 586 | 7 我们公司有个人比你还惨， 他那时候perm被audit了两年，然后被拒，也是因为律师的
原因
后来律师就给他file了一份新的申请，同时appeal旧的case。后来他的新的很快下来了
，appeal那个也迟迟没消息
你问问律师看能不能同时进行
还有你的情况明明是律师的责任，让公司出面说一下，律师还要再收费简直太无耻了
,
per
【在 e******e 的大作中提到】
: 理由如下：
: #1:
: The wage offer range listed in the SWA job order, $XX,000-YY,000 per year,
: is less than the wage offered the foreign worker, $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year,
: as listed on the ETA form 9089.
: #2:
: The notice of fililng for the Application for Permanent Employment
: Certification submitted by the employer contains a wage, $XX,000-$YY,000 per
: year, which is lower than the offered wage of $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year
: listed in item G.1 of the ETA form 9089.
| e******e
发帖数: 2530 | 8 据信里面有一句。
A new application in the same occupation for the same alien cannot be filed
while a request for review is pending with the Board of Alien Labor
Certification Appeals.
这个意思看来，如果新的申请和appeal同时搞，需要换position啊。
【在 s********9 的大作中提到】
: 我们公司有个人比你还惨， 他那时候perm被audit了两年，然后被拒，也是因为律师的
: 原因
: 后来律师就给他file了一份新的申请，同时appeal旧的case。后来他的新的很快下来了
: ，appeal那个也迟迟没消息
: 你问问律师看能不能同时进行
: 还有你的情况明明是律师的责任，让公司出面说一下，律师还要再收费简直太无耻了
:
: ,
: per
| d********g
发帖数: 10550 | 9 我的PERM有13条理由被拒，我已经淡定了
,
per
【在 e******e 的大作中提到】
: 理由如下：
: #1:
: The wage offer range listed in the SWA job order, $XX,000-YY,000 per year,
: is less than the wage offered the foreign worker, $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year,
: as listed on the ETA form 9089.
: #2:
: The notice of fililng for the Application for Permanent Employment
: Certification submitted by the employer contains a wage, $XX,000-$YY,000 per
: year, which is lower than the offered wage of $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year
: listed in item G.1 of the ETA form 9089.
| e******e
发帖数: 2530 | 10 同cft
那最后你办成了吗？
【在 d********g 的大作中提到】
: 我的PERM有13条理由被拒，我已经淡定了
:
: ,
: per
| | | j*******e
发帖数: 1058 | | S***P
发帖数: 335 | 12 能不能说下是哪家律师公司, 不方便的话,站内信.
,
per
【在 e******e 的大作中提到】
: 理由如下：
: #1:
: The wage offer range listed in the SWA job order, $XX,000-YY,000 per year,
: is less than the wage offered the foreign worker, $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year,
: as listed on the ETA form 9089.
: #2:
: The notice of fililng for the Application for Permanent Employment
: Certification submitted by the employer contains a wage, $XX,000-$YY,000 per
: year, which is lower than the offered wage of $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year
: listed in item G.1 of the ETA form 9089.
| d********g
发帖数: 10550 | 13 显然，能办得成吗
【在 e******e 的大作中提到】
: 同cft
: 那最后你办成了吗？
| c***y
发帖数: 194 | 14 please clarity the relationship of these wages:
A: PWD
B: my actual wage
C: min wage on notice of filing and job order
D: max wage on notice of filing and job order
of
【在 c**2 的大作中提到】
: if your offered wage range is outside of the ad wage range, or any of the
: two ranges above is lower than PWD, then DOL had made a correct decision.
: And usually you(or a single position) put one exact number in your offer
: wage, not a range. Range would be useful if there are multiple positions of
: the same title/duties for this company.
| T**G
发帖数: 367 | 15 Company use ranges for various reasons, and it's been done often, not just
for multiple positions.
If B>=A, post range (B, D), else post (A, D). Of course, if the latter,
company will need to resolve the wage issue, commit to wage A when you
obtain the LPR status.
You should be consistent about the wage: in the SWA (if required), in the
notice of filing, and in the ETA9089. If you choose to use a range, then let
all three above mentioned be the same range.
【在 c***y 的大作中提到】
: please clarity the relationship of these wages:
: A: PWD
: B: my actual wage
: C: min wage on notice of filing and job order
: D: max wage on notice of filing and job order
:
: of
| c***y
发帖数: 194 | 16 sorry, I am confused about the first part.
if B>=A, can I post (B,D)?
if B
let
【在 T**G 的大作中提到】
: Company use ranges for various reasons, and it's been done often, not just
: for multiple positions.
: If B>=A, post range (B, D), else post (A, D). Of course, if the latter,
: company will need to resolve the wage issue, commit to wage A when you
: obtain the LPR status.
: You should be consistent about the wage: in the SWA (if required), in the
: notice of filing, and in the ETA9089. If you choose to use a range, then let
: all three above mentioned be the same range.
| T**G
发帖数: 367 | 17 Apologies! My typo. If B>=A, post (B, D).
Example:
PW is 50,000
Current Salary is 40,000.
Company's range for the position is 35,000 to 60,000.
Posting Range: 50,000 to 60,000, company needs to commit to 50k when you
receive the greencard.
Or, if current salary is 53,000
Posting Range: 53,000 to 60,000.
【在 c***y 的大作中提到】
: sorry, I am confused about the first part.
: if B>=A, can I post (B,D)?
: if B:
: let
| d*******p
发帖数: 2525 | 18 I have never seen an actual job ad that didn't have range on salaries unless
it's entry level job.
the reason: depends on applicant's experience, you need offer different
salary even if it's same position | y***m
发帖数: 7027 | 19 实例，太有用了，包子奉上，版主该m.
建议大家多分享 denied 案例.
,
per
【在 e******e 的大作中提到】
: 理由如下：
: #1:
: The wage offer range listed in the SWA job order, $XX,000-YY,000 per year,
: is less than the wage offered the foreign worker, $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year,
: as listed on the ETA form 9089.
: #2:
: The notice of fililng for the Application for Permanent Employment
: Certification submitted by the employer contains a wage, $XX,000-$YY,000 per
: year, which is lower than the offered wage of $ZZ,000-$AA,000 per year
: listed in item G.1 of the ETA form 9089.
|
|
